Tungsten: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Tungsten ore is one of four conflict minerals named in US rules on eastern Congo. Its supply has been part of wars and trade disputes. Examples are Portugal's wartime sales to Germany, a WTO case on Chinese export limits, and the tariffs and export controls of 2024 and 2025.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

The Second World War. Portugal was neutral. From 1941 to mid-1944, under secret agreements, it sent Germany over 2,000 tonnes of wolfram ore a year. That was about 60% of Germany’s estimated minimum need1. The Allies bought wolfram to keep it from Germany1.

From January 1944, the Allies pushed Portugal’s leader, António Salazar, to stop all sales. Portugal defended its right as a neutral to sell to anyone. It also feared an attack by Germany1. On 2 June 1944, the US minister in Lisbon reported that Salazar had offered to stop all wolfram mining and exports, with conditions2. After the Allies threatened sanctions, Portugal stopped all wolfram exports that June1.

Conflict minerals. In 2012, the US Securities and Exchange Commission put in force a rule on minerals that may finance armed groups in Congo and its neighbors. The rule covers four minerals, among them wolframite3. In 2022, the US Government Accountability Office (GAO) studied a sample of company reports for 2021. More than half of the companies named the conflict minerals they used, and 56% reported tungsten. Congo and its neighbors had produced only 1% to 2% of world tungsten in recent years3. The GAO also concluded that peace and security in eastern Congo had not improved since 20143. The EU has its own rule, Regulation 2017/821, in force since 20214.

The WTO case. In 2012, the United States asked for WTO talks on China’s export limits on rare earths, tungsten and molybdenum5. China said that the limits served to conserve its natural resources and to reduce pollution from mining. The complainants said that the limits gave Chinese industries protected access to the raw materials5. The panel found that the export quotas served industrial policy rather than conservation. The WTO adopted the reports in August 20145. In May 2015, China told the WTO that it had removed the export duties and quotas5.

Export controls. In February 2025, China put export controls on tungsten products, for reasons of national security6. The IEA reports that trade in tungsten carbide and powder then fell sharply or stopped7.

Workers and communities

In central Africa, much tungsten comes from artisanal miners. In eastern Congo, artisanal miners often produce it as a by-product of tin or coltan3. Rwanda has many tungsten mines, most of them artisanal3. Burundi, Congo, Rwanda and Uganda take part in a scheme to trace tin, tantalum and tungsten from mine to plant3. According to the Bolivian government, mining cooperatives produced 57% of Bolivia’s tungsten in 20213.

Workers in factories face risks of their own. ITIA writes that workers can breathe in tungsten during powder handling and metal forming, and that they need ventilation and protective equipment8. Workers who breathe in dust of tungsten carbide with cobalt can get a lung disease, hard metal lung disease98. In 2006, the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classed cobalt metal with tungsten carbide as probably carcinogenic to humans (Group 2A)9. A later study of more than 32,000 hard metal workers found no evidence that exposure at the levels studied raised lung cancer deaths108. ITIA started and paid for that study10.

ITIA notes that mining projects often have a large effect on local communities. In its view, opposition to mining in rich countries pushes the problems to poorer countries with weaker controls11.

Who gains and who loses

In the Second World War, Portugal gained much from selling wolfram to both sides1. Germany paid with goods, escudos and gold. Estimates of the looted gold that Portugal received range from $50.5 million to $106.6 million1.

Export limits change who pays. In the WTO case, the United States and the other complainants argued that China’s limits helped Chinese makers of downstream goods (see above). In the US tariff debate (see below), opponents said that the tariffs would raise costs for US users12.

High prices help mines outside China. In 2025, production rose, especially at the new Boguty deposit in Kazakhstan13. The IEA reports a growing gap between prices inside and outside China for several critical minerals7.

Public debate

In 2024, the United States raised Section 301 tariffs on tungsten products from China in two steps. In September it announced a 25% increase on carbides, concentrates, oxides, powders and tungstates14. In December it raised tariffs on three more groups of tungsten metal products to 25%, from January 202512. USGS describes the result as an increase of tariffs to 50% on several tungsten products13. We could not confirm the 50% figure in the US notices we read. In the December 2024 notice, the 50% rate applies to polysilicon and wafers, not to tungsten12. Supporters said that the tariffs would make US supply chains more secure12. Some asked for rates up to 75%12. Opponents said that there was little tungsten outside China and that costs and inflation would rise12.

Sources

  1. 1

    U.S. National Archives and Records Administration, 1999. Records of the Foreign Service Posts of the Department of State: Portugal (Holocaust-era assets finding aid) , Introduction.

    Portugal's wolfram exports to Germany from 1941 to 1944, Allied pre-emptive purchases and the embargo of June 1944.

