Who controls tennessine
Who controls the supply, and who depends on it?
Nobody controls a supply, because there is none. The berkelium for every experiment came from one reactor at Oak Ridge in the United States1. The atoms were made in Russia and Germany.
Tennessine is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →
Last updated 15 October 2026.
How concentrated supply is
Tennessine has been made in two accelerator laboratories: JINR in Dubna, Russia, and GSI in Darmstadt, Germany. The work needs two rare materials: a beam of calcium-48, an enriched isotope of calcium, and a target of berkelium-249. Oak Ridge said in 2016 that the berkelium for element 117 was available only from its High Flux Isotope Reactor1. Oak Ridge provided it as a US contribution to the experiments1.
Who depends on it
The users are a few research groups in nuclear physics. The paper of 2010 had authors from four US institutions and two Russian ones. Among them were JINR, the University of Nevada Las Vegas and a reactor institute in Dimitrovgrad2. Lawrence Livermore analyzed the data of the beam collisions to check the Dubna search3. The GSI team of 2014 came from Australia, Finland, Germany, India, Japan, Norway, Poland, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States4.
How governments treat it
| List | On the list |
|---|---|
| EU critical raw materials (2023) | No Tennessine is not on the EU list of critical raw materials in Annex II of the Critical Raw Materials Act. 5 |
| EU strategic raw materials (2023) | No Tennessine is not on the EU list of strategic raw materials in Annex I. 5 |
| US critical minerals (USGS, 2025) | No The 2025 US list is in alphabetical order. Tennessine is not on it. 6 |
| US critical materials for energy (DOE) | No Tennessine is not one of the DOE critical materials for energy. 7 |
| UK critical minerals (2024) | No The UK assessment of 2024 left out radionuclides, so tennessine was not assessed. 8 |
| Canada critical minerals (2024) | No Tennessine is not one of the 34. 9 |
Tennessine is not on the critical materials lists of the EU, the United States or the United Kingdom. The UK left radioactive materials out of its 2024 assessment.
Governments pay for the work. In the United States, the Department of Energy decides who receives berkelium10. Shipments need many approvals. An Oak Ridge physicist, Krzysztof Rykaczewski, said in 2010 that the transfer of 36 curies of berkelium to Russia went through a lot of desks11. The curie is a unit of radioactivity. The authors of the GSI paper of 2019 name funders in Germany, Australia, Sweden and the United States12.
The cooperation between the United States and Russia that made tennessine has stopped. C&EN wrote that the collaboration of Livermore, Oak Ridge and JINR broke down in 201713. That year the US Department of State refused to renew Livermore’s agreement with JINR13. C&EN gives no reason for the decision. Science gives a later date. It reported in 2024 that the US collaboration was suspended after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine14. The superheavy elements page has more.
Sources
- 1
Oak Ridge National Laboratory, 2016. 'Tennessine' acknowledges state institutions' roles in element's discovery , 30 November 2016.
The naming of tennessine, the role of Oak Ridge's berkelium-249, the six months of beam, the partners, and the reason for the ending -ine. Read with Firecrawl because the site refused the script.
-
which was available only from ORNL’s High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR)
-
was provided as a U.S. contribution to those experiments
-
- 2
Yu. Ts. Oganessian and others, JINR Dubna, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, University of Nevada Las Vegas, Vanderbilt University, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and RIAR Dimitrovgrad; Physical Review Letters 104, 142502, 2010. Synthesis of a New Element with Atomic Number Z = 117 , Abstract; pages 142502-1 and 142502-2.
The first report of element 117, the berkelium target, the beam and its dates, and the six decay chains. Free copy on the APS Physics site.
-
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, RU-141980 Dubna, Russian Federation
-
University of Nevada Las Vegas, Las Vegas, Nevada 89154, USA
-
Research Institute of Atomic Reactors, RU-433510 Dimitrovgrad, Russian Federation
-
- 3
U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, 2011. Nations Work Together to Discover New Element .
The partners in the discovery, the irradiation, processing and beam times, the role of Livermore and Vanderbilt, and Roberto's comments on uses.
-
analyzed data from the calcium-48 beam collisions
-
- 4
Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (press release, with GSI), 2014. Superheavy Element 117 Confirmed - On the Way to the Island of Stability , 2 May 2014, pages 1 and 2.
The confirmation at GSI, the size of the team, the 13 milligrams of berkelium sent to Mainz and the new isotopes in the decay chains.
-
from 16 institutions in Australia, Finland, Germany, India, Japan, Norway, Poland, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the United States
-
- 5
European Parliament and Council of the European Union, 2024. Regulation (EU) 2024/1252 establishing a framework for ensuring a secure and sustainable supply of critical raw materials (Critical Raw Materials Act) .
-
(u) manganese (v) graphite (w) nickel
-
(i) magnesium metal (j) manganese
-
- 6
U.S. Geological Survey (Federal Register vol. 90, no. 214), 2025. Final 2025 List of Critical Minerals .
The 60 minerals on the final 2025 US list of critical minerals.
-
manganese, metallurgical coal, neodymium
-
- 7
U.S. Department of Energy, 2023. Notice of Final Determination on 2023 DOE Critical Materials List (preprint) .
The US Department of Energy list of critical materials for energy, 2023.
-
Critical materials for energy: aluminum, cobalt, copper
-
- 8
UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre, British Geological Survey, 2024. UK 2024 Criticality Assessment , Section 2.1, materials left out of the assessment.
The UK assessment of 2024 left out radionuclides, so it gives no result and no recycling rate for tennessine.
-
highly processed materials, such as radionuclides
-
- 9
Natural Resources Canada, 2024. Critical minerals: an opportunity for Canada .
Canada's list of 34 critical minerals (2021, updated June 2024).
-
critical minerals list identifies 34 minerals and metals
-
- 10
Claire Jarvis, Physics Today (American Institute of Physics), 2019. The overlooked element makers , 30 September 2019, DOI 10.1063/PT.6.4.20190930a.
The people at Oak Ridge who purified the berkelium, the shipments of June 2009 and of 2012, and the 61 people credited. The article places Dimitrovgrad in Serbia; it is in Russia, so only the date of the 2009 shipment is used from that sentence.
-
The US Department of Energy has the final say over who gets what.
-
- 11
Alexandra Witze, Science News, 2010. The backstory behind a new element , 12 April 2010.
How the berkelium for element 117 was obtained, its cost and its shipment to Russia.
-
When you’re transferring 36 curies [a measure of radioactivity] of berkelium to Russia, you go through a lot of desks
-
- 12
J. Khuyagbaatar, A. Yakushev, Ch. E. Düllmann and others; Physical Review C 99, 054306 (record and abstract at Oak Ridge National Laboratory), 2019. Fusion reaction 48Ca + 249Bk leading to formation of the element Ts (Z = 117) , Abstract and funding note, published 7 May 2019.
The full GSI results, with two long and two short decay chains, and the funders.
-
This work was financially supported in part by the German BMBF
-
the Australian Research Council, the Swedish Research Council
-
the U.S. Department of Energy by LLNL
-
- 13
Felicity Nelson, ACS Central Science 10(9), 1669 (C&EN), 2024. How Japan Took the Lead in the Race to Discover Element 119 , 15 August 2024.
The end of the agreement between Lawrence Livermore and JINR in 2017.
-
the prolific LLNL-ORNL-JINR collaboration, broke down
-
LLNL’s request to renew a longstanding memorandum of understanding with the Russian institution was denied by the US Department of State
-
- 14
Robert F. Service, Science, 2024. U.S. back in race to forge unknown, superheavy elements , 23 July 2024. Read with Firecrawl; the site refuses scripts..
The suspension of the US collaboration with JINR after Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
-
the U.S. collaboration was suspended after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine
-