Who controls thulium
Who controls the supply, and who depends on it?
By the EU count, China did all the processing of thulium in 2016 to 2020. The United States relies on imports for all the heavy rare earths it uses. In October 2025, China announced export controls on thulium, then suspended them. The EU, the US and the UK list it as critical.
Thulium is one of the rare earth elements. How they are mined, separated, sold and controlled →
Last updated 11 November 2026.
How concentrated supply is
China 100%. Top three countries 100%. HHI at least 10,000, highly concentrated.1
HHI is the Herfindahl-Hirschman index: the sum of each country's squared percentage share. We compute it from the country table. We leave out the rest of the world, so the true value can be a little higher. In the 2023 US merger guidelines, above 1,800 is "highly concentrated". In older guidelines, 1,000 to 1,800 was "moderately concentrated". Those guidelines are for companies, not countries.2
The EU gives China 100% of world supply of thulium at the processing stage, as an average of 2016 to 20201. USGS gives a net import reliance of 100% for the heavy rare earth compounds and metals that the United States used from 2021 to 20253. USGS names import sources for five heavy rare earths, but not for thulium. For China’s share of mining, see the production chapter. For the companies and the trade policies of China, see the rare earths page.
Who depends on it
Hospitals and clinics use thulium lasers for surgery and for kidney stones. Portable X-ray machines use thulium-170 (see the uses chapter). We found no source that says how much any industry depends on thulium. In a report of 2013, the US Department of Defense named thulium among rare earth materials that could be in short supply4.
How governments treat it
| List | On the list |
|---|---|
| EU critical raw materials (2023) | Yes The Act lists the heavy rare earth elements as a group but does not name its members. The EU criticality study of 2023 counts thulium among them. 5 |
| EU strategic raw materials (2023) | No The strategic list names seven rare earths for permanent magnets. Thulium is not one of them. 5 |
| US critical minerals (USGS, 2025) | Yes 6 |
| US critical materials for energy (DOE) | No Thulium is not on the DOE list of critical materials for energy. It appears in the report only in the USGS list of 2022 that the report repeats. 7 |
| UK critical minerals (2024) | Yes The UK assessed the rare earths, thulium included, as one group, and found the group critical. 8 |
| Canada critical minerals (2024) | Yes Listed as one of the rare earth elements; the list does not name each one. 9 |
-
European Union. The Critical Raw Materials Act lists the heavy rare earths as critical5. The EU study of 2023 counts thulium among them1. Thulium is not on the strategic list. That list names seven rare earths for permanent magnets5.
-
United States. Thulium is on the 2025 list of critical minerals6. It was also on the list of 20227. It is not on the 2023 DOE list of critical materials for energy7.
-
United Kingdom. The 2024 assessment treats the rare earths as one group, and finds the group critical8.
-
China. On 9 October 2025, China announced export controls on erbium, europium, holmium, thulium and ytterbium1011. Exporters of thulium metal, crystal materials, luminescent materials, oxide and compounds would need a license11. The ministry gave national security and non-proliferation as its reasons11. The controls were to start on 8 November11.
USGS says that China suspended them in late October, after an agreement with the US government10. The formal notice is dated 7 November. It suspends the controls until 10 November 202612. On 9 November 2026, China extended the suspension to 10 January 2027. The notice gives no reason13. So the controls on thulium have not come into effect.
Sources
- 1
European Commission (M. Grohol and C. Veeh), 2023. Study on the Critical Raw Materials for the EU 2023: Final Report , Table A, major global supplier countries (row 46, thulium); list of heavy rare earths; table of end uses (thulium row).
China's share of world thulium supply at the processing stage, 2016-2020, thulium as a heavy rare earth, and the end use that the EU assigned to it.
-
46 thulium P China 100%
-
heavy rare earths - HREE (dysprosium, erbium, europium, gadolinium, holmium, lutetium, terbium, thulium, ytterbium, yttrium)
-
- 2
U.S. Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission, 2023. Merger Guidelines , Guideline 1, p. 5 and footnote 15.
Defines the Herfindahl-Hirschman index; above 1,800 is highly concentrated. Footnote 15 gives the older band of 1,000 to 1,800 as moderately concentrated.
- 3
U.S. Geological Survey (Shelby N. Johnston), 2026. Rare earths (heavy), in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Both pages of the chapter: domestic production and use, salient statistics, recycling, import sources, events, world resources, substitutes.
The heavy rare earths as a group, their uses, US net import reliance, recycling, China's export controls of 2025 and substitutes. The chapter gives no price and no import source for thulium.
