How we get bismuth

How much do we make each year, and how?

The USGS estimates world refinery output at 16,000 tonnes in 2025. Refiners recover most bismuth from lead bullion, or from tungsten and zinc ores. Almost none is recycled, because most uses spread it thinly in medicines, pigments and cosmetics.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

How much is produced

Refinery output

~ 16thousand tonnes a year1

2025. World refinery production of bismuth, tonnes, USGS estimate for 2025. The USGS gives no world mine production.

Some other sources give much lower figures. Deady and others (2022), with data from the British Geological Survey, give world production of 3,700 tonnes in 2020. The EU says that mine production (bismuth sulfide concentrates) and refined production are often confused.

Production over time
0 5k 10k 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 Gap
Unit: t. World production of bismuth, tonnes, USGS historical statistics. 1912 to 1921 and 1937 to 2015; the USGS has no world total for 1922 to 1936. The USGS has no world total for 1922 to 1936. The table does not say whether world production is mine or refinery output. For 2015 it gives 13,300 t; the USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries give 10,300 t of mine output for the same year. The USGS estimates world refinery output at 16,000 t in 20252
Show the numbers
Yeart
1912722
1913922
19141,050
19151,770
19161,670
1917907
1918992
1919833
1920817
1921274
1937700
19381,000
19391,300
19401,400
19411,400
19421,700
19431,400
19441,200
19451,100
1946940
19471,500
19481,500
19491,500
19501,400
19511,770
19521,770
19532,090
19541,680
19551,910
19562,400
19572,270
19582,090
19592,270
19602,400
19612,590
19623,040
19632,530
19642,890
19652,960
19663,110
19673,380
19683,770
19693,760
19703,720
19713,830
19724,000
19733,720
19744,820
19753,980
19763,940
19774,480
19784,250
19793,420
19803,610
19813,750
19824,110
19833,980
19843,480
19854,410
19863,660
19873,170
19883,220
19893,650
19903,440
19913,230
19922,870
19933,550
19943,410
19953,430
19963,600
19974,490
19983,990
19995,490
20003,760
20014,420
20024,600
20035,100
20045,600
20055,400
20065,800
20076,400
20087,500
20097,500
20107,700
20118,170
20126,960
20138,480
201412,600
201513,300

The USGS estimates world refinery production at 16,000 tonnes in 20251. That is about the same as the revised figure of 16,300 tonnes for 20241. The USGS had no data on production capacities1.

Some other sources give much lower figures. Deady and others, with data from the British Geological Survey, give world production of 3,700 tonnes in 2020 and 6,300 tonnes in 20193. The EU says that people often confuse mine production with refined production4. In the EU definition, mine production is the quantity of bismuth sulfide concentrates. Refined bismuth is metal of at least 99.8% purity4. The USGS gave no world mine figure after its 2017 edition, because it found the data inadequate5.

Who produces it

Refined bismuth by country
China (est.) 88% 14,000 t
South Korea (est.) 6.3% 1,000 t
Japan (est.) 3.1% 500 t
Laos (est.) 3.1% 500 t
2025. Refinery production of bismuth in 2025, tonnes, USGS estimates. The Laos figure for 2024 is a reported value. World: 16,000 t. Kazakhstan (180 t), Bolivia (50 t) and Bulgaria (50 t) are left out of the rows. With them, the rows add up to more than the rounded world total. The United States has refined no primary bismuth since 19971

China refined an estimated 14,000 tonnes in 2025, or 88% of the world total1. The Republic of Korea refined about 1,000 tonnes. Japan and Laos refined about 500 tonnes each, Kazakhstan about 180 tonnes, and Bolivia and Bulgaria about 50 tonnes each1.

Laos had a larger share a few years earlier. In 2022 the USGS put China at 82%, Laos at 10% and Korea at 4%6.

The Nui Phao mine in Vietnam opened in 2014. Deady and others call it the first major bismuth-producing mine to open since 19853. Its bismuth output rose from 646 tonnes in 2014 to 3,099 tonnes in 2018. It fell below 1,000 tonnes in 2019 and 20203.

How it is mined and refined

Most bismuth is separated in lead refineries. If lead bullion holds more than 4% bismuth, refiners use the electrolytic Betts process4. Bismuth then stays behind in the anode sludge7. In the Betterton-Kroll process, refiners add calcium or magnesium to molten lead. The bismuth compound that forms is skimmed off as dross7.

At Nui Phao, the plant makes bismuth concentrate by flotation, then leaching and cementation4. In China, part of the bismuth comes from artisanal mining with hand sorting of bismuth-rich rock4.

What it costs to produce

We found no published cost of production per tonne. In 2019 the EU reported that the price in Europe had fallen close to the cost of production4.

For copper producers, bismuth can be a cost. A copper concentrate with more than 500 ppm of bismuth gets a penalty from the smelter3.

Recycling

End-of-life recycling

0%8

Other sources: below 1% (UNEP, 2011)9.

World end-of-life recycling rate weighted by end use, from the UK 2024 criticality assessment. It gives 0% for chemicals (62% of use), fusible alloys (28%) and metallurgical additives and others (10%), from VERAM (2017).

The UK assessment adds that the CRM Alliance reported a rate below 1%. The EU says that bismuth is not recycled. The USGS estimates that recycled alloy scrap was up to 10% of US apparent consumption in 2021 to 2025.

