History of thulium
How did our relationship with it begin and change?
Per Teodor Cleve found thulium in Sweden in 1879 and named it after Thule, a name for Scandinavia. For decades it had almost no use. Thulium-170 was proposed for X-ray sources in the 1950s, and lasers came later. The US approved the thulium fiber laser for kidney stones in 2019.
Last updated 11 November 2026.
Discovery and name
In 1879, Per Teodor Cleve at the University of Uppsala, Sweden, separated thulium as its oxide1. He found it in a sample of an erbium mineral2. Britannica says that he found holmium in the same year3.
Cleve named the oxide after Thule, an ancient name for Scandinavia32. The RSC podcast quotes his proposal. He first spelled the name with two letters l1.
CIAAW says that the American chemist Charles James first isolated thulium, in 19112. The Science History Institute says that James needed 15,000 fractional crystallizations to get pure thulium4. The RSC gives the 15,000 recrystallizations to another American chemist, Theodore William Richards1. We follow CIAAW and the Science History Institute, which both name James.
How our use changed
For a long time, thulium had almost no use. Brian Clegg says, in an RSC podcast, that other elements could do all that thulium did, better and at a lower cost1.
Clegg says that thulium-170 was first proposed as a portable source of X-rays in the 1950s. Since then, small devices such as dental X-ray units have used it1.
Thulium lasers came later. The thulium fiber laser for kidney stones was first available from one Russian maker, for use in Russia5. The US FDA approved it in 2019, and it received the CE mark in Europe in 20205.
In 2011, UNEP still said that thulium had no significant uses6. For later views, see the uses chapter. Thulium is on the US lists of critical minerals of 2022 and 202578. The EU and the UK list it as critical as part of a group of rare earths (see the power chapter).
On 9 October 2025, China announced export controls on thulium and four other rare earths910. On 7 November, before they started, China suspended them until 10 November 202611. In November 2026, China extended the suspension to 10 January 202712. For the events of the whole group, see the rare earths page.
1800s
1900s
-
1911
Science
The American chemist Charles James is first to isolate thulium, by the account of CIAAW. 2
-
1911
Science
James needs 15,000 fractional crystallizations to get pure thulium, by the account of the Science History Institute. 4
-
c. 1955
Health
In the 1950s, scientists first propose radioactive thulium-170 as a portable source of X-rays. 1
2000s
-
2010
Trade
Rhodia lists thulium oxide at about $1,500 per kg. It is the latest USGS price for thulium that we found. 13
-
2011
Science
A UNEP report on metal recycling says that thulium has no significant uses. 6
-
2013
Law and policy
In a report, the US Department of Defense names thulium among rare earth materials that could be in short supply. 14
-
2019
Health
The US FDA approves the thulium fiber laser, a newer tool for kidney stones. 5
-
2020
Health
The thulium fiber laser receives the CE mark in Europe. 5
-
2020
Science
The EU says that thulium has no real commercial use, but that glass, phosphors and fiber optics have potential. 15
-
2022
Law and policy
Thulium is on the US list of critical minerals of 2022. 7
-
2023
Law and policy
In its criticality study, the EU counts thulium among the heavy rare earths and finds this group critical. 16
-
2024
Law and policy
The EU Critical Raw Materials Act lists the heavy rare earths as critical raw materials. 17
-
2025
Trade
On 9 October, China announces export controls on thulium metal, oxide and compounds, and on four other rare earths, to start on 8 November. 9
-
2025
Trade
On 7 November, before they start, China suspends the October export controls until 10 November 2026. 11
-
2025
Law and policy
Thulium is on the final 2025 US list of critical minerals. 8
-
2026
Trade
On 9 November, China extends the suspension of the October 2025 export controls to 10 January 2027. 12
-
2026
Trade
USGS shows no price change for thulium for 2024 to 2025. It says that there was not enough information on prices. 18
Sources
- 1
Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Thulium - Element information, properties and uses , Sections Uses, Biological role, Natural abundance, History; podcast transcript (Chemistry in its element: thulium, Brian Clegg).
Discovery, name, uses in X-ray sources and lasers, biological role, minerals and production. The podcast gives a rough figure for yearly output without a year or a source.
-
Thulium was first isolated in 1879 as its oxide by Per Teodor Cleve at the University of Uppsala, Sweden
-
I propose the name of thullium derived from Thule, the ancient name of Scandinavia
-
putting two L’s in the name
-
In 1911, the American chemist Theodore William Richards performed 15,000 recrystallisations of thulium bromate
-
For a long time thulium was a Cinderella substance.
-
There was nothing you could do with thulium that couldn’t be done better and cheaper with one of the other elements.
-
It was first suggested for this role in the 1950s and has frequently turned up since in small scale devices, such as those used in dentist’s surgeries
-
It was first suggested for this role in the 1950s
-
- 2
Commission on Isotopic Abundances and Atomic Weights (IUPAC), 2026. Thulium .
The one stable isotope of thulium, the origin of its name, its discovery in 1879 and its first isolation in 1911.
-
It was discovered in 1879 by the Swedish chemist Per Theodor Cleve in a sample of erbium mineral.
-
The name derives from Thule, the earliest name for the northernmost part of the civilized world
-
Thulium was first isolated by the American chemist Charles James in 1911.
-
- 3
Britannica Editors, Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2026. thulium .
Properties, discovery, name, minerals, isotopes, abundance, production and uses. Read with Firecrawl; the site refused a script.
-
Thulium was discovered in 1879, along with holmium, by Per Teodor Cleve
-
who named the oxide thulia after an ancient name for Scandinavia
-
- 4
Michal Meyer, Distillations, Science History Institute, 2016. Industrial Vitamins .
Charles James and the 15,000 fractional crystallizations that gave pure thulium in 1911.
-
In 1911 Charles James reported the isolation of a measurable quantity of pure thulium, but only after 15,000 successive fractional crystallizations of his impure sample
-
- 5
Peter Kronenberg, Bm Zeeshan Hameed and Bhaskar Somani, Current Opinion in Urology 31 (2): 80-86, 2021. Outcomes of thulium fibre laser for treatment of urinary tract stones: results of a systematic review , Abstract; Introduction; Thulium fibre laser machine specifications; Conclusion.
The thulium fiber laser for kidney and urinary stones, its approval in the US and Europe, and how it compares with the holmium laser.
-
until recently only one single Russian manufacturer had this kind of lasers available and approved for clinical use in Russia
-
With the recent FDA approval in 2019 and the European CE mark approval in 2020
-
With the recent FDA approval in 2019
-
the European CE mark approval in 2020
-
- 6
UNEP International Resource Panel (T.E. Graedel et al.), 2011. Recycling Rates of Metals: A Status Report , Appendix table of OSR, RC and EOL-RR by metal (Tm row); Appendix A (uses of the rare earths).
End-of-life recycling rate and recycled content below 1% for thulium; thulium has no significant uses.
-
Tm – Thulium has no significant uses
-
- 7
U.S. Department of Energy, 2023. Notice of Final Determination on 2023 DOE Critical Materials List (preprint) , Summary: critical materials for energy; the USGS list of 2022.
Thulium is not on the DOE list of critical materials for energy. The report repeats the USGS list of 2022, which has thulium.
-
terbium, thulium, tin, titanium
-
- 8
U.S. Geological Survey (Federal Register vol. 90, no. 214), 2025. Final 2025 List of Critical Minerals , The list of 60 critical minerals.
Thulium is on the 2025 US list of critical minerals.
-
tantalum, tellurium, terbium, thulium
-
- 9
Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs of the People's Republic of China, 2025. 商务部 海关总署公告2025年第57号: 公布对部分中重稀土相关物项实施出口管制的决定 (Announcement No. 57 of 2025: export controls on some medium and heavy rare earth items) , Section 3 (1C911, thulium items); last paragraph (start date).
In Chinese. Dated 9 October 2025. Export controls on holmium, erbium, thulium, europium and ytterbium items, the stated reasons, and the start date of 8 November 2025.
-
2025年10月9日
-
1C911 铥相关物项
-
- 10
U.S. Geological Survey (Shelby N. Johnston), 2026. Rare Earths, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Pp. 152-153: events, trends and issues; world mine production and reserves.
World rare earth output and reserves in 2025, and China's export controls of October 2025 and their suspension.
-
In October, China expanded its rare-earths export controls to include europium, holmium, erbium, thulium, and ytterbium
-
- 11
Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs of the People's Republic of China, 2025. 商务部、海关总署公告2025年第70号: 公布暂停实施商务部、海关总署公告2025年第55号、56号、57号、58号及商务部公告2025年第61号、62号的决定 (Announcement No. 70 of 2025: suspension of Announcements No. 55 to 58, 61 and 62) .
In Chinese. Dated 7 November 2025. Suspends the export controls of October 2025, among them No. 57 on thulium, until 10 November 2026.
-
自即日起至2026年11月10日
-
- 12
Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs of the People's Republic of China, 2026. 商务部、海关总署公告2026年第58号: 公布继续暂停实施商务部、海关总署公告2025年第55号、56号、57号、58号及商务部公告2025年第61号、62号的决定 (Announcement No. 58 of 2026: continued suspension of Announcements No. 55 to 58, 61 and 62 of 2025) .
In Chinese. Dated 9 November 2026. Keeps the October 2025 export controls, among them No. 57 on thulium, suspended until 10 January 2027.
-
自2026年11月11日起至2027年1月10日
-
- 13
U.S. Geological Survey (Joseph Gambogi and Daniel J. Cordier), 2012. Rare Earths, in 2010 Minerals Yearbook , Text (crustal abundance); Table 2 (rare earth contents of major ores); Table 3 (rare earth oxide prices, 2010, from Rhodia).
Crustal abundance of thulium, the thulium content of the main rare earth ores, and the 2010 list price of thulium oxide.
-
Thulium 99.90 5 1,500.00
-
- 14
U.S. Geological Survey (Joseph Gambogi), 2016. Rare Earths, in 2013 Minerals Yearbook , Government programs: the Department of Defense stockpile report of 2013.
Thulium among the rare earth materials that the US Department of Defense named as potential shortfall materials.
-
Rare-earth materials that were identified as potential shortfall materials included dysprosium, erbium, scandium, terbium, thulium, yttrium
-
- 15
European Commission (G.A. Blengini and others), 2020. Study on the EU's list of Critical Raw Materials (2020): Factsheets on Critical Raw Materials , Chapter 21, rare earth elements: sections 21.1, 21.1.1, 21.2 (uses), 21.3 (supply, Table 176), 21.4 (prices), 21.5 (recycling).
Thulium as a heavy rare earth with niche uses, its crustal abundance, its uses, a demand forecast, EU use and trade, prices, recycling, and a rough estimate of world output of holmium, thulium, lutetium and ytterbium oxides together.
-
Thulium has no real commercial use; but glass, phosphors and fibre optics have potential.
-
- 16
European Commission (M. Grohol and C. Veeh), 2023. Study on the Critical Raw Materials for the EU 2023: Final Report , Table A, major global supplier countries (row 46, thulium); list of heavy rare earths; table of end uses (thulium row).
China's share of world thulium supply at the processing stage, 2016-2020, thulium as a heavy rare earth, and the end use that the EU assigned to it.
-
heavy rare earths - HREE (dysprosium, erbium, europium, gadolinium, holmium, lutetium, terbium, thulium, ytterbium, yttrium)
-
- 17
European Parliament and Council of the European Union, 2024. Regulation (EU) 2024/1252 establishing a framework for ensuring a secure and sustainable supply of critical raw materials (Critical Raw Materials Act) , Annex I, Section 1 (strategic raw materials); Annex II, Section 1 (critical raw materials).
The adopted lists of strategic and critical raw materials.
-
(q) heavy rare earth elements
-
- 18
U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , PDF p. 13 (trade policy actions); PDF p. 27 (uses of critical minerals, thulium row); notes to Figure 10A (1-year percent change in prices).
China's export controls of October 2025 and their suspension; the main uses of thulium; USGS had not enough price information for thulium.
-
thulium, and uranium are not shown because there was not enough information available regarding prices
-