-
Net import reliance4 as a percentage of apparent consumption
-
- 4
U.S. Geological Survey (Joseph Gambogi), 2016. Rare Earths, in 2013 Minerals Yearbook , Government programs: the Department of Defense stockpile report of 2013.
Thulium among the rare earth materials that the US Department of Defense named as potential shortfall materials.
-
Rare-earth materials that were identified as potential shortfall materials included dysprosium, erbium, scandium, terbium, thulium, yttrium
-
- 5
European Parliament and Council of the European Union, 2024. Regulation (EU) 2024/1252 establishing a framework for ensuring a secure and sustainable supply of critical raw materials (Critical Raw Materials Act) , Annex I, Section 1 (strategic raw materials); Annex II, Section 1 (critical raw materials).
The adopted lists of strategic and critical raw materials.
-
(q) heavy rare earth elements
-
rare earth elements for permanent magnets (Nd, Pr, Tb, Dy, Gd, Sm, and Ce)
-
- 6
U.S. Geological Survey (Federal Register vol. 90, no. 214), 2025. Final 2025 List of Critical Minerals , The list of 60 critical minerals.
Thulium is on the 2025 US list of critical minerals.
-
tantalum, tellurium, terbium, thulium
-
- 7
U.S. Department of Energy, 2023. Notice of Final Determination on 2023 DOE Critical Materials List (preprint) , Summary: critical materials for energy; the USGS list of 2022.
Thulium is not on the DOE list of critical materials for energy. The report repeats the USGS list of 2022, which has thulium.
-
Critical materials for energy: aluminum, cobalt, copper
-
terbium, thulium, tin, titanium
-
- 8
UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre, British Geological Survey, 2024. UK 2024 Criticality Assessment , Table 2, candidate materials; Appendix 6, end-of-life recycling rates (REE row and REE table by use).
The UK assessed thulium with the other rare earths as one group, which it found critical, and gives 0% end-of-life recycling for every rare earth use.
-
REEs (15 lanthanoids plus yttrium and scandium assessed as a single group)
-
- 9
Natural Resources Canada, 2024. Critical minerals: an opportunity for Canada .
Canada's list of 34 critical minerals (2021, updated June 2024).
-
critical minerals list identifies 34 minerals and metals ... Rare earth elements
-
- 10
U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , PDF p. 13 (trade policy actions); PDF p. 27 (uses of critical minerals, thulium row); notes to Figure 10A (1-year percent change in prices).
China's export controls of October 2025 and their suspension; the main uses of thulium; USGS had not enough price information for thulium.
-
In early October, China issued export controls on erbium, europium, holmium, thulium, and ytterbium
-
However, in late October following an agreement with the United States Government, China suspended the October controls for 1 year
-
- 11
Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs of the People's Republic of China, 2025. 商务部 海关总署公告2025年第57号: 公布对部分中重稀土相关物项实施出口管制的决定 (Announcement No. 57 of 2025: export controls on some medium and heavy rare earth items) , Section 3 (1C911, thulium items); last paragraph (start date).
In Chinese. Dated 9 October 2025. Export controls on holmium, erbium, thulium, europium and ytterbium items, the stated reasons, and the start date of 8 November 2025.
-
2025年10月9日
-
1. 金属铥
-
含铥的晶体材料
-
含铥的发光材料
-
氧化铥及其混合物
-
向国务院商务主管部门申请许可
-
为维护国家安全和利益、履行防扩散等国际义务
-
本公告自2025年11月8日起正式实施
-
- 12
Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs of the People's Republic of China, 2025. 商务部、海关总署公告2025年第70号: 公布暂停实施商务部、海关总署公告2025年第55号、56号、57号、58号及商务部公告2025年第61号、62号的决定 (Announcement No. 70 of 2025: suspension of Announcements No. 55 to 58, 61 and 62) .
In Chinese. Dated 7 November 2025. Suspends the export controls of October 2025, among them No. 57 on thulium, until 10 November 2026.
-
2025年11月07日
-
自即日起至2026年11月10日
-
- 13
Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs of the People's Republic of China, 2026. 商务部、海关总署公告2026年第58号: 公布继续暂停实施商务部、海关总署公告2025年第55号、56号、57号、58号及商务部公告2025年第61号、62号的决定 (Announcement No. 58 of 2026: continued suspension of Announcements No. 55 to 58, 61 and 62 of 2025) .
In Chinese. Dated 9 November 2026. Keeps the October 2025 export controls, among them No. 57 on thulium, suspended until 10 January 2027.
-
2026年11月09日
-
自2026年11月11日起至2027年1月10日
-