How much thulium is there?
And how much of that can we reach?
Thulium makes up about 0.5 parts per million of the crust by mass, by USGS data. With lutetium, it is the least common of the rare earths that occur in nature. USGS gives no reserve for thulium alone. All rare earths together have reserves of over 75 million tonnes of oxide.
Last updated 14 October 2026.
In nature
Wolfram ElementData gives 0.000045% of the crust by mass, or 0.45 parts per million (ppm)1. USGS gives 0.52 ppm, after Lide (2004)3. The EU gives somewhat less than 0.3 ppm for thulium and lutetium in the upper crust4. The values come from different compilations, so they do not agree exactly.
In a yearbook, USGS gives 0.5 ppm for thulium and lutetium, and calls them the least abundant of the lanthanides. USGS also says that the crust has more of them than of antimony, bismuth, cadmium and thallium5. For thallium, this comparison does not fit other data. Wolfram gives 0.54 ppm for thallium, more than its 0.45 ppm for thulium6. Britannica says that thulium is about as common as antimony and iodine7.
Thulium is never found as a metal in nature. It is a minor part of rare earth minerals and clays (see the geology chapter). Nuclear fission also makes small amounts7.
The mean concentration in seawater is about 0.20 nanograms per kilogram2. For the universe, Wolfram gives 1×10⁻⁸% by mass1.
All natural thulium is one stable isotope, thulium-1698. For its radioactive isotope thulium-170, see the uses chapter.
Reserves and resources
USGS gives no reserve for thulium. For all rare earths together, it gives reserves of more than 75 million tonnes of rare earth oxide. Of this, China has 44 million tonnes9.
The EU counts thulium with holmium, lutetium and ytterbium. Together, these four are about 0.6% of all rare earth oxide produced4. Thulium alone is a smaller share (see the production chapter). So we do not estimate a reserve for thulium from the reserve of all rare earths.
Limits to supply
The amount in the rock does not limit the supply of thulium. Mines produce it with the other rare earths, and it is a very small part of each ore. USGS says that rare earths are fairly common in the crust, but that concentrations worth mining are less common10. The supply of thulium depends on how much ore the mines treat, and on the plants that separate it. By the EU count, all of this separation is in China (see the power chapter).
Sources
- 1
Theodore Gray, periodictable.com (data from Wolfram ElementData), 2026. Technical data for Thulium (from Wolfram ElementData) , Abundances.
Abundance in the universe and the crust, as mass fractions. It gives no value for the human body.
-
% in Universe 1×10⁻⁸%
-
% in Earth's Crust 0.000045%
-
% in Earth’s Crust 0.000045%
-
- 2
Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute (MBARI), 2026. Periodic Table of Elements in the Ocean: Summary Table , Row 69, Tm.
Mean ocean concentration of thulium, 0.20 ng/kg (1.2 pmol/kg). A compiled value.
-
69 Tm 2.00E-01 168.9342 1.18E-03 1.2 pmol/kg
-
- 3
U.S. Geological Survey (Bradley S. Van Gosen, Philip L. Verplanck, Robert R. Seal II, Keith R. Long and Joseph Gambogi), 2017. Rare-earth elements, chapter O of Critical mineral resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802-O) , Table O1 (crustal abundance); Introduction (deposit types); Sources and production (China).
Crustal abundance of thulium after Lide (2004), and ion-adsorption clays as the main source of the heavy rare earths.
-
Thulium Tm 69 168.93 0.52
-
- 4
European Commission (G.A. Blengini and others), 2020. Study on the EU's list of Critical Raw Materials (2020): Factsheets on Critical Raw Materials , Chapter 21, rare earth elements: sections 21.1, 21.1.1, 21.2 (uses), 21.3 (supply, Table 176), 21.4 (prices), 21.5 (recycling).
Thulium as a heavy rare earth with niche uses, its crustal abundance, its uses, a demand forecast, EU use and trade, prices, recycling, and a rough estimate of world output of holmium, thulium, lutetium and ytterbium oxides together.
-
somewhat less than 0.3 ppm for Tm and Lu, the rarest of the REE (Weng et al. 2015)
-
Ho, Tm, Lu, … 660 0.6
-
- 5
U.S. Geological Survey (Joseph Gambogi and Daniel J. Cordier), 2012. Rare Earths, in 2010 Minerals Yearbook , Text (crustal abundance); Table 2 (rare earth contents of major ores); Table 3 (rare earth oxide prices, 2010, from Rhodia).
Crustal abundance of thulium, the thulium content of the main rare earth ores, and the 2010 list price of thulium oxide.
-
Thulium and lutetium, the least abundant of the lanthanides at 0.5 ppm, occur in the Earth’s crust in higher concentrations than antimony, bismuth, cadmium, and thallium
-
- 6
Theodore Gray, periodictable.com (data from Wolfram ElementData), 2026. Technical data for Thallium (from Wolfram ElementData) , Abundances.
Abundance of thallium in the crust, for comparison with thulium.
-
% in Earth’s Crust 0.000054%
-
- 7
Britannica Editors, Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2026. thulium .
Properties, discovery, name, minerals, isotopes, abundance, production and uses. Read with Firecrawl; the site refused a script.
-
Its abundance in Earth’s crust is nearly the same as those of antimony and iodine
-
and in products of nuclear fission
-
- 8
Commission on Isotopic Abundances and Atomic Weights (IUPAC), 2026. Thulium .
The one stable isotope of thulium, the origin of its name, its discovery in 1879 and its first isolation in 1911.
-
Thulium is a monoisotopic element and its atomic weight is determined solely by its isotope 169Tm.
-
- 9
U.S. Geological Survey (Shelby N. Johnston), 2026. Rare Earths, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Pp. 152-153: events, trends and issues; world mine production and reserves.
World rare earth output and reserves in 2025, and China's export controls of October 2025 and their suspension.
-
China … 44,000,000
-
World total (rounded) … >75,000,000
-
- 10
U.S. Geological Survey (Shelby N. Johnston), 2026. Rare earths (heavy), in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Both pages of the chapter: domestic production and use, salient statistics, recycling, import sources, events, world resources, substitutes.
The heavy rare earths as a group, their uses, US net import reliance, recycling, China's export controls of 2025 and substitutes. The chapter gives no price and no import source for thulium.
-
Rare earths are relatively abundant in the Earth’s crust, but minable concentrations are less common than for most other mineral commodities
-