How we get thulium
How much do we make each year, and how?
We found no reliable world figure for thulium alone. The EU estimated about 660 tonnes a year for holmium, thulium, lutetium and ytterbium oxides together. Mines produced about 390,000 tonnes of all rare earth oxides in 2025, 69% of them in China. Almost no thulium is recycled.
Thulium is one of the rare earth elements. How they are mined, separated, sold and controlled →
Last updated 14 October 2026.
How much is produced
We found no reliable world figure for thulium alone. USGS counts all rare earths together, as oxide. Mines produced about 390,000 tonnes of rare earth oxide in 20251.
The authors of the EU study of 2020 found no world data for each rare earth, so they made their own estimates2. They give holmium, thulium, lutetium and ytterbium only as one group. For this group, they give about 660 tonnes of oxide, or 0.6% of all rare earth oxide2. The estimate uses World Mining Data. A chart of the same data gives the output of this group as an average of 2012 to 20162. Thulium is only part of this group, so its own output is smaller.
The science writer Brian Clegg says, in an RSC podcast, that about 50 tonnes of thulium are mined each year3. He gives no year and no source, so we do not use this figure in the data.
Who produces it
China mined 270,000 of the 390,000 tonnes of rare earth oxide in 2025, or 69%1. The EU gives China 100% of the processing of thulium (see the power chapter).
In 2025, no company in the United States made heavy rare earth compounds in steady commercial amounts. At least five companies were building plants to process them5. For the main companies of the group, see the rare earths page.
How it is mined and refined
Mines produce thulium with the other rare earths. Then chemical plants separate the rare earths by ion exchange and solvent extraction3. For these steps, see the rare earths page.
To make the metal, plants reduce thulium fluoride with calcium, or thulium oxide with lanthanum3. Britannica says that the thulium metal is then distilled6.
To make thulium-170 for X-ray sources, a nuclear reactor bombards natural thulium with neutrons6.
What it costs to produce
We found no published cost of production for thulium. The rare earths come out of one ore, so a mine shares its costs among all of them. For the energy use and the greenhouse gas emissions of production, see the impact chapter.
Recycling
- End-of-life recycling
-
~ 1%7
Other sources: 0% (UK assessment, 2024)8.
Global end-of-life recycling rate for thulium, given by UNEP (2011) as less than 1%. We show it as 1%, the upper end.
Range 0% to 1%. UNEP (2011) also gives a recycled content below 1% for thulium. The UK criticality assessment of 2024 gives 0% for the rare earths as one group, but its table by use does not name lasers or X-ray sources, the uses of thulium that USGS names. The EU said in 2020 that nobody had tried to recover thulium from scrap, even in a laboratory.
Almost no thulium is recycled at the end of its life. In 2011, UNEP gave both the end-of-life recycling rate and the recycled content of thulium as below 1%7. The UK assessment of 2024 gives 0% for the rare earths as a group8. Its table by use does not name lasers or X-ray sources, the uses of thulium that USGS names, so we show the UNEP value.
The EU said in 2020 that nobody had tried to recover thulium from scrap, even in a laboratory. It gave two reasons: there are few used devices that contain it, and its concentration in them is low2.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Geological Survey (Shelby N. Johnston), 2026. Rare Earths, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Pp. 152-153: events, trends and issues; world mine production and reserves.
World rare earth output and reserves in 2025, and China's export controls of October 2025 and their suspension.
-
World total (rounded) … 380,000 390,000
-
270,000 270,000
-
- 2
European Commission (G.A. Blengini and others), 2020. Study on the EU's list of Critical Raw Materials (2020): Factsheets on Critical Raw Materials , Chapter 21, rare earth elements: sections 21.1, 21.1.1, 21.2 (uses), 21.3 (supply, Table 176), 21.4 (prices), 21.5 (recycling).
Thulium as a heavy rare earth with niche uses, its crustal abundance, its uses, a demand forecast, EU use and trade, prices, recycling, and a rough estimate of world output of holmium, thulium, lutetium and ytterbium oxides together.
-
As there is no data available at the global level for individual production of REE
-
Ho, Tm, Lu, … 660 0.6
-
Global production of Ho, Tm, Lu, Yb oxide, average 2012-2016 (WMD, 2019)
-
Ho, Tm, Yb and Lu recovery from scrap has not been attempted even at laboratory scale due to the limited number of end-of-life devices containing these REE and their low concentrations
-
- 3
Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Thulium - Element information, properties and uses , Sections Uses, Biological role, Natural abundance, History; podcast transcript (Chemistry in its element: thulium, Brian Clegg).
Discovery, name, uses in X-ray sources and lasers, biological role, minerals and production. The podcast gives a rough figure for yearly output without a year or a source.
-
about 50 tonnes of it is mined each year
-
It is extracted by ion exchange and solvent extraction
-
The metal is obtained by reducing the anhydrous fluoride with calcium, or reducing the oxide with lanthanum
-
- 4
European Commission (M. Grohol and C. Veeh), 2023. Study on the Critical Raw Materials for the EU 2023: Final Report , Table A, major global supplier countries (row 46, thulium); list of heavy rare earths; table of end uses (thulium row).
China's share of world thulium supply at the processing stage, 2016-2020, thulium as a heavy rare earth, and the end use that the EU assigned to it.
-
46 thulium P China 100%
-
- 5
U.S. Geological Survey (Shelby N. Johnston), 2026. Rare earths (heavy), in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Both pages of the chapter: domestic production and use, salient statistics, recycling, import sources, events, world resources, substitutes.
The heavy rare earths as a group, their uses, US net import reliance, recycling, China's export controls of 2025 and substitutes. The chapter gives no price and no import source for thulium.
-
At least five companies were developing commercial-scale heavy-rare-earth processing and refining capacity
-
although none produced sustained commercial-scale quantities
-
- 6
Britannica Editors, Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2026. thulium .
Properties, discovery, name, minerals, isotopes, abundance, production and uses. Read with Firecrawl; the site refused a script.
-
The metal is prepared by reduction of its oxide by lanthanum metal followed by distillation of the thulium metal
-
Bombarded by neutrons, natural thulium becomes radioactive thulium-170 (128.6-day half-life)
-
- 7
UNEP International Resource Panel (T.E. Graedel et al.), 2011. Recycling Rates of Metals: A Status Report , Appendix table of OSR, RC and EOL-RR by metal (Tm row); Appendix A (uses of the rare earths).
End-of-life recycling rate and recycled content below 1% for thulium; thulium has no significant uses.
-
Tm <1 <1
-
- 8
UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre, British Geological Survey, 2024. UK 2024 Criticality Assessment , Table 2, candidate materials; Appendix 6, end-of-life recycling rates (REE row and REE table by use).
The UK assessed thulium with the other rare earths as one group, which it found critical, and gives 0% end-of-life recycling for every rare earth use.
-
Rare earth elements (REE) 0 Magnesite 52
-