Vanadium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

In 2021, after a request from two US producers, the US government found that vanadium imports did not threaten national security. Workers can breathe in vanadium pentoxide dust, which may cause cancer. Soils near some mines and smelters hold much more vanadium than normal.

Last updated 10 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

In November 2019, two US vanadium producers, AMG Vanadium and U.S. Vanadium, asked the Department of Commerce for an investigation under Section 232. The investigation was to find the effect of vanadium imports on national security11. Both companies make vanadium from waste, in Ohio and Arkansas1.

The department finished its report in February 20211. It said vanadium is critical to national security and that the United States depends on imports1. But it concluded that imports did not threaten to impair national security1. Among its reasons were the health of the US industry, idle domestic resources, existing government actions, and the needs of steel and titanium makers1. It recommended other support, such as a stockpile of high-purity V₂O₅ and help for recycling11.

In 2025 the United States raised tariffs on many Brazilian goods to 50%. High-purity vanadium was included; ferrovanadium was not. A large Brazilian producer asked for an exemption. It reported delays and defaults on its contracts. It said its product is important for US aerospace and defense2. USGS does not say whether an exemption was given.

Workers and communities

Workers are exposed mostly by breathing V₂O₅ dust when ferrovanadium and steel are made3. USGS says breathing V₂O₅ can cause a long-lasting cough and is suspected to cause cancer3. Since 1 December 2023, EU law classifies V₂O₅ as a substance that may cause cancer (category 1B). The Vanadium Consortium, a group of vanadium companies, reports this classification4.

The US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) sets limits for V₂O₅ in workplace air. They are 0.5 mg per cubic meter for respirable dust and 0.1 mg for fume5. Both are ceiling limits, not averages over an 8-hour day5.

The public takes in vanadium mostly with food3. People need very little. USGS gives a possible need of less than 10 micrograms a day, and toxic effects above 10 to 20 mg a day33.

Mines and smelters can raise vanadium in the soil around them. Near a vanadium mine in South Africa’s North West Province, soils held 548 to 7,160 ppm, about ten times normal levels3. In the Panzhihua region of China, soils near smelters held the most vanadium, 208 to 938 ppm, and soils in towns the least3.

In 2018 polluted water was found in the Jinsha River at Panzhihua. Local governments then inspected producers, and many stopped or cut production6. USGS does not say what the pollution was.

Who gains and who loses

Low prices can stop production. Production in Utah stopped in 2020 because prices fell7.

The Commerce Department weighed these sides in the Section 232 report. It said higher US prices than world prices would hurt US steelmakers and titanium makers1. In titanium alloys, vanadium is 4% of the weight but 12% to 14% of the cost1. The department said that Russian and Chinese titanium makers would gain1.

China’s rebar standard of 2018 also had costs. USGS reported that in January 2019, 30% to 40% of mills had not fully changed. Many small mills could not pay for the new technology6.

Sources

  1. 1

    US Department of Commerce, Bureau of Industry and Security (Federal Register, 18 November 2021), 2021. Publication of a Report on the Effect of Imports of Vanadium on the National Security: An Investigation Conducted Under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, as Amended (86 FR 64454) , Executive Summary, Findings, Conclusion, Recommendations; III.A Initiation of Investigation; findings D and E.

    The Section 232 investigation of vanadium imports, its petitioners, findings, conclusion and recommendations.

    • On November 19, 2019, AMG Vanadium LLC and U.S. Vanadium LLC
    • to determine the effect of imports of vanadium on the national security
    • Applicants are secondary producers of vanadium, using vanadium-bearing waste feedstock to produce vanadium products: AMG Vanadium operates a facility in Cambridge, Ohio that produces ferrovanadium, and U.S. Vanadium operates a facility in Hot Springs, Arkansas
    • This report was completed on February 22, 2021
    • Although vanadium is critical to national security and the United States is currently dependent on imported sources of vanadium
    • the Secretary concludes that the present quantities and circumstances of vanadium imports do not threaten to impair the national security as defined in Section 232
    • the health of the U.S. industry, availability of idle domestic resources, existing USG actions, and the importance of vanadium to competitive steel and titanium industries
    • Expansion of the National Defense Stockpile To Include High Purity Vanadium Pentoxide
    • the USG should support the vanadium industry
    • Unilaterally Increasing Domestic Prices of Vanadium Would Harm Critical U.S. Industries
    • contains 4% vanadium by weight, but represents between 12 and 14% by cost
    • Would Harm the U.S. Titanium Industry, to the Benefit of Russian and Chinese Titanium Producers
  2. 2

