Tennessine: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
We found no dispute about the discovery of tennessine. The questions were about cooperation between the United States and Russia, and about credit. The name honors the Tennessee region. Oak Ridge said that 61 of its people played a role6.
Tennessine is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →
Last updated 15 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
We found no competing claim for element 117. In 2016 the joint working party of IUPAC and IUPAP credited the Dubna, Livermore and Oak Ridge collaborations1. Its main evidence was a cross reaction. Tennessine-293 decays into moscovium-289, and Dubna made moscovium-289 directly from americium as well. The two sets of decays agreed1.
The working party also named a limit. Like other hot fusion elements, tennessine decays into nuclei that were not known before. The working party called for direct methods to measure the atomic number1.
Science News wrote in 2010 that the work joined two formerly secret nuclear weapons laboratories, in the United States and Russia2. This cooperation has stopped, and the power chapter gives the dates. Dawn Shaughnessy, who led this research at Livermore, called the end of the work very heartbreaking3.
Workers and communities
Only research staff work with tennessine, one atom at a time. Other staff handle the radioactive berkelium-249 for the targets, in shielded hot cells and glove boxes4. The berkelium page has more. We found no report of an injury or illness from this work.
Who gains and who loses
We found no source on income from tennessine. The gains that sources report are credit and recognition. Oak Ridge said in 2016 that its main role was to make the berkelium-2495. Julie Ezold of Oak Ridge said that 61 people from the laboratory played a role. Physics Today wrote that they were an equal mix of operations staff, support staff and researchers6. One of them, Clarice Phelps, is thought to be the first African American woman to help discover a chemical element6.
The state of Tennessee took the name as an honor. In 2016 Governor Bill Haslam thanked IUPAC on behalf of all Tennesseans5. In 2017 UT-Battelle, the company that runs Oak Ridge, gave new periodic tables to more than 1,000 public schools in Tennessee7.
Public debate
IUPAC put the proposed names out for public comment for five months in 2016. IUPAC reported many comments8. Some people proposed other names, in some cases with petitions8. IUPAC did not accept them, because only the discoverers can propose a name8. Chemists also said that Ts is a common abbreviation for the tosyl group. IUPAC decided that the context makes the meaning clear8.
Sources
- 1
P. J. Karol, R. C. Barber, B. M. Sherrill, E. Vardaci and T. Yamazaki (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 88(1-2), 139-153, 2016. Discovery of the elements with atomic numbers Z = 113, 115 and 117 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Section 3.2 (Z = 115), section 3.3 (Z = 117) and Summary.
The working party's review of the Dubna experiments of 2010, 2012 and 2013, the cross reaction with element 115, and the verdict. The publisher refuses scripts; the text was read with Firecrawl.
-
are credited with the discoveries of elements 115 and 117
-
A convincing case in cross reaction producing 289115 and 285113 from both 48Ca+249Bk and 48Ca+243Am is demonstrated in the top of the previous table.
-
As a result a large group of super heavy nuclides are now on an island without connection to the main peninsula of known nuclei
-
We encourage development of direct physical methods to determine
-
- 2
Alexandra Witze, Science News, 2010. The backstory behind a new element , 12 April 2010.
How the berkelium for element 117 was obtained, its cost and its shipment to Russia.
-
formerly secret nuclear weapons laboratories in the United States and Russia
-
- 3
Felicity Nelson, ACS Central Science 10(9), 1669 (C&EN), 2024. How Japan Took the Lead in the Race to Discover Element 119 , 15 August 2024.
The end of the agreement between Lawrence Livermore and JINR in 2017.
-
It was very heartbreaking because we’re scientists and we just want to do science.
-
- 4
James B. Roberto, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Progress in Nuclear Science and Technology 5, 14-18, 2018. The discovery of element 117 , Abstract, Table 1, sections 2.1 to 2.3 and 3.
How Oak Ridge made the berkelium-249, how the target was made and irradiated, the atoms of element 117 made to date, and the heaviest nuclei.
-
REDC is a large complex of heavily-shielded hot cells
-
in a glove box and shipped to Dubna
-
- 5
Oak Ridge National Laboratory, 2016. 'Tennessine' acknowledges state institutions' roles in element's discovery , 30 November 2016.
The naming of tennessine, the role of Oak Ridge's berkelium-249, the six months of beam, the partners, and the reason for the ending -ine. Read with Firecrawl because the site refused the script.
-
ORNL had several roles in the discovery, the most prominent being production of the radioisotope berkelium-249 for the search.
-
On behalf of all Tennesseans we thank this world body for honoring our state this way.
-
- 6
Claire Jarvis, Physics Today (American Institute of Physics), 2019. The overlooked element makers , 30 September 2019, DOI 10.1063/PT.6.4.20190930a.
The people at Oak Ridge who purified the berkelium, the shipments of June 2009 and of 2012, and the 61 people credited. The article places Dimitrovgrad in Serbia; it is in Russia, so only the date of the 2009 shipment is used from that sentence.
-
61 people from Oak Ridge played a role in the discovery of tennessine, an equal mix of operations staff, support personnel, and researchers
-
She is thought to be the first African American woman to help discover a chemical element.
-
61 people from Oak Ridge played a role in the discovery of tennessine
-
- 7
Oak Ridge National Laboratory, on Newswise, 2017. Haslam Visits ORNL to Highlight State's Role in Discovering Tennessine , 27 January 2017.
The ceremony at Oak Ridge, the periodic tables for schools, the governor's statements and the role of Vanderbilt.
-
is marking the discovery by providing more than 1,000 public middle schools and high schools in Tennessee with new charts of the periodic table
-
- 8
International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry, 2016. IUPAC Announces the Names of the Elements 113, 115, 117, and 118 , 30 November 2016.
The approval of the name tennessine on 28 November 2016, the proposers, the reason for the name and the ending -ine.
-
Comments from the general public, during the 5 month period were many.
-
comments were received suggesting other names, in some cases accompanied by petitions from large groups of people
-
only the discoverers have the right to propose names and symbols
-
Ts is one of the two commonly used abbreviations for the tosyl group
-
makes the meaning unambiguous
-