Silver: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Spain took silver from Potosí in Bolivia with the forced labor of Indigenous people. Children still work in Bolivian mines, by US government findings. In Guatemala, a court stopped a large silver mine in 2017 for lack of consultation.
Last updated 13 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Escobal is a silver mine in Guatemala. Its owner, Pan American Silver, calls it one of the largest primary silver deposits in the world1. The company writes that the mine produced about 20 million troy ounces a year from 2014 to 20171. Metals Focus records 27.0 million troy ounces from Guatemala in 2016, 10.8 million in 2017, and none since2.
The mine stopped in 2017. MiningWatch Canada and Earthworks, two advocacy groups, write that local communities set up roadside camps to stop all mine traffic. After that, a court suspended the mine for discrimination and lack of prior consultation3. Pan American writes that the Constitutional Court suspended the license until the government consults the Xinka people under ILO Convention 1691. The company says that it fully respects this process1.
In May 2025 the Xinka Parliament refused consent to reopen the mine3. The two groups call this the end of the consultation that the Constitutional Court ordered in 20183. Pan American writes that the consultation is still in its second phase, and that the mine is on care and maintenance11. The two groups write that many residents of La Cuchilla were forcibly displaced after damage to their homes. The residents blame vibrations from the mine3. The company and the government deny a connection3.
Workers and communities
Potosí in Bolivia was the main colonial source of silver for Spain. UNESCO writes that by the 17th century 13,500 Indigenous people were forced to work in its mines under the mita system4. Mining there still continues4.
The US Department of Labor reports that children in Bolivia do dangerous work in mining. It lists the mining of gold, silver, tin, lead and zinc, which Bolivian law classes as hazardous work for children5. In 2024, 117 Bolivian labor inspectors made 2,103 inspections and found no child labor violations5. The Department writes that too few inspectors and poor transport make it hard to inspect mines5.
Who gains and who loses
High prices in 2025 helped producers. Metals Focus writes that costs at primary silver mines fell, mostly because of higher by-product credits from record gold prices2. Buyers paid more. Metals Focus writes that the price rise disrupted the profit structure of solar cell makers2. Jewelry demand fell 8% in 2025, with the largest fall in India, the biggest maker22.
Investors who held silver gained. Coin and bar demand rose 14% in 2025, by Metals Focus figures2.
Public debate
Sources
- 1
Pan American Silver, 2026. Escobal .
The company's account of the Escobal mine, its output from 2014 to 2017, the court ruling and the ILO 169 consultation.
-
It is one of the largest primary silver deposits globally
-
When in operation from 2014 to 2017, the mine produced approximately 20 million ounces of silver annually
-
The court suspended the mine’s operating license until the Guatemalan government completes an ILO 169 consultation with the Xinka Indigenous Peoples.
-
At Pan American, we fully respect this process.
-
The consultation process is currently in Phase 2.
-
On Care and Maintenance
-
- 2
The Silver Institute (prepared by Metals Focus), 2026. World Silver Survey 2026 , Summary; Chapter 2 (Market Outlook); Chapter 4 (Mine Supply, Primary Silver Production Costs); Chapter 6 (Bullion flows); Chapter 7 (Industrial & Photography, PV focus box); Appendix 1 (tons).
World supply and demand of silver by use, 2017 to 2025, mine supply by source metal, costs, prices and trade in 2025. The Silver Institute is an association of the silver industry.
-
Guatemala 27.0 10.8
-
This was largely attributed to higher by-product credits from record gold prices.
-
disrupted the profit structure of cell manufacturing, with silver
-
global silver jewelry fabrication declined by 8%
-
with the biggest fabricator, India, recording the steepest decline
-
coin and net bar demand rebounded by 14%
-
- 3
MiningWatch Canada and Earthworks, 2025. Xinka People Say 'No' to the Escobal Mine .
Press release of two advocacy groups on the Xinka decision about the Escobal silver mine in Guatemala, 8 May 2025.
-
In mid-2017, communities organized two ongoing 24-hour roadside camps to stop all mine traffic, after which the court ordered the mine suspended for discrimination and lack of prior consultation.
-
The Xinka People denied consent for the Escobal mine
-
The announcement signals the conclusion of a formal consultation process ordered by the Constitutional Court of Guatemala in 2018.
-
many residents were forcibly displaced from the nearby community of La Cuchilla after damage to their homes, church and road that they attribute to vibrations from the mine
-
The company and the Guatemalan government deny any connection between this damage and the mine.
-
- 4
UNESCO World Heritage Centre, 2026. City of Potosí .
Potosí as a colonial silver mine, forced labor under the mita, the patio process with mercury, and the damage to Cerro Rico. Read with Firecrawl.
-
By the 17th century there were 160,000 colonists living in Potosí along with 13,500 Indians who were forced to work in the mines under the system of <em>mita</em> (mandatory labour).
-
which slowed significantly after 1800 but still continues
-
- 5
US Department of Labor, Bureau of International Labor Affairs, 2025. 2024 Findings on the Worst Forms of Child Labor: Bolivia .
Child labor in the mining of silver and other metals in Bolivia, and labor inspections in 2024. Read with Firecrawl.
-
Children also perform dangerous tasks in agriculture and mining.
-
Mining† of gold, silver, tin, lead, and zinc … Determined by national law or regulation as hazardous
-
In 2024, <strong>117</strong> labor inspectors conducted <strong>2,103</strong> worksite inspections, finding <strong>0</strong> child labor violations.
-
a lack of inspectors and logistical barriers, such as transportation issues to access the mining sector and the Amazon region, hinder the Ministry of Labor’s work
-
- 6
U.S. Geological Survey (William E. Brooks), 2013. Silver, in Metal Prices in the United States Through 2010 (Scientific Investigations Report 2012-5188) , Silver (Ag), pp. 167 to 169.
The history of silver as money and the US silver price to 2010, ores, properties and industrial uses.
-
With the ending of the relationship between silver and the U.S. monetary system in 1968
-
In 1967, silver coins were withdrawn from circulation, and holders of silver certificates were given 1 year, until June 24, 1968, to redeem the certificates for silver
-
an attempt by a group of investors to … the silver market
-