Nihonium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
RIKEN in Japan and JINR in Dubna, Russia, both claimed element 113. IUPAC gave the credit to RIKEN in 2015. JINR called the decision unexpected but said that it respected it4.
Nihonium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →
Last updated 15 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Two teams claimed element 113. RIKEN made nihonium-278 by cold fusion of zinc and bismuth. JINR, with Lawrence Livermore, saw nihonium-284 and nihonium-283 as decay products of element 115 (see the history chapter). RIKEN claimed priority in 2006 and in 2007, on the basis of its first two atoms1.
In 2011 the IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party rejected both claims. It called the RIKEN work “very promising”. But it found too few events, no firm link to known nuclei and some inconsistencies2. The Dubna results also did not meet the criteria. The reasons were too few events, no links to known nuclei and no cross-bombardments2.
In its 2016 report the working party gave priority to RIKEN3. It wrote that the Dubna measurements of 2004 and 2007 could not fix the atomic number beyond reasonable doubt. It also found the chemistry tests used at Dubna unpersuasive3.
JINR answered in January 2016. It wrote that it had first recorded element 113 in 2003, and that GSI and Berkeley had confirmed its isotope nihonium-2844. It called the decision “somewhat unexpected”. It noted that IUPAC had shared the credit for elements 103, 104 and 105 between Dubna and Berkeley4. JINR also wrote that the RIKEN method of making superheavy elements was “completely exhausted”4. It said that it respected the decision of IUPAC and would decide its position after the reports were published4.
We found no dispute about the name nihonium.
Workers and communities
Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with nihonium, one atom at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from nihonium.
Who gains and who loses
We found no source on income from nihonium. The gains that we found are prestige and money for research. RIKEN called nihonium the first element found in Asia5. In 2016 Morita said that until then only research groups in western countries had discovered new elements6. The research group was chosen for the Asahi Prize7. RIKEN also received a supplementary budget of 4 billion yen to upgrade its accelerator (see the power chapter).
Sources
- 1
RIKEN (press release in Japanese, 27 September 2012), 2012. 3個目の113番元素の合成を新たな崩壊経路で確認 (A third atom of element 113 confirmed by a new decay path) .
The beam time of 553 days, the mass of zinc used, the claims of priority in 2006 and 2007, the funding and the spinning target. Quotes are in Japanese; the text gives the translation.
-
2006年と2007年に113番元素発見の優先権を主張していますが
-
- 2
R. C. Barber, P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, E. Vardaci and E. W. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 83(7), 1485-1498, 2011. Discovery of the elements with atomic numbers greater than or equal to 113 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Section Z = 113, items 113;01 to 113;03, and the Summary.
The 2011 assessment that neither the RIKEN nor the Dubna claim for element 113 met the criteria.
-
The work of the collaboration of Morita et al. is very promising but has not
-
The results are encouraging but do not meet the criteria for discovery because of the paucity of events, the lack of connections to known nuclides, and the
-
- 3
P. J. Karol, R. C. Barber, B. M. Sherrill, E. Vardaci and T. Yamazaki (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 88(1-2), 139-153, 2016. Discovery of the elements with atomic numbers Z = 113, 115 and 117 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Section 3.1, Z = 113, the JWP assessments, and the Summary.
The 2016 assessment that gave the credit for element 113 to RIKEN, with the reasons, the dates of the Dubna and RIKEN papers and the GSI and Dubna work of 2013. Read with Firecrawl; the publisher refuses scripts.
-
Priority for the discovery has been fulfilled by the RIKEN collaboration.
-
But, the 2004 and 2007 Dubna physical measurements were not able to within reasonable doubt determine
-
Chemistry probes that had been employed in previous experiments remain unpersuasive in their ability to assure the
-
- 4
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (JINR), Dubna, 2016. Discovery of the new chemical elements with numbers 113, 115, 117 and 118 , Section 'Regarding the discovery of the element 113'.
The position of JINR on the credit for element 113.
-
has been registered for the first time in 2003 in JINR
-
The fact of synthesis of the isotope of element 113 with the mass 284 was confirmed in GSI (Germany) and Berkeley (USA)
-
there are enough precedents of acknowledging
-
the method of synthesizing the superheavy elements, chosen by RIKEN researchers is completely exhausted
-
We respect the decision of IUPAC.
-
To us, this is somewhat unexpected decision.
-
- 5
RIKEN (press release, 31 December 2015), 2015. It's official! Element 113 was discovered at RIKEN .
The start of the search in 2003, the dates of the three atoms, the experiments, the gap of seven years and the plans for element 119.
-
has become the first element on the periodic table found in Asia
-
- 6
RIKEN (news, 8 June 2016), 2016. IUPAC begins Public Review of nihonium and Nh, the proposed name and symbol for the new element 113 .
Kosuke Morita's reasons for the name and his view that only western groups had discovered elements before.
-
only research groups in western countries have discovered new elements
-
- 7
Hideto En'yo, Director, RIKEN Nishina Center for Accelerator-Based Science, 2017. Preface, RIKEN Accelerator Progress Report vol. 50 .
Nishina's element 93 of 1940, the ceremony of March 2017, the memorial monument, the Asahi Prize and the budget for the RILAC upgrade.
-
the Asahi Prize will be given to the Element 113 Research Group
-