    U.S. Geological Survey (D.E. Polyak), 2026. Vanadium, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , p. 1, Domestic Production and Use, Salient Statistics, Recycling, Import Sources; p. 2, Events, World Mine Production and Reserves, World Resources, Substitutes, footnotes.

    World production and reserves by country, resources, prices, US production and imports, tariffs, flow batteries, substitutes.

    • A major producer and supplier of vanadium in Brazil sought an exemption after experiencing delays and defaults on its high-purity vanadium contracts
  3. 3

    U.S. Geological Survey (K.D. Kelley, C.T. Scott, D.E. Polyak, B.E. Kimball), 2017. Vanadium, chap. U of Critical mineral resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802) , Abstract; Uses and Applications; Geology; Resources and Production; Environmental Considerations; table U3.

    Abundance, minerals, deposit types and locations, uses, substitutes, sources of supply, health and environment.

    • Occupational exposure to vanadium usually results from the inhalation of V2O5 dust during the production of FeV and steel
    • Inhalation of V2O5 may cause extended coughing and is suspected to cause cancer
    • The general public is most likely to be exposed to vanadium through consumption of contaminated food
    • a postulated requirement for humans of less than 10 micrograms per day
    • Vanadium toxicity is believed to result from an intake of more than 10 to 20 milligrams per day
    • the concentration of vanadium in soils (548 to 7,160 ppm) collected near a vanadium mine in the North West Province of South Africa (Mandiwana and Panichev, 2004) is roughly an order of magnitude greater than natural concentrations in soils
    • smelting (208 to 938 ppm), mining (112 to 591 ppm), agricultural (86 to 227 ppm), and urban use (94 to 184 ppm)
  4. 4

    The Vanadium Consortium (an association of vanadium companies for EU chemicals rules), 2026. Classification and Labelling , Introduction; table, row 'Divanadium pentaoxide'.

    The EU harmonized classification of V2O5, in force since 1 December 2023, including carcinogenicity category 1B.

    • for which a CLP harmonised classification is in force since 1 December 2023
    • Divanadium pentaoxide … Carc. 1B – H350
  5. 5

    US Occupational Safety and Health Administration, 2026. Table Z-1, Limits for Air Contaminants (29 CFR 1910.1000) , Rows 'Vanadium' (respirable dust and fume, as V2O5); note 1.

    Workplace air limits for vanadium pentoxide dust and fume, as ceiling limits.

    • Respirable dust (as V2 O5) … (C)0.5
    • Fume (as V2 O5) … (C)0.1
    • The PELs are 8-hour TWAs unless otherwise noted; a (C) designation denotes a ceiling limit
  6. 6

    U.S. Geological Survey (D.E. Polyak), 2020. Vanadium, in 2018 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , Prices; World Review, China.

    The 2018 price rise, China's rebar standard, the import ban on vanadium slag and the closures at Panzhihua.

    • continued to suspend or decrease vanadium production owing to local governments conducting environmental inspections following the discovery of polluted water in the Jinsha River in Panzhihua
    • It was reported that approximately 30% to 40% of mills had not fully switched to the new standards. Many of the small mills could not afford to implement the technology needed to produce the upgraded rebar
  7. 7

    U.S. Geological Survey, 2021. Vanadium, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2021 , p. 1, Domestic Production and Use.

    Metallurgical share of US vanadium consumption in 2020, and the end of production in Utah.

    • ceased in the first quarter of 2020 owing to decreasing vanadium prices