Fluorine: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Fluorspar caused a WTO trade case against China's export limits. Miners in Newfoundland had a higher risk of lung cancer from radon. The largest disputes now are about fluorine chemicals: PFAS in drinking water, with settlements in the billions, and fluoride in tap water.

Last updated 5 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

We found no wars or armed groups linked to fluorspar. The main dispute has been about trade.

In 2009 the United States, the EU and Mexico brought a case at the World Trade Organization (WTO). It was about Chinese export duties and quotas on fluorspar and other raw materials1. The complainants said the limits made the materials scarce and raised world prices. They said the limits also gave Chinese industry cheaper and steadier supply1. China said some of its limits served to conserve exhaustible natural resources1.

The WTO panel reported in July 2011, and the Appellate Body in January 2012. The panel found that China could not show matching limits on its own production or use1. China removed the duties and quotas from 1 January 20131.

Workers and communities

Mining at St. Lawrence, Newfoundland, left the best-documented harm to workers. Commercial mining ran from 1933 to 1978. A study followed 2,661 men who worked there2. Of them, 2,111 worked underground. There they breathed radon from groundwater that seeped into the mines2. Fans were installed in 19602. For underground miners, the mean yearly exposure in 1955 to 1959 was about 50 times that of 1961 to 19652. Researchers say the miners’ higher risk of lung cancer from radon is well established3.

Dust is a risk at all fluorspar mines. USGS says dust control should be enforced carefully4. Tailings dams are another risk. USGS notes that their collapse, though rare, can kill people and damage the environment4.

Mine safety now limits production in China. In 2025 some mines stopped for safety inspections5. In Mexico in 2022, a “geological issue” made the ramp of the Las Cuevas mine less safe, and output fell6.

Communities near fluorine-rich water carry a natural burden. In parts of India, Kenya and Tanzania, drinking water holds 3 to 8 parts per million of fluoride. Crippling bone deformities such as knock knee have been reported there4. Water in Kerio Valley, Kenya, including mine water, reaches 305 parts per million4. For comparison, the World Health Organization gives a guideline value of 1.5 parts per million4.

Who gains and who loses

China has kept more of its fluorspar at home. It developed its own chain from fluorspar to fluorine chemicals, and its exports fell as its own use grew4. When Chinese exports fell, producers elsewhere could not make up the gap, and prices rose4.

Some makers of fluorine chemicals have agreed to pay water suppliers. In June 2023, 3M reached a tentative agreement to pay $10.3 billion over 13 years to US public water suppliers. The deal would settle about 4,000 lawsuits over PFAS in drinking water7. Most of the suits blame firefighting foam that contained PFOA or PFOS7. Weeks earlier, Chemours, DuPont and Corteva agreed to pay $1.19 billion. The companies say the settlements are not an admission of liability7.

Water systems and their customers carry the cost of cleanup. The US EPA expected its 2024 drinking-water rule to prevent PFAS exposure for about 100 million people8.

Public debate

Two debates about fluorine are open in the United States: fluoride in tap water, and PFAS.

Fluoride has been added to drinking water since 1945. In Grand Rapids, Michigan, tooth decay among children born after fluoridation fell by more than 60%9. Newer studies find a smaller effect. A Cochrane review of 2024 looked at studies made after 1975, when fluoride toothpaste came into wide use10. In those studies, children with fluoridated water had about a quarter of a tooth less decay. The authors say this estimate includes the possibility of no benefit10. At 0.7 parts per million, about 12% of people had visible marks on their teeth (dental fluorosis)10. More than 200 million people in the United States receive fluoridated water11. In March 2025 Utah became the first state to ban it11. Utah lawmakers who pushed for the ban said fluoridation was too expensive11. A few months earlier, a federal judge ordered the EPA to regulate fluoride. The judge’s reason was that high levels could pose a risk to children’s intellectual development11. The president of the American Dental Association said the added amounts are below levels of concern11. Opponents of the ban warned that it would hurt low-income residents most11. In May 2025 Florida passed a law that allows only additives that treat the water12. Before that, the state Surgeon General had advised against fluoridation12.

PFAS are a family of thousands of fluorine chemicals. They are used in many industries and consumer products, and their health effects are a concern6. In April 2024 the EPA set drinking-water limits for six PFAS8. In May 2026 the EPA proposed to keep the limits for PFOA and PFOS, with more time to comply. It also proposed to remove the limits for the four other PFAS. The EPA said the 2024 rule had not followed the Safe Drinking Water Act8. 3M said in 2022 that it would stop making PFAS by the end of 20256.

Sources

  1. 1

    World Trade Organization, 2026. DS394: China — Measures Related to the Exportation of Various Raw Materials .

    The WTO case on Chinese export duties and quotas, fluorspar included, 2009 to 2013.

    • On 23 June 2009, the United States requested consultations with China with respect to China’s restraints on the export from China of various forms of raw materials
    • The complainants argued that the use of export restraints creates scarcity and causes higher prices of the raw materials in global markets
    • China had argued in its defence that some of its export duties and quotas were justified because they related to the conservation of exhaustible natural resources
    • But China was not able to demonstrate that it imposed these restrictions in conjunction with restrictions on domestic production or consumption of the raw materials
    • Both notices had taken effect on 1 January 2013
  2. 2

    P.J. Villeneuve and others, International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health, 2023. Circulatory system disease mortality and occupational exposure to radon progeny in the cohort of Newfoundland Fluorspar Miners between 1950 and 2016 , Methods.

    The St. Lawrence miners, 1933 to 1978, and their exposure to radon before and after ventilation.

    • the all-male cohort initially included 2661 miners, employed between 1933 (date that commercial mining started in St. Lawrence) to 1978 (closure of the last mine)
    • 2111 miners worked underground, where they were exposed to radon via groundwater seepage
    • In 1960, mechanical ventilation was installed in the mines
    • 64.8 WLM
    • 1.3 WLM
  3. 3

    P.J. Villeneuve, R. Morrison and R. Lane, Radiation and Environmental Biophysics, 2025. Exposure to radon progeny and cancer mortality, excluding lung cancer, in the cohort of Newfoundland Fluorspar Miners between 1950 and 2016 , Introduction.

    States that the higher lung cancer risk of the miners is well established; the paper itself studies other cancers.

    • The increased risk of lung cancer from radon progeny among Newfoundland fluorspar miners is well established
  4. 4

    T.S. Hayes, M.M. Miller, G.J. Orris and N.M. Piatak, U.S. Geological Survey, 2017. Fluorine, chap. G of Critical mineral resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802) , pp. G1-G80.

    Minerals, deposit types, history of US production, processing, environment and health.

    • Dust control should be carefully enforced
    • Although rare, collapse of tailings dams can destroy property and cause injuries, fatalities, and environmental damage
    • Skeletal deformations and the crippling bone deformities of genu valgum (that is, knock knee) have been reported to occur in regions in India, Kenya, and Tanzania
    • reaches 305 ppm
    • the World Health Organization reports a guideline value of 1.5 ppm
    • China’s fluorspar exports started to decrease as its domestic consumption increased
    • Producers outside of China were unable to increase production capacity to make up for the reduction in global supply
  5. 5

    V. Londono, U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Fluorspar, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Salient statistics; World Mine Production and Reserves; World Resources.

    World fluorspar production and reserves by country, US import prices and trade, 2021 to 2025.

    • with some mines suspending production for safety inspections
  6. 6

    U.S. Geological Survey, 2025. Fluorspar, in 2022 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , pp. 26.1-26.4.

    Grades, world end uses in 2022, prices, laws on fluorinated gases and PFAS, world review and outlook.

    • Reduced safety standards at the mine’s ramp, as a result of a … geological issue … limited access to the material underground
    • there are concerns about the potential health and environmental effects of PFAS use
    • 3M announced that it would end the manufacture of PFAS
  7. 7

    Chemical & Engineering News (American Chemical Society), 2023. 3M agrees to $10.3 billion PFAS settlement .

    The 3M and DuPont-group settlements with US water suppliers over PFAS, June 2023.

    • 3M has reached a tentative agreement to resolve about 4,000 lawsuits
    • Most of the suits attribute the contamination to the use of firefighting foam
    • The settlements are not an admission of liability, the companies say
  8. 8

    U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2026. Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) – Final PFAS National Primary Drinking Water Regulation .

    The 2024 national drinking-water limits for six PFAS, and the two rules the EPA proposed in May 2026.

    • EPA expects that over many years the final rule will prevent PFAS exposure in drinking water for approximately 100 million people
    • EPA announced the final NPDWR for six PFAS
    • rescind drinking water regulations for PFHxS, PFNA, HFPO-DA
  9. 9

    National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research (US), 2026. The Story of Fluoridation .

    Grand Rapids, the first city to fluoridate its water in 1945, and the fall in tooth decay there.

    • The caries rate among Grand Rapids children born after fluoride was added to the water supply dropped more than 60 percent
  10. 10

    Z. Iheozor-Ejiofor and others, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2024. Water fluoridation for the prevention of dental caries , Abstract.

    Effect of water fluoridation on tooth decay in studies after 1975, and the rate of dental fluorosis at 0.7 ppm.

    • before or after the widespread use of fluoride toothpaste in 1975
    • This equates to a difference in dmft of approximately one-quarter of a tooth in favour of CWF; this effect estimate includes the possibility of benefit and no benefit
    • approximately 12% of participants had fluorosis of aesthetic concern
  11. 11

    Associated Press (PBS News), 2025. Utah becomes the first state to ban fluoride in public drinking water .

    Utah's ban of March 2025, with the stated reasons of both sides.

    • More than 200 million people in the U.S., or almost two-thirds of the population, receive fluoridated water
    • Utah has become the first state to ban fluoride in public drinking water
    • Utah lawmakers who pushed for a ban said putting fluoride in water was too expensive
    • a federal judge ordered the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to regulate fluoride in drinking water because high levels could pose a risk to the intellectual development of children
    • has said the amounts of fluoride added to drinking water are below levels considered problematic
    • Opponents warn the ban will disproportionately affect low-income residents
  12. 12

    The Florida Senate, Committee on Fiscal Policy, 2025. Bill Analysis and Fiscal Impact Statement, CS/CS/CS/SB 700 (Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services) , Sections 31 and 32, Present Situation and Effect of Proposed Changes.

    The ban on water additives that do not treat the water, and the Florida Surgeon General's advice against fluoridation. The Governor approved the bill on 20 May 2025 (Chapter 2025-22).

    • to prohibit the use of any additives in a public water system which do not meet the definition of a water quality additive
    • recommends against community water fluoridation