Bismuth: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

We found no war or armed group linked to bismuth. It is part of a US-China trade dispute, with US tariffs from 2018 and Chinese export controls from 2025. In 2015 a Chinese metals exchange that held bismuth collapsed. More than 220,000 investors had bought one of its products.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

We found no war, armed group or smuggling linked to bismuth.

Bismuth is part of the trade dispute between the United States and China. The United States put a 10% tariff on Chinese bismuth products in September 2018. It raised the tariff to 25% in May 20191. The EU says that the duties forced suppliers to cut their prices1.

On 4 February 2025, China put metallic bismuth and some bismuth compounds under export control2. The Ministry of Commerce gave a general reason: to protect national security and interests and to meet non-proliferation duties2. The USGS describes the controls as a response to a 10% US tariff on Chinese goods in February3.

A financial scandal came earlier. The Fanya Metal Exchange in China held large stocks of bismuth. In April 2015, its clients could not withdraw money from an investment product called Ri Jin Bao, which had promised more than 13% a year4. More than 220,000 investors had bought it, for about 43 billion yuan ($6.77 billion)4. In October the government of Yunnan Province ordered an official investigation4.

Workers and communities

The Nui Phao mine in Thai Nguyen Province, Vietnam, produces tungsten, fluorspar, bismuth and copper5. In 2016 local people complained about its effect on the environment, and the environment ministry planned an inspection6. Masan Resources, the owner, said that the company had strictly complied with environmental rules6.

In 2017 the ministry fined the mining company about $22,0005. Viet Nam News reports these findings of the inspection:

  • The company used land that was not planned for the project5.
  • Compensation and resettlement for local residents who had to move were behind schedule5.
  • The plant released toxic solvents into the environment5.

In China, part of the bismuth concentrate comes from artisanal mining with hand sorting1. We found no study of these miners’ conditions. In 2018 many bismuth smelters in China shut down under new environmental policies, some for a time and some permanently1.

In its 2020 criticality study, the EU found no specific social or economic issues for bismuth1.

Who gains and who loses

China became by far the largest producer. China merged producers in 2007, cut production and restricted exports. The EU says that this policy succeeded in tightening supply to the rest of the world1.

Buyers paid much more in 2025. That year the annual average price was almost four times that of 20243. In 2019, by contrast, the EU reported that suppliers in Europe worked at very low margins1.

Public debate

We found little public debate about bismuth itself. In the sources we read, the main topic is its use in place of lead. In the United States, lead limits for drinking-water pipes opened a market for bismuth in brass fittings7.

Sources

  1. 1

    European Commission (G.A. Blengini and others), 2020. Study on the EU's list of Critical Raw Materials (2020): Factsheets on Critical Raw Materials , Bismuth factsheet, pp. 96–107.

    Uses, supply chain, refining processes, market structure, prices, the 2007 consolidation in Hunan, tariffs and the Fanya exchange.

    • The US introduced a 10% import tariff on Chinese bismuth products in September 2018 and increased it to 25% in May 2019
    • The import duties forced suppliers to cut their offer prices during the first half of 2019 to stimulate export demand
    • In China, artisanal mining for bismuth also exists, with manual separation of bismuth-rich mineralization contributing significantly to global production of concentrates
    • New environmental policies that came into effect in China in 2018, resulted in many bismuth smelters shutting down temporarily for inspections or permanently for infractions
    • No specific issues were identified during data collection and stakeholders consultation
    • It succeeded in its objective to tighten supply to the rest of the world and become by far the leading producer in the following years
    • The bismuth price in Europe has fallen close to the cost of production; suppliers are now operating at very low margins
  2. 2

    Shanghai Metals Market (SMM), 2025. Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs: Export Controls Imposed on Tungsten, Tellurium, Bismuth, Molybdenum, and Indium-Related Items .

    An English text of Announcement No. 10 of 2025 of China's Ministry of Commerce and customs, with the controlled bismuth items and the stated reason.

    • III. Items Related to Bismuth
    • to safeguard national security and interests and fulfill international obligations such as non-proliferation
  3. 3

    U.S. Geological Survey (Kateryna Klochko), 2026. Bismuth, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 .

    World refinery production by country 2024 and 2025, US uses, imports and import reliance, prices, recycling, resources and substitutes.

    • owing to China issuing export controls on bismuth in response to the United States imposing 10% import tariffs on Chinese goods in February
    • The estimated annual average price in 2025 was $20 per pound, almost four times the price in 2024
  4. 4

    U.S. Geological Survey, 2017. Bismuth, in Minerals Yearbook 2015 .

    The collapse of the Fanya Metal Exchange, its bismuth stocks, the Nui Phao mine and the 2006 price rise.

    • Beginning in April, clients of the FME were unable to withdraw funds from the Ri Jin Bao investment product. The Ri Jin Bao had promised returns of more than 13% per year
    • Reportedly, more than 220,000 investors had purchased the Ri Jin Bao product, with a total estimated value of 43 billion yuan ($6.77 billion)
    • In October, the Yunnan Provincial government instructed the municipal government of Kunming to launch an official investigation into FME
  5. 5

    Viet Nam News, 2017. Việt Nam’s biggest polymetallic project fined for violations .

    The 2017 inspection of the Nui Phao mine, its findings and the fine.

    • the Núi Pháo project was permitted to exploit and process tungsten, fluorspar, bismuth and copper for 30 years, starting from 2004
    • will have to pay a fine of VNĐ510 million (US$22,000) for its violations
    • the company was found to have taken lands not planned for the project
    • Compensation and resettlement assistance to local residents dislocated by the project has been slow against the approved schedule
    • the factory emitted toxic solvents to environment
  6. 6

    DTiNews (Dan Tri), 2016. Nui Phao mine to face inspection over pollution claims .

    Complaints about the Nui Phao mine in 2016, the response of Masan Resources, and the history and ownership of the mine.

    • After receiving complaints from local people about the project’s environmental impact, MoNRE worked with the Thai Nguyen Provincial People’s Committee to prepare a comprehensive inspection plan
    • Masan’s press release on July 27 stated that the company has strictly complied with environmental rules
  7. 7

    Eimear Deady and others, British Geological Survey (Ore Geology Reviews 143, 104722), 2022. Bismuth: Economic geology and value chains .

    Crustal abundance, minerals, deposit types, the Nui Phao and Tasna mines, mine production, reserves, uses, recycling and smelter penalties. Open access copy in the NERC archive.

    • opened a wider market for bismuth as a metallurgical additive to lead-free pipe fittings, fixtures and water meters