    • Germany and Portugal negotiated secret agreements in accordance with which Portugal exported an average of over 2,000 metric tons of wolfram to Germany annually between 1941 and mid-1944, about 60 percent of Germany’s estimate minimum industrial requirement
    • The Allies’ objective was to purchase enough of wolfram to satisfy Portugal’s export demands and prevent as much as possible from going to the enemy
    • In January 1944, the Allies began to pressure Salazar to embargo all wolfram sales, but Portugal resisted, defending its right as a neutral to sell to anyone and fearing that any reduction in its exports would prompt Germany to attack Portuguese shipping
    • On the eve of the D-Day invasion in June 1944, after the Allies threatened economic sanctions, the Portuguese government imposed a complete embargo on wolfram exports to both the Allies and the Axis
    • Portugal’s trade with the Allies and Axis worked to its great advantage as both sides paid inflated prices for wolfram
    • Germany paid for its Portuguese imports, including wolfram, with German goods and escudos, as well as gold (most of which came through Switzerland) and Swiss francs purchased with gold. Estimates of the total amount of looted gold received by Portugal ranged from $50.5 million to $106.6 million
  2. 2

    U.S. Department of State, Office of the Historian (telegram from the US Minister in Portugal, 2 June 1944), 1944. Foreign Relations of the United States, Diplomatic Papers, 1944, Europe, Volume IV, Document 134 .

    Salazar's offer of June 1944 to stop wolfram mining and exports, with conditions.

    • Salazar last night gave Campbell a promise to stop all mining in Portugal of wolfram and to prohibit all exports provided
  3. 3

    U.S. Geological Survey (K.B. Shedd), 2025. Tungsten, in 2021 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , Consumption; Prices; Government Actions and Legislation; World Review (China, Congo (Kinshasa), Rwanda, Bolivia, Portugal, Austria, United Kingdom, Vietnam).

    Properties and uses, conflict minerals rules, China's controls on mining and exports, producers by country.

    • In 2012, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) implemented section 1502 … cassiterite, columbite-tantalite, gold, wolframite, or their derivatives
    • more than one-half of the companies identified the specific conflict minerals used in their products and 56% reported using tungsten. Tungsten concentrate production from Congo (Kinshasa) and adjoining countries (Burundi, Rwanda, and Uganda) had been only 1% to 2% of world production in recent years
    • Overall peace and security in the eastern part of the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) has not improved since 2014 because of persistent, interdependent factors that fuel violence by non-state armed groups
    • Tungsten was produced in eastern Congo (Kinshasa) by artisanal miners, often as a byproduct of mining tin and (or) coltan
    • Rwanda had numerous tungsten mining operations; most were artisanal, and some were small-scale semi-industrial operations
    • Burundi, Congo (Kinshasa), Rwanda, and Uganda each participated in the International Tin Association Ltd.’s ITA Tin Supply Chain Initiative (iTSCi)
    • According to the Bolivian Government, in 2021, 57% of Bolivia’s production was from mining cooperatives
  4. 4

    International Tungsten Industry Association (ITIA), 2026. Responsible Sourcing .

    Tungsten as a conflict mineral, the US and EU rules, and smelter audits. An industry association.

    • including the EU Conflict Minerals Regulation (2017/821 , effective 2021)
  5. 5

    World Trade Organization, 2015. DS431: China, Measures Related to the Exportation of Rare Earths, Tungsten and Molybdenum , Summary of the dispute to date.

    The US complaint of 2012, the arguments of each side, the panel and Appellate Body findings and China's implementation.

    • On 13 March 2012, the United States requested consultations with China with respect to China … restrictions on the export of various forms of rare earths, tungsten and molybdenum
    • China argued that the restrictions are related to the conservation of its exhaustible natural resources, and necessary to reduce pollution caused by mining. The complainants disagreed, arguing that the restrictions are designed to provide Chinese industries that produce downstream goods with protected access to the subject materials
    • It found that China … export quotas were designed to achieve industrial policy goals rather than conservation … At its meeting on 29 August 2014, the DSB adopted the Appellate Body report and the panel report
    • the application of export duties and export quotas to rare earths, tungsten and molybdenum … had been removed
  6. 6

    Shanghai Metals Market (SMM), 2025. Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs: Export Controls Imposed on Tungsten, Tellurium, Bismuth, Molybdenum, and Indium-Related Items .

    The text of China's export controls on tungsten items of 4 February 2025.

    • to safeguard national security and interests and fulfill international obligations such as non-proliferation
  7. 7

    International Energy Agency, 2026. Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026 , 1. Market review (prices, export controls); defence applications.

    The rise in tungsten prices from January 2025 to April 2026, export controls and defense uses.

    • trade volumes significantly decreased or stopped; this was the case for some rare earth-related items, such as permanent magnets, and for other dual-use elements, such as antimony oxide and tungsten carbide and powder
    • A widening divergence between Chinese domestic and ex-China prices has emerged for several critical minerals
  8. 8

    International Tungsten Industry Association (ITIA), 2026. Health & Environment , Environmental occurrence; Exposure; Health and Environmental Effects.

    Crustal abundance, exposure, hard metal lung disease, and the industry's summary of health studies. An industry association.

    • At tungsten manufacturing facilities, workers may be exposed to tungsten, tungsten compounds and other metals during powder handling and metal forming operations. For this reason, risk management measures, such as local exhaust ventilation, enclosures, respiratory protective devices, and other personal protective equipment, should be utilized
    • exposure to the combination of tungsten carbide and cobalt particles can cause a rare lung condition, known as Hard Metal Lung Disease
    • no evidence that duration, average intensity or cumulative exposure to tungsten, cobalt, or nickel, at levels experienced by the workers examined, increases lung cancer mortality risks
  9. 9

    International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization, 2006. Cobalt in Hard Metals and Cobalt Sulfate, Gallium Arsenide, Indium Phosphide and Vanadium Pentoxide: Summary of Data Reported and Evaluation (IARC Monographs Volume 86) , Metallic cobalt particles (with or without tungsten carbide): 5.2 Human carcinogenicity data; 5.4 Other relevant data; 5.5 Evaluation.

    IARC classed cobalt metal with tungsten carbide (hard metal) as probably carcinogenic to humans (Group 2A), and described hard metal lung disease. Copy of the IARC summary on INCHEM.

    • fibrosing alveolitis (cobalt metal mixed with tungsten carbide or with microdiamonds). Fibrosis alveolitis, also known as hard-metal lung disease
    • Cobalt metal with tungsten carbide is probably carcinogenic to humans (Group 2A)
  10. 10

    UPMC and University of Pittsburgh, news release, 2017. Largest Study to Date Evaluates Occupational Health Risks to Hardmetal Workers .

    The pooled study of hard metal workers led by the University of Pittsburgh, its size, its funding (ITIA and the Pennsylvania Department of Health) and its results.

    • study of more than 32,000 workers in five countries
    • The research was initiated and funded by the International Tungsten Industry Association
  11. 11

    International Tungsten Industry Association (ITIA), 2024. Tungsten mining, part 1: project generation and project development , Mineralogy; Deposit types; Project Development.

    Tungsten minerals, deposit types and grades, where deposits are, the size of the industry, mine development times.

    • Mining projects have often a significant impact on the local communities … Critics of mining in many industrialised countries are pushing the problems to less developed countries, which have lesser control on the possible impact management
  12. 12

    Office of the United States Trade Representative, Federal Register Vol. 89 (FR Doc. 2024-29462), 16 December 2024, 2024. Notice of Modification: China's Acts, Policies, and Practices Related to Technology Transfer, Intellectual Property, and Innovation , Background; Tungsten Subheadings; Annex A.

    The decision to raise Section 301 tariffs on three tungsten subheadings to 25% from 2025, and the comments for and against it.

    • These comments express concerns that increased tariffs on tungsten will increase production costs, exacerbate inflation
    • has determined to increase tariffs on the 3 tungsten subheadings to 25 percent beginning in 2025
    • the U.S. Trade Representative has determined to increase tariffs on polysilicon and wafers to 50 percent in 2025
    • Comments supporting increases primarily assert that increasing tariffs on tungsten products is vital to the security and the resilience of domestic supply chains
    • Some supporting comments recommend tariff rates as high as 75 percent to address China’s efforts to dominate and undercut domestic production
    • Comments opposing increases primarily assert limited availability of tungsten products outside of China … These comments express concerns that increased tariffs on tungsten will increase production costs, exacerbate inflation, harm U.S. competitiveness, and decrease U.S. market share
  13. 13

    U.S. Geological Survey (S.H. Saloum), 2026. Tungsten, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , p. 1, Domestic Production and Use, Salient Statistics, Recycling, Import Sources, Government Stockpile; p. 2, Events, World Mine Production and Reserves, World Resources, Substitutes, footnotes.

    World production and reserves by country, US use, prices, events of 2025, substitutes.

    • World mine production increased, especially from the start of production at the Boguty deposit in Kazakhstan
    • increased tariffs to 50% on several tungsten products from China
  14. 14

    U.S. Geological Survey, 2025. Tungsten, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2025 , p. 2, Events, Trends, and Issues.

    The US Section 301 tariff increase of September 2024 on tungsten products from China.

    • In September, the United States Trade Representative announced a section 301 tariff increase of 25% on imports of tungsten carbides, concentrates, oxides, powders, and tungstates from China