Almost no bismuth is recycled at the end of its life. The UK criticality assessment of 2024 gives a world rate of 0%8. Published rates differ only a little: UNEP gave less than 1% in 2011, and the EU says that bismuth is not recycled94. Most bismuth goes into medicines, pigments and other uses that spread it thinly, so it is hard to recover8.

Some alloy scrap is recycled. The USGS estimates that recycled alloy scrap made up to 10% of US apparent consumption in 2021 to 20251. Deady and others name solder alloys in electronic equipment as the most likely source for more recycling3.

Sources

  1. 1

    U.S. Geological Survey (Kateryna Klochko), 2026. Bismuth, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 .

    World refinery production by country 2024 and 2025, US uses, imports and import reliance, prices, recycling, resources and substitutes.

    • Estimated world production of bismuth was 16,000 tons in 2025
    • World total (rounded) Refinery productione 2024 2025 — — 50 50 48 50 14,000 14,000 500 500 180 180 1,000 1,000 7 492 500 16,300 16,000
    • Reported bismuth production capacities were unavailable
    • Refinery productione 2024 2025 — — 50 50 48 50 14,000 14,000 500 500 180 180 1,000 1,000 7 492 500 16,300 16,000
    • China accounted for 88% of the bismuth world production in 2025
    • Recycled bismuth-containing alloy scrap was estimated to compose up to 10% of U.S. bismuth apparent consumption for the years 2021–25
  2. 2

    U.S. Geological Survey (D.A. Buckingham, J.F. Carlin Jr. and C.S. Anderson), 2017. Bismuth statistics, in Historical Statistics for Mineral and Material Commodities in the United States (Data Series 140) , Sheet 1, columns 'Unit value (98$/t)' and 'World production'.

    World production 1912 to 2015 and US unit value 1900 to 2015.

    • 2015 0 1950 519 464 662 1370 16700 11500 13300
  3. 3

    Eimear Deady and others, British Geological Survey (Ore Geology Reviews 143, 104722), 2022. Bismuth: Economic geology and value chains .

    Crustal abundance, minerals, deposit types, the Nui Phao and Tasna mines, mine production, reserves, uses, recycling and smelter penalties. Open access copy in the NERC archive.

    • Annual global production in 2020 was 3700 tonnes, falling from a ten year high of 6300 tonnes in 2019
    • it is the first major Bi-producing mine to open (Fig. 6A) since the closure of the Tasna mine in Bolivia in 1985
    • production from the Masan Resources-owned Núi Pháo mine in Vietnam, rising from 646 t in 2014 to 3099 t in 2018 (Brown et al., 2020), fell to <1000 t in 2019 and 2020
    • a Bi content exceeding 500 ppm in a saleable copper concentrate incurs a penalty
    • The most likely candidates for recycling are solder alloys, typically found in electronic equipment
  4. 4

    European Commission (G.A. Blengini and others), 2020. Study on the EU's list of Critical Raw Materials (2020): Factsheets on Critical Raw Materials , Bismuth factsheet, pp. 96–107.

    Uses, supply chain, refining processes, market structure, prices, the 2007 consolidation in Hunan, tariffs and the Fanya exchange.

    • However, confusions are often made between these two categories when considering global bismuth production
    • refers to the bismuth metal of a purity of at least 99.8%, in opposition to … referring to bismuth sulphide concentrates quantities
    • If the bismuth content of lead bullion is higher than 4%, the electrolytic route is preferred (Betts process)
    • These concentrates are also obtained through bismuth flotation, followed by leaching and cementation
    • In China, artisanal mining for bismuth also exists, with manual separation of bismuth-rich mineralization contributing significantly to global production of concentrates
    • The bismuth price in Europe has fallen close to the cost of production; suppliers are now operating at very low margins
    • Bismuth is not recycled
  5. 5

    U.S. Geological Survey, 2018. Bismuth, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2018 .

    The end of USGS world mine production and reserve estimates.

    • Mine production and reserves data were reevaluated, and available information was inadequate to make reliable estimates
  6. 6

    U.S. Geological Survey (Amy C. Tolcin), 2025. Bismuth, in Minerals Yearbook 2022 .

    World refinery shares, host ores by country, the US critical mineral lists, Chinese exports and the sale of the Tilly plant.

    • China was the world’s leading producer of refined bismuth, accounting for 82% of the estimated world total, followed by Laos and the Republic of Korea with 10% and 4%, respectively
  7. 7

    R. Thomas Sanderson, Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2026. Bismuth .

    History and name, occurrence, refining processes, uses, properties and toxicity. Fetched with Firecrawl because the site refused a script.

    • the Betts process, involves electrolytic refining of lead bullion (containing bismuth and other impurities) in a solution of lead fluosilicate and free fluosilicic acid, bismuth being recovered from the anode sludge
    • Separation of bismuth from lead by the Betterton–Kroll process involves the formation of high-melting calcium or magnesium bismuthide (Ca3Bi2 or Mg3Bi2), which separates and can be skimmed off as dross
  8. 8

    UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre, British Geological Survey, 2024. UK 2024 Criticality Assessment , Table of results; end-of-life recycling rates by end use.

    The UK critical minerals list of 2024, with end uses and end-of-life recycling rates.

    • Bismuth (Bi) 0
    • Bismuth is difficult to recycle since it is commonly used in dissipative applications like pigments and medicines
  9. 9

    UNEP International Resource Panel (T.E. Graedel et al.), 2011. Recycling Rates of Metals: A Status Report , Table F1.

    End-of-life recycling rates, recycled content and old scrap ratios for 60 metals.

    • Bi <1 <1