Boron: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
The largest dispute is over Rio Tinto's Jadar lithium and borate project in Serbia, halted after protests in 2022 and restarted in 2024. Rio Tinto later put it on care and maintenance. In California, a 107-day lockout at the Boron mine in 2010 ended with a new union contract.
Last updated 5 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
The main dispute is in the Jadar valley in western Serbia. Lithium, boron and a new mineral, jadarite, were found there in 20041. Rio Tinto plans a mine and plant on about 250 hectares1. At full output the project would make 286,000 tonnes of boric acid a year, as well as lithium2.
In February 2020 Serbia’s government adopted a spatial plan for the project. It repealed the plan after mass protests in December 20213. In January 2022 the government shelved the project4.
In July 2024 the Constitutional Court ruled that this halt was unconstitutional. Five days later the government restarted the project by decree1. Critics say the court ruled under political influence3. In 2024 Serbia and the European Commission also signed a memorandum on a partnership for raw materials, batteries and electric vehicles. The German chancellor, Olaf Scholz, was present3. A new wave of mass protests against lithium mining followed in the summer of 20243. In October 2024 parliament voted 128 to 84 against an opposition bill to ban lithium and boron mining4.
Opponents say the mine would harm water, land and health. They also say they do not trust state institutions to enforce the standards3. Activists and some locals say the financial benefits for Serbia will be small4.
Supporters, led by President Aleksandar Vučić, point to billions of euros of income and about 1,000 long-term jobs1. The mining minister said the project would go ahead only if it is shown to cause no harm to the environment4. Rio Tinto says the project meets standards of environmental protection and social responsibility3.
By October 2026, Rio Tinto’s project page said that the company was moving Jadar into care and maintenance. It gave its focus on capital discipline and on near-term projects as the reason5.
Workers and communities
The US borate industry employed about 1,500 people in 20252. All three producers are in southern California.
In 2010 Rio Tinto locked out about 570 miners at Boron, after they voted down a new contract. The lockout started on January 31 and lasted 107 days6.
The miners belonged to the International Longshore and Warehouse Union. According to Labor Notes, Rio Tinto wanted the right to turn full-time jobs into part-time ones, cut pay, end seniority and outsource work7. The miners voted 279 to 95 for a six-year contract7. It gave 2.5% raises a year. New hires got 401(k) savings plans in place of pensions7.
The mine’s general manager, Dean Gehring, called it a fair agreement that would improve work practices and productivity6. Both reports come from publications that cover the labor movement. We found no other statement from Rio Tinto.
In 2019, earthquakes damaged the plants and railway of Searles Valley Minerals at Trona8.
Who gains and who loses
For Turkey, boron brings in more than a billion dollars a year. Eti Maden sold boron products for $1.322 billion in 20249. Turkey’s boron exports reached nearly $1.15 billion in 20259. SCRREEN put boron products at about 0.1% of Turkey’s exports in 2021, by its count from UN trade data. They mattered more to Bolivia, at 0.7%10. The share for Turkey looks low next to the ministry’s export figure. SCRREEN may count only some boron products (our reading).
Rio Tinto put its borates business under strategic review in 202511. It said it would report the outcome later.
In Serbia, the gains and losses are disputed. Ana Brnabić, the speaker of parliament, said in 2025 that Jadar would create 20,000 new jobs3. That is far more than the 1,000 long-term jobs cited by supporters in 2024. A BIRN investigation found that Rio Tinto spent at least €1.2 million on land at the site after the project was cancelled4.
SCRREEN, a European research project, found no specific information on social and ethical problems in the wider borate supply chain10.
Sources
- 1
RFE/RL's Balkan Service, 2024. Serbian Government Restarts Rio Tinto's Contentious Lithium Mine Project .
The July 2024 decree that restarted Jadar, and the views of the government and the opponents.
-
the discovery there in 2004 of lithium, boron, and jadarite, a new mineral
-
Rio Tinto’s plans for a sprawling 250-hectare complex
-
a government session on July 16 adopted a decree to restart the project immediately, based on the Constitutional Court’s conclusion five days earlier
-
Vucic and other proponents point to the benefits of billions of euros from mined lithium
-
around 1,000 long-term jobs
-
- 2
A.S. Brioche, U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Boron, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , World Production and Reserves table; Events, Trends, and Issues.
Production by country in mixed forms, reserves, US trade, substitutes, new projects and the 2025 US critical list.
-
was expected to produce 286,000 tons per year of boric acid at full production
-
1,330 E 1,400 E 1,430 E 1,500 E 1,500 E
-
- 3
European Western Balkans, 2025. European Commission approves controversial Serbian lithium project as strategic for the EU .
The June 2025 EU decision on Jadar and the reactions of Rio Tinto, the government and the opposition.
-
In February 2020, the government adopted a Decree on approving the spatial plan
-
This decree was repealed following mass protests in December 2021
-
in a decision critics believe was made under political influence
-
A Memorandum of Understanding, signed in 2024 by Serbian authorities and European Commission Vice President Maroš Šefčovič in the presence of the then German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, launched a Strategic Partnership on sustainable raw materials, battery value chains, and electric vehicles
-
Subsequently, another wave of mass protests against lithium mining was held over the summer
-
The citizens cited environmental and health concerns and distrust in state institutions to enforce the necessary standards
-
This decision further confirms that the Jadar Project meets standards of technical feasibility, as well as environmental protection, social responsibility, and governance
-
the Jadar project would create 20,000 new jobs
-
- 4
K. Baletic, Balkan Insight (BIRN), 2024. Serbian MPs Reject Proposed Ban on Lithium and Boron Mining .
The October 2024 vote on a ban on lithium and boron mining in Serbia.
-
Serbia’s government had shelved the project in January 2022, following months of protests
-
In the vote, 128 MPs voted against and 84 in favour
-
They also claim the financial benefits for the country will be small
-
She repeated that the Jadar project will be implemented only if it is shown that it will not have negative consequences for the environment
-
Rio Tinto had spent at least 1.2 million euros on buying land in Serbia at the proposed site of the mine, even after the project was formally cancelled
-
- 5
Rio Tinto, 2026. Jadar (project page) .
Rio Tinto's own statement that it is moving the Jadar project into care and maintenance. The page gives no date for the decision.
-
We are transitioning the Jadar Project into care and maintenance. This decision reflects our global focus on capital discipline and prioritising near-term opportunities
-
- 6
R. Arrieta, In These Times, 2010. Hard-Fought Victory for Locked-Out Borax Miners .
The 2010 lockout at Boron, with statements from the union and from the mine's general manager.
-
The company locked out the workers in Boron on January 31 after they voted down a giveback-packed contract from Rio Tinto
-
570 RioTinto Borax miners who were locked out of the Rio Tinto mining facility for 107 days
-
We have reached a fair agreement that allows us to improve work practices and productivity so we can keep the business competitive throughout the life of the operation
-
- 7
Labor Notes, 2010. Settlement Voted Up in Boron, Calif., Lockout .
The union's account of the 2010 lockout and its settlement. Labor Notes is a labor-movement publication.
-
Rio Tinto had demanded the right to convert full-time jobs to part-time, gut seniority, cut pay at any time, and outsource
-
voted by 279 to 95 May 15 to end their 107-day lockout
-
The agreement calls for annual 2.5 percent raises
-
new hires will receive 401(k)s with a 4 percent company contribution instead
-
- 8
A.S. Brioche, U.S. Geological Survey, 2024. Boron, in 2019 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , pp. 13.1-13.6.
Producers, uses, trade, history and projects by country, 2019.
-
SVM’s Trona and Westend plants were damaged by earthquakes on July 4 and 5, significantly slowing production
-
- 9
Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources, 2026. Boron .
Turkey's reserves, Eti Maden sales and exports, new boron product plants and the government's view on prices and recycling.
-
generating $1.322 billion in sales revenue
-
As of 2025, Türkiye’s boron exports had reached nearly $1.15 billion
-
- 10
SCRREEN2 (EU Horizon 2020 project), 2023. SCRREEN2 factsheets updates based on the EU factsheets 2020: Borates , Tables 1 and 3; demand; outlook for supply; recycling; health.
World production shares 2016 to 2020, EU supply, consumption in 2018, recycling and drinking-water limits.
-
Boron product exports are most relevant for Bolivia (0.7 %), Turkey (0.1 %) and Chile (0.1 %)
-
SOCIAL AND ETHICAL ASPECTS No specific information was found.
-
- 11
Rio Tinto (copy hosted by Poder360), 2025. Third quarter operations review 2025 , pp. 1, 3, 9 and production table.
Rio Tinto borate output by quarter, demand comment and the strategic review. The company site refuses scripts; this is a copy of the company's PDF.
-
As announced on 27 August 2025, our Borates, and Iron and Titanium businesses have now moved to the Chief Commercial Officer’s portfolio for strategic review
-