Oxygen: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Authorities in Europe, Brazil and Peru fined gas companies for oxygen cartels. Brazilian courts later annulled the Brazilian fine. Oxygen fires have killed astronauts and patients. A 2025 Lancet commission estimated that 5 billion people lack affordable medical oxygen.
Last updated 5 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
The main disputes about oxygen are about prices and competition.
In 2002 the European Commission fined seven gas companies a total of EUR 25.72 million. It found that they had run a secret cartel in the Netherlands from 1993 to 19971. The Commission stated that the companies colluded to keep the prices of oxygen and other gases high1.
In September 2010 Brazil’s competition authority, CADE, fined five gas companies a total of BRL 2.94 billion for a cartel in hospital and industrial gases2. Later that month, CADE lowered the total to BRL 2.33 billion. It had used the wrong method to calculate interest3. The fine for White Martins, the largest, fell to BRL 1.76 billion3. In December 2010, the press reported a preliminary order by a judge in Minas Gerais. It required the companies to pay damages to private and charity hospitals in that state4. An economic study was to set the amount later4. White Martins said it would appeal, because it disagreed with the order. It also said that it stays committed to free competition4.
In September 2015, a federal judge in Brasília annulled the fine against White Martins5. The judge found the evidence unlawful. It came from phone taps that started only on anonymous reports5. In 2017, CADE stated that the regional federal court had upheld the annulment for all the companies. CADE said that it would appeal to the higher courts6. White Martins stated that the 2015 decision showed that it had not broken competition law6. We found no later court decision.
In Peru, the social security system EsSalud claimed in 2003 that two liquid oxygen companies had fixed prices in public tenders7. The companies appealed against the procedure in 20107. In 2013 a competition court found a very serious infringement7. Peru’s Supreme Court confirmed the fine of almost $7 million in 20207. The source does not name the two companies, and we found no statement from them.
Workers and communities
In January 1967, a fire killed the three Apollo 1 astronauts during a ground test. NASA had filled the cabin with pure oxygen at 16.7 pounds per square inch8. NASA gives the pure oxygen atmosphere as one reason why the fire spread very fast8.
In April 2021, a fire at the Ibn Khatib hospital for Covid-19 patients in Baghdad killed scores of people and injured more than 1009. UN News wrote that, according to reports, an oxygen tank explosion caused it9.
We found no source on work safety in air separation plants as a group.
Who gains and who loses
Patients without oxygen lose most. The Lancet commission authors estimate that 5 billion people, 60% of the world’s population, do not have access to affordable, high-quality medical oxygen7. In low- and middle-income countries, they estimate that only 30% of the people who need oxygen for acute conditions get enough7.
The Covid-19 pandemic made the gap larger. In a study of 64 intensive care units in sub-Saharan Africa, 45% of the patients who died of Covid-19 never received oxygen7.
In India before the pandemic, about 1,000 tonnes of oxygen a day was available for medical use. In early May 2021, the need was 8,943 tonnes a day10. The government moved oxygen from industry to hospitals10. Railways ran about 477 Oxygen Express trains and delivered more than 35,000 tonnes of liquid oxygen10.
The Lancet commission authors and the gas industry give different reasons for the gap. The authors write that the liquid oxygen industry had shown little interest in new health-care markets in these countries7. From the industry side, they report that governments’ focus on low prices in procurement is a barrier to investment7. After talks in 2020 and 2021, Unitaid and the Clinton Health Access Initiative signed agreements with Air Liquide, Linde and later Global Gases7.
Public debate
Public debate about medical oxygen grew during the Covid-19 pandemic. In February 2021, Unitaid and the Wellcome Trust led a new task force on oxygen shortages7. The Lancet commission of 2025 made medical oxygen security its subject. Its authors call for open tenders, published prices and support for new suppliers7.
Atmospheric oxygen gets less public attention. Scripps scientists measure its slow decline and state that it is too small to affect human health11.
Sources
- 1
European Commission, 2002. Commission fines seven companies in Dutch industrial gases cartel (IP/02/1139) .
Press release of 24 July 2002. The URL is the Commission's own press corner service, which returns the text as data.
-
fined seven producers of industrial and medical gases a total of € 25.72 million for participating in a secret cartel in the Netherlands between September 1993 and December 1997
-
oxygen, nitrogen, carbon dioxide and argon for which the cartel members colluded to keep prices high
-
- 2
Consultor Jurídico (Conjur), 2010. Cade aplica multa de R$ 2,22 bilhões contra White Martins por cartel .
Legal news report of 1 September 2010 on the CADE cartel fines. In Portuguese.
-
empresas de gases hospitalares e industriais, condenadas por formação de quartel, deverão desembolsar R$ 2,94 bilhões
-
- 3
Martha Beck, O Globo, 2010. Multa a empresas do setor de gases hospitalares condenadas por cartel encolhe .
News report of 22 September 2010. CADE lowers the cartel fines to BRL 2.33 billion in total. In Portuguese.
-
A punição de R$ 2,94 bilhões - a maior já aplicada na história do Cade - foi reduzida para R$ 2,33 bilhões
-
a multa da White Martins, por exemplo, que havia sido de R$ 2,18 bilhões (a maior entre as empresas) , caiu para R$ 1,76 bilhão
-
- 4
Agência Estado, in Gazeta do Povo, 2010. White Martins recorrerá de decisão sobre cartel .
News report of 3 December 2010 with White Martins' statement. In Portuguese.
-
determina que as empresas condenadas pelo Conselho Administrativo de Defesa Econômica (Cade) por formação de
-
O valor para recompor esses custos será definido após uma perícia econômica
-
irá recorrer da decisão por discordar do seu conteúdo … A empresa reafirma seu compromisso com a livre concorrência
-
- 5
Mario Cesar Carvalho, Folha de S.Paulo, 2015. Justiça manda anular maior multa da história do Cade .
News report of 16 September 2015. A federal court in Brasília annuls the fine against White Martins. In Portuguese.
-
anulou a maior multa já aplicada na história do Cade
-
foram coletadas depois que foram feitas interceptações telefônicas que tinham como base apenas denúncias anônimas
-
- 6
Adriano Nogueira, O Povo, 2017. Cartel de gases deve ser julgado no STJ e STF .
News report of 13 March 2017, with statements from CADE and White Martins on the appeals. In Portuguese.
-
para reverter a decisão do Tribunal Regional Federal da 1ª Região, que manteve a sentença que considerou nula a decisão do órgão antitruste
-
o que indica que a companhia não cometeu infração à ordem econômica
-
- 7
Hamish R Graham and others, The Lancet Global Health 13, 2025. Reducing global inequities in medical oxygen access: the Lancet Global Health Commission on medical oxygen security .
Medical oxygen need and access, the market for medical oxygen, the Peru case, and history.
-
In January, 2003, EsSalud … the social security system of Peru … claimed that two liquid oxygen companies had entered into agreements to restrict competition and fix prices
-
In 2010, the procedure was declared valid, and appealed by the liquid oxygen companies
-
In 2013, the Court for the Defence of Competition and Intellectual Property concluded that the two companies had incurred a very serious infringement
-
The companies were fined the equivalent of almost US$7 million, but it was not until 2020 that the Peruvian Supreme Court ratified the sanction imposed
-
5 billion people … 60% of the world’s population … do not have access to affordable, high-quality medical oxygen services
-
In LMICs, only 89 million (30%) of the 299 million people who need oxygen for acute medical or surgical conditions receive adequate oxygen therapy
-
In a study of 64 intensive care units (ICUs) in sub-Saharan Africa, 634 (45%) of the 1416 patients who died from COVID-19 never received oxygen
-
The liquid oxygen industry had shown little interest in serving new health-care markets in these settings previously
-
From the industry perspective, the prioritisation of low prices in government procurements acts as a barrier to investment
-
Unitaid and the Clinton Health Access Initiative signed memorandums of understanding with the liquid oxygen companies Air Liquide, Linde, and, later, Global Gases
-
in response to the rapidly escalating COVID-19 oxygen shortages. In February, 2021, the ACT-A Oxygen Emergency Taskforce, co-chaired by Unitaid and the Wellcome Trust, was announced
-
Governments and global health agencies can increase competition by conducting open, competitive tenders for procurement of oxygen equipment and contract services, and by publishing contractual terms and prices
-
- 8
NASA History, 2022. 55 Years Ago: The Apollo 1 Fire and its Aftermath .
The pure oxygen cabin atmosphere in the Apollo 1 fire of 1967.
-
pressurized it with pure oxygen at 16.7 pounds per square inch (psi)
-
Because of the pure oxygen atmosphere, pressurized to 16.7 psi – two pounds above atmospheric pressure and a larger-than-allowable amount of flammable material in the spacecraft – the fire spread very rapidly
-
- 9
UN News, 2021. Iraq: UN representative calls for ‘stronger protection measures’ after fatal fire in COVID hospital .
The April 2021 fire at the Ibn Khatib hospital in Baghdad.
-
the scores of people who lost their lives during a blaze that erupted at the Ibn Khatib hospital on Saturday night and wished the 100-plus injured
-
According to reports, the accident was caused by the explosion of an oxygen tank
-
- 10
Moonis Mirza and others, Indian Journal of Community Medicine, 2023. India’s Multi-Sectoral Response to Oxygen Surge Demand during COVID-19 Pandemic: A Scoping Review .
Oxygen production and medical demand in India before and during the 2021 Covid-19 wave, and the government's response.
-
only 1000 MT was available for medical usage … 8943 MT in early May 2021
-
diverting industrial oxygen into MO and restricting industrial oxygen use
-
Around 477 Oxygen Expresses delivered more than 35000 MT of LMO
-
- 11
Scripps O2 Program, Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UC San Diego, 2026. Scripps O2 Global Oxygen Measurements .
The global decrease of atmospheric oxygen and its cause.
-
The changes are too small to have an impact on human health
-