Americium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

States disagree on whether americium can be used in nuclear weapons. In 1976 an explosion at Hanford contaminated the worker Harold McCluskey with americium-241.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

States disagree about americium in nuclear weapons. ISIS reports that Russia and France have challenged its usefulness, while the United States has said that it can be used1. Critics compare it to plutonium-238, which is seen as unsuitable for weapons because of its high heat output1. Advocates say that americium-241 gives one-fifth of the heat of plutonium-2381. In 1998 the United States said that the problems of heat and radiation could be overcome with a relatively low level of sophistication1. No country is known to have used americium in a weapon1.

The amount in smoke detectors is very small for this purpose. In a podcast of the Royal Society of Chemistry, Brian Clegg estimates that a critical mass would need the americium of around 180 billion detectors2.

Workers and communities

On 30 August 1976 a glove box exploded at the Plutonium Finishing Plant at Hanford, Washington. The chemical operator Harold McCluskey inhaled about 500 times the occupational standard for americium-2413. Other workers who helped him were also contaminated3. A doctor, Bryce Breitenstein, treated him in isolation for five months with an experimental drug that removed 80% of the contamination3. He received a settlement of 275,000 dollars and died in 19873.

Americium also adds to the radiation dose of people who work with old plutonium. Los Alamos describes it as an impurity that increases the risk to workers4. MOX fuel plants have removed americium from plutonium for the same reason1.

Who gains and who loses

Los Alamos says that its recovery work turns a highly radioactive waste constituent into a valuable industrial and research product4. It says that recovery saves money, because each drum of waste for the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant costs around 100,000 dollars4. Jean-Luc Palayer, the head of Orano USA, put it this way in 2025: “It’s only waste if you waste it”5.

In 2014 the ESA engineer Keith Stephenson said that americium power systems could become an export product for the United Kingdom6. The UK National Nuclear Laboratory says that americium could give ESA independence and make space work more affordable7.

Public debate

In a podcast of the Royal Society of Chemistry, Brian Clegg notes that people sometimes panic when they find it in smoke detectors2. The US Nuclear Regulatory Commission allows the use. In its view, the lives saved far outweigh the risk from the radiation8. The US Environmental Protection Agency says that an undamaged detector is no health threat9.

Several countries now prefer detectors without americium. The World Nuclear Association reports that Australia, Belgium, France and Germany are phasing out detectors of the ionization-only type10.

Sources

  1. 1

    David Albright and Kimberly Kramer, Institute for Science and International Security (ISIS), 2005. Neptunium 237 and Americium: World Inventories and Proliferation Concerns , Revised 22 August 2005; pp. 1-13 and Tables 1, 2 and 5.

    World amounts of americium in spent fuel to the end of 2003, by country, separated stocks, uses, the weapons debate and the IAEA monitoring scheme.

    • Russia and France have challenged its … usefulness in a nuclear explosive, while the United States has stated that americium can in fact be used in nuclear explosives.
    • Critics compare it to plutonium 238, which is viewed as unsuitable for use in nuclear explosives because of its high heat rate.
    • advocates state that the heat rate of americium 241 is one-fifth of that of plutonium 238
    • they could be overcome with a relatively low level of sophistication
    • Although no nation is known to have used either neptunium 237 or americium in nuclear explosives
    • The purpose of this separation is to reduce the radiation doses to workers during fuel fabrication.
  2. 2

    Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Americium - Element information, properties and uses , Sections Uses, Biological role, Natural abundance, History; podcast transcript by Brian Clegg.

    The discovery, the first names, natural traces and Oklo, uses in smoke detectors and the amount in one detector.

    • it would take around 180 billion of them to have sufficient americium-241 assembled to go critical
    • Every now and then someone will panic when they discover that not only is there a radioactive material in household smoke detectors
  3. 3

    HistoryLink.org, 2004. Harold McCluskey becomes the Atomic Man at Hanford on August 30, 1976. , Essay 5692, posted 23 April 2004.

    The 1976 accident at the Hanford Plutonium Finishing Plant and its outcome.

    • He inhaled approximately 500 times the occupational standard for americium 241, a plutonium byproduct.
    • Other workers who rendered assistance were also contaminated.
    • administered an experimental drug which flushed 80 percent of the contamination out of McCluskey’s system
    • He received a settlement of $275,000 plus medical care for life. The Atomic Man died in 1987.
  4. 4

    Los Alamos National Laboratory, Actinide Research Quarterly, 2023. United States of Americium , 1 November 2023.

    The discovery and its announcement, US production from 1962 to 1984, dependence on Russia, the restart at Los Alamos from 2017, the process, the uses and the ESA program.

    • creates additional gamma radiation dose in aged plutonium materials, causing increased risk to workers
    • transforms a highly radioactive waste constituent into a valuable industrial and research product
    • waste drums sent to WIPP (Waste Isolation Pilot Plant) in Carlsbad, New Mexico cost around $100,000 each
  5. 5

    Zeno Power (press release), 2025. Zeno Power and Orano Unlock Americium-241 Supply Through Strategic Agreement to Fuel Space Nuclear Batteries , 24 September 2025.

    The agreement for americium-241 from the La Hague site in France.

    • As we like to say: It’s only waste if you waste it.
  6. 6

    World Nuclear News, 2014. Cosmic recycling , 21 July 2014.

    The NNL separation of americium-241 from civil plutonium, the amounts, the purity, and an ESA engineer's cost comparison with plutonium-238.

    • Am-241 radioisotope power systems could become a multi-million dollar export product for the UK
  7. 7

    United Kingdom National Nuclear Laboratory, 2026. Americium in space power systems .

    The ESA call of 2009, why americium-241 can replace plutonium-238, and the UK stock of civil plutonium.

    • Finding an alternative would give ESA independence and make space exploration more affordable.
  8. 8

    U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 2025. Backgrounder on Smoke Detectors , January 2025.

    Licenses for smoke detectors since 1963, the amount of americium-241 in one unit, doses and disposal. Read with Firecrawl because the site refused the script.

    • because a smoke detector’s ability to save lives far outweighs any health risk from the radiation
  9. 9

    U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2026. Americium in Ionization Smoke Detectors .

    How the source is shielded, and disposal of smoke detectors in the United States.

    • There is no health threat from ionization smoke detectors as long as the detector is not damaged and used as directed.
  10. 10

    World Nuclear Association, 2026. Radioisotopes in Consumer Products , Updated 11 February 2026; section on smoke detectors.

    How ionization smoke detectors work, the price of 1962, the amount per detector, phase-outs of ionization detectors, and space power work. The World Nuclear Association is the trade body of the nuclear industry.

    • In several countries including Australia, Belgium, France, and Germany, ionization-only detectors are being phased out.