Titanium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Titanium dioxide is part of trade disputes between China and other countries. The EU banned it in food; Canada did not. A US court jailed a man for selling DuPont's pigment secrets to Chinese state companies. Plans for sand mines led to disputes about land and water.
Last updated 10 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
In 2014, a US court sentenced Walter Liew to 15 years in prison. A jury had found that he and others conspired to steal trade secrets from DuPont about its chloride-route TiO₂ process1. They sold the secrets to Pangang Group companies, which are owned by the Chinese state, for more than $20 million11. The prosecutors called it the first federal jury conviction under the Economic Espionage Act of 19961.
In 2017, a federal appeals court rejected the challenges to the trade secret convictions. It reversed the convictions for conspiracy to obstruct justice and for witness tampering, and sent the case back to the lower court22. We found no public statement by Pangang Group about the case.
In January 2025, the EU put anti-dumping duties of €0.25 to €0.74 per kg on TiO₂ from China. The European Commission said that dumped imports harmed EU producers, which employ almost 5,000 people3. In December 2024, before the final duties, China’s commerce ministry urged the EU to follow WTO rules and not to abuse trade remedies4.
In October 2026, the UK Trade Remedies Authority proposed anti-dumping duties on rutile TiO₂ from China. It said that imports threaten UK producers. It also listed trade measures on TiO₂ in the European Union, Brazil, India and Saudi Arabia55.
In June 2021, Rio Tinto stopped work at Richards Bay Minerals in South Africa after a security incident at the mine. Work restarted in August 20216.
Workers and communities
At Tellnes in Norway, about 2 million tonnes of tailings a year went into a local fjord during the 1980s. This reduced the number and diversity of species there. Seabed life began to recover after the dumping stopped in 19947. At Lac Tio in Quebec, waste rock piles are more than 72 million tonnes and cover about 100 hectares7.
USGS says the health risk from titanium is small7. The Royal Society of Chemