What we use thulium for
Where does it go, and why this element?
Thulium has few uses, and all of them are small. USGS names lasers, metallurgy and X-ray devices. Thulium lasers are used in surgery and for kidney stones, and radioactive thulium-170 is used in portable X-ray sources. UNEP said in 2011 that thulium had no significant uses.
Last updated 14 October 2026.
Where it goes
We found no source that gives the amount of thulium in each use. The EU says that the use of thulium in each application is too small to estimate with accuracy1. So we give no shares.
USGS lists lasers, metallurgy and X-ray devices as the uses of thulium2.
- Lasers. Thulium is a dopant in laser crystals, such as yttrium aluminum garnet31. The RSC says that thulium lasers have uses in surgery4. One of them is the thulium fiber laser, which breaks kidney and urinary stones5.
- X-ray sources. A nuclear reactor can turn thulium into thulium-170, which emits X-rays. A small button of it is the source in light, portable X-ray machines for medical use4. Britannica says that people also use such sources to check thin-walled structures for faults3.
- Glass and other uses. The EU names glass as the main use of thulium, holmium, lutetium and ytterbium as a group1. It also names garnets for microwave devices1. Britannica says that thulium is part of some high-temperature superconducting oxides3.
From 2016 to 2018, the EU used about 8 tonnes a year of holmium, lutetium, ytterbium and thulium compounds together, for glass and optics1. The EU gives no figure for thulium alone.
The sources do not agree on how much thulium is used at all. UNEP said in 2011 that thulium had no significant uses6. The EU said in 2020 that it had no real commercial use, but that glass, phosphors and fiber optics had potential1. Britannica says that thulium has little practical use beyond research3. In its criticality study of 2023, the EU put all thulium in ceramics7. The EU gives no reason for this.
Why this element
For X-ray sources, thulium-170 has a half-life of 128.6 days3. Natural thulium is all one isotope, thulium-169, so a reactor makes thulium-170 from it directly (see the abundance chapter).
For lasers, thulium gives light at a wavelength of about 2,000 nanometers4. The thulium fiber laser uses 1,940 nanometers. Water absorbs this light four times more strongly than the light of the holmium laser5. The authors of a 2021 review say that it breaks stones twice as fast as the holmium laser, and dusts them four times as fast5. They also say that larger clinical studies were necessary to confirm its safety and efficacy5.
What could replace it
For kidney stones, the holmium laser is the standard tool, and the thulium fiber laser is the newer choice5. The authors of the 2021 review say that the thulium laser could compete with the holmium laser or replace it5.
Two reviews of 2026 compare the two lasers in patients. One review of 13 studies found more patients free of stones with the thulium laser8. But it found results similar to those of newer holmium lasers with pulse modulation8. A review of 8 high-quality studies of kidney stones found no significant difference from high-power holmium lasers9. So each laser is an alternative to the other.
USGS says that light rare earths can replace heavy rare earths in several uses10. USGS names no substitute for thulium alone. Brian Clegg says that, for a long time, other elements could do all that thulium did, better and at a lower cost4.
Where demand is going
We found no current forecast for thulium. The EU study of 2020 quotes an older forecast. In this forecast, supply and demand of holmium, thulium, ytterbium and lutetium together grow about 8% a year until 20201. This was a forecast, and the period is now past. We found no check of it.
Sources
- 1
European Commission (G.A. Blengini and others), 2020. Study on the EU's list of Critical Raw Materials (2020): Factsheets on Critical Raw Materials , Chapter 21, rare earth elements: sections 21.1, 21.1.1, 21.2 (uses), 21.3 (supply, Table 176), 21.4 (prices), 21.5 (recycling).
Thulium as a heavy rare earth with niche uses, its crustal abundance, its uses, a demand forecast, EU use and trade, prices, recycling, and a rough estimate of world output of holmium, thulium, lutetium and ytterbium oxides together.
-
The use of holmium, thulium, ytterbium and lutetium in individual applications is too small to be estimated with accuracy
-
Yttrium, neodymium, erbium, ytterbium and thulium are dopants in laser crystals
-
Glass is also the main application of erbium and holmium/lutetium/ytterbium/thulium
-
followed by Ho, Tm, Er and Yb compounds as dopant agents
-
per year of holmium, lutetium, ytterbium and thulium compounds (oxide content)
-
thulium metals and interalloys between 2016-2018 for glass-optical applications
-
Thulium has no real commercial use; but glass, phosphors and fibre optics have potential.
-
The overall supply and demand for Ho-Tm-Yb-Lu supply is expected to increase by around 8% per year until 2020 (EC, 2014)
-
- 2
U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , PDF p. 13 (trade policy actions); PDF p. 27 (uses of critical minerals, thulium row); notes to Figure 10A (1-year percent change in prices).
China's export controls of October 2025 and their suspension; the main uses of thulium; USGS had not enough price information for thulium.
-
Lasers, metallurgy, and X-ray devices.
-
- 3
Britannica Editors, Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2026. thulium .
Properties, discovery, name, minerals, isotopes, abundance, production and uses. Read with Firecrawl; the site refused a script.
-
The element is also employed as a dopant in yttrium- aluminum garnet for laser applications
-
Thulium-170 is used in small portable X-ray sources suitable for medical X-ray imaging and nondestructive evaluation of thin-walled structures
-
Together with yttrium, thulium is a component of some high-temperature superconducting oxides
-
Thulium has little practical use beyond research
-
natural thulium becomes radioactive thulium-170 (128.6-day half-life)
-
- 4
Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Thulium - Element information, properties and uses , Sections Uses, Biological role, Natural abundance, History; podcast transcript (Chemistry in its element: thulium, Brian Clegg).
Discovery, name, uses in X-ray sources and lasers, biological role, minerals and production. The podcast gives a rough figure for yearly output without a year or a source.
-
Thulium is used in lasers with surgical applications.
-
When irradiated in a nuclear reactor, thulium produces an isotope that emits x-rays. A ‘button’ of this isotope is used to make a lightweight, portable x-ray machine for medical use.
-
The crystal is used as the active medium in a laser with a wavelength of around 2,000 nanometres, which is ideal for laser surgery
-
There was nothing you could do with thulium that couldn’t be done better and cheaper with one of the other elements.
-
- 5
Peter Kronenberg, Bm Zeeshan Hameed and Bhaskar Somani, Current Opinion in Urology 31 (2): 80-86, 2021. Outcomes of thulium fibre laser for treatment of urinary tract stones: results of a systematic review , Abstract; Introduction; Thulium fibre laser machine specifications; Conclusion.
The thulium fiber laser for kidney and urinary stones, its approval in the US and Europe, and how it compares with the holmium laser.
-
With the recent FDA approval in 2019 and the European CE mark approval in 2020, Thulium fibre laser technology has become more widely available, but is still a rarity in most urological departments
-
the TFL uses 1940 nm wavelength and its radiation absorption is four times higher in water
-
This makes the TFL ablate twice as fast for fragmentation, 4 times as fast for dusting
-
However larger multicentric prospective clinical studies with long-term follow-up are needed to establish the safety and efficacy of the TFL in endourology
-
Although Holmium:Yttrium-Aluminum-garnet (Ho:YAG) laser is the current gold-standard in endoscopic laser lithotripsy
-
the TFL has the potential to compete or even replace the Ho:YAG laser
-
- 6
UNEP International Resource Panel (T.E. Graedel et al.), 2011. Recycling Rates of Metals: A Status Report , Appendix table of OSR, RC and EOL-RR by metal (Tm row); Appendix A (uses of the rare earths).
End-of-life recycling rate and recycled content below 1% for thulium; thulium has no significant uses.
-
Tm – Thulium has no significant uses
-
- 7
European Commission (M. Grohol and C. Veeh), 2023. Study on the Critical Raw Materials for the EU 2023: Final Report , Table A, major global supplier countries (row 46, thulium); list of heavy rare earths; table of end uses (thulium row).
China's share of world thulium supply at the processing stage, 2016-2020, thulium as a heavy rare earth, and the end use that the EU assigned to it.
-
Thulium Ceramics 100%
-
- 8
Hyun Kyu Ahn and others, Medicina 62 (4): 644, 2026. Thulium Fiber Laser Versus Holmium Laser for Ureteroscopic Lithotripsy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis , Abstract.
Thirteen studies with 2,217 patients. Higher stone-free rate with the thulium fiber laser than with the holmium laser overall; similar to holmium lasers with pulse modulation; similar complication rates.
-
Overall, the TFL group demonstrated a significantly higher SFR compared to the Ho:YAG group
-
TFL demonstrates comparable efficacy to modern Ho:YAG systems equipped with pulse modulation
-
- 9
Khi Yung Fong and others, Therapeutic Advances in Urology 18, 2026. Thulium fiber laser versus high-power holmium laser for renal stones: a systematic review and meta-analysis of high-quality studies , Abstract.
Eight randomized or matched studies with 1,290 patients. No significant difference between the thulium fiber laser and high-power holmium lasers for kidney stones.
-
found no significant differences between HPHL and TFL
-
- 10
U.S. Geological Survey (Shelby N. Johnston), 2026. Rare earths (heavy), in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Both pages of the chapter: domestic production and use, salient statistics, recycling, import sources, events, world resources, substitutes.
The heavy rare earths as a group, their uses, US net import reliance, recycling, China's export controls of 2025 and substitutes. The chapter gives no price and no import source for thulium.
-
Light rare earths can substitute for heavy rare earths in several applications.
-