Where thulium is found

What is it found in, and where on Earth?

Thulium is a minor part of rare earth minerals such as monazite and xenotime, and of ion-adsorption clays. In most ores, it is only a trace. Most heavy rare earths come from clays in southern China. Thulium is always mined with the other rare earths.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Minerals and ores

Thulium has no ore of its own. Britannica names laterite ionic clays, xenotime and euxenite1. The RSC says that thulium comes mainly from monazite, which has about 20 ppm of it2.

In a yearbook, USGS gives the rare earth content of the main ores. In every bastnaesite and monazite in the table, thulium is only a trace. In xenotime from Malaysia and China, it is about 1.1% to 1.3% of the rare earths. In a clay from Longnan, China, it is 0.7%3. So the RSC names monazite as the main source, but the USGS table gives more thulium in xenotime and in the clays.

Thulium is a heavy rare earth. USGS and the EU both put it in this group45.

How deposits form

USGS says that heavy rare earths are less common than light rare earths. They are richer in some ores, such as ion-adsorption clays4. USGS says that the clays are valued for their medium and heavy rare earths6. For how these deposits form, see the rare earths page.

Where the deposits are

USGS says that the ion-adsorption clays of southern China are the main world source of the heavy rare earths6. We found no source that names deposits for their thulium. For China’s share of the reserves, see the abundance chapter.

What it comes with

Thulium always comes with the other rare earths. In 1879, Cleve found it in a sample of an erbium mineral (see the history chapter). Plants must separate it from its chemically similar neighbors, erbium and ytterbium (see the production chapter). For the uranium and thorium in rare earth ores, see the rare earths page.

Sources

  1. 1

    Britannica Editors, Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2026. thulium .

    Properties, discovery, name, minerals, isotopes, abundance, production and uses. Read with Firecrawl; the site refused a script.

    • It is found in small amounts in such rare-earth minerals as laterite ionic clays, xenotime, and euxenite
  2. 2

    Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Thulium - Element information, properties and uses , Sections Uses, Biological role, Natural abundance, History; podcast transcript (Chemistry in its element: thulium, Brian Clegg).

    Discovery, name, uses in X-ray sources and lasers, biological role, minerals and production. The podcast gives a rough figure for yearly output without a year or a source.

    • Thulium is found principally in the mineral monazite, which contains about 20 parts per million
  3. 3

    U.S. Geological Survey (Joseph Gambogi and Daniel J. Cordier), 2012. Rare Earths, in 2010 Minerals Yearbook , Text (crustal abundance); Table 2 (rare earth contents of major ores); Table 3 (rare earth oxide prices, 2010, from Rhodia).

    Crustal abundance of thulium, the thulium content of the main rare earth ores, and the 2010 list price of thulium oxide.

    • Thulium trace trace 1.10 1.30 trace 0.7
  4. 4

    U.S. Geological Survey (Shelby N. Johnston), 2026. Rare earths (heavy), in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Both pages of the chapter: domestic production and use, salient statistics, recycling, import sources, events, world resources, substitutes.

    The heavy rare earths as a group, their uses, US net import reliance, recycling, China's export controls of 2025 and substitutes. The chapter gives no price and no import source for thulium.

    • Terbium, dysprosium, holmium, erbium, thulium, ytterbium, and lutetium are heavy
    • Heavy rare earths are less abundant than light rare earths but are elevated in some ores, including ion-adsorption clays
  5. 5

    European Commission (M. Grohol and C. Veeh), 2023. Study on the Critical Raw Materials for the EU 2023: Final Report , Table A, major global supplier countries (row 46, thulium); list of heavy rare earths; table of end uses (thulium row).

    China's share of world thulium supply at the processing stage, 2016-2020, thulium as a heavy rare earth, and the end use that the EU assigned to it.

    • heavy rare earths - HREE (dysprosium, erbium, europium, gadolinium, holmium, lutetium, terbium, thulium, ytterbium, yttrium)
  6. 6

    U.S. Geological Survey (Bradley S. Van Gosen, Philip L. Verplanck, Robert R. Seal II, Keith R. Long and Joseph Gambogi), 2017. Rare-earth elements, chapter O of Critical mineral resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802-O) , Table O1 (crustal abundance); Introduction (deposit types); Sources and production (China).

    Crustal abundance of thulium after Lide (2004), and ion-adsorption clays as the main source of the heavy rare earths.

    • ion-adsorption clays are valued for their medium REE and HREE content
    • Ion-adsorption clay deposits in southern China are the world’s primary source of the heavy REEs