Nickel: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
The fast growth in Indonesia brought investment, and also deaths at work and protests over damage to nature. A furnace explosion at Morowali in December 2023 killed 20 people, by a police count. Low prices closed mines in Australia. Unrest cut New Caledonia's output in 2024.
Last updated 10 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
In 2024 there was widespread unrest in New Caledonia, a French territory with large nickel mines. By USGS estimates, its mine production fell by 52%. USGS names the unrest and low prices as the causes1. In 2025 production rose again2.
In Indonesia, there are disputes about the effect of mines on nature and on indigenous people. The International Energy Agency (IEA) reports that Indonesia revoked four nickel mining permits in Raja Ampat, after protests, because of environmental violations3. The IEA also reports that, in September 2025, Norway’s state pension fund sold its shares in the French company Eramet. The reason given was alleged environmental damage and violations of indigenous rights at the Weda Bay nickel mine3.
Workers and communities
On 24 December 2023 a furnace exploded at the stainless steel plant of Indonesia Tsingshan Stainless Steel (ITSS), in the Indonesia Morowali Industrial Park. By 3 January 2024, the police counted 20 dead: 12 Indonesian and 8 foreign workers. Another 29 people had severe injuries44. The police chief said that the investigation suggested violations of operating procedures by staff4. Four days later, a fire broke out at another nickel smelter, of Gunbuster Nickel Industri4. President Joko Widodo asked for stricter checks of smelters4.
Strikes have shaped the industry before. In 1969, long strikes stopped the nickel, copper and iron ore industries of Canada, then the largest producer5. A strike at Inco’s mines in Sudbury lasted from September 1978 to June 19795.
Who gains and who loses
Indonesia’s policy brought processing into the country. USGS reports that the ban on ore exports led to the building of smelters6. The International Nickel Study Group (INSG) says that the growth came from investment backed by China7.
Producers in other countries lost. The IEA says that the large supply from Indonesia made projects in other countries unprofitable3.
Buyers of nickel paid less. The average LME price fell from $25,815 per tonne in 2022 to about $15,000 in 20252.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Geological Survey, 2025. Nickel, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2025 , p. 2, Events, Trends, and Issues.
Prices and events in 2024, including the unrest in New Caledonia.
-
In New Caledonia, production decreased by an estimated 52% owing to widespread unrest in addition to reduced global nickel prices
-
- 2
U.S. Geological Survey (A.A. Stewart), 2026. Nickel, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , p. 1, Domestic Production and Use, Salient Statistics, Recycling; p. 2, Events, Trends, and Issues, World Mine Production and Reserves, World Resources, Substitutes, footnotes.
World mine production and reserves by country, LME prices, US production, recycling and imports, the market surplus, sea-floor deposits, substitutes.
-
In New Caledonia, production increased as a result of more consistent operating conditions after the interruptions in 2024
-
25,815 11.71 21,495 9.75 16,812 7.63 15,000 6.90
-
- 3
International Energy Agency, 2026. Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026 , Chapter 2, Outlook for nickel (pp. 145 to 154); Annex, nickel demand and supply tables (pp. 353 to 355); Chapter 1, pp. 33, 97, 98, 133.
Demand by use in 2021 and 2025, mined and refined supply by country, Indonesia's quotas and ore prices, sulfur costs, reserves, recycling, permits revoked in Raja Ampat, outlook to 2040.
-
In Indonesia, four nickel mining permits were revoked in Raja Ampat over environmental violations after public protests
-
In September 2025, Norway’s state pension fund divested its stake in Eramet over alleged environmental damage and indigenous rights violations at the PT Weda Bay nickel
-
drove the market into sustained oversupply, rendering projects around the world uneconomical
-
- 4
Jakarta Globe (Muhammad Fakhruddin), 2024. Death Toll Rises to 20 in Morowali Steel Furnace Explosion .
The furnace explosion of 24 December 2023 at ITSS in the Indonesia Morowali Industrial Park; the police count of the dead and injured.
-
has increased to 20 individuals, including 12 Indonesian workers and eight foreign workers, according to the Central Sulawesi Regional Police
-
there are 29 individuals with severe injuries and 11 with minor injuries
-
Agus revealed that the investigation suggests several violations of standard operating procedures (SOP) on the part of personnel
-
a second fire occurred in the smelter of Gunbuster Nickel Industri (GNI) on Dec. 28, 2023
-
calls for rigorous inspections of equipment and systems in smelters or mining processing facilities to prevent future explosions
-
- 5
U.S. Geological Survey (P.H. Kuck), 2013. Nickel, in Metal Prices in the United States Through 2010 (Scientific Investigations Report 2012-5188) , Nickel (Ni), pp. 105 to 112.
The history of nickel production and prices from the 18th century to 2010, stainless steel, strikes, the start of LME trading.
-
In 1969, the Canadian nickel, copper, and iron ore industries were shut down by a prolonged series of labor strikes
-
The strike at Inco’s operations in the Sudbury district lasted from September 16, 1978, to June 3, 1979
-
- 6
U.S. Geological Survey, 2025. Nickel, in 2021 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , Production; Consumption; World Review (Indonesia, China, Russia); Outlook.
World use shares in 2021, laterite and sulfide production, Class I and Class II nickel, Indonesia's smelters and the first HPAL plant, batteries.
-
Increased primary production was the result of the continued development and commissioning of smelters which had been stimulated through implementation of a ban on
-
- 7
International Nickel Study Group (R. Ferreira, F. Pinto), 2026. The World Nickel Market in 2026 - Indonesia, the Influencer .
Production, use and market balance in 2025 and the forecast for 2026; Indonesia's quotas and ore price rules; sulfur supply; LME prices and stocks. First published in Stainless Steel World, June 2026.
-
The country’s rapid production growth over the past decade reflects the scale of Chinese-backed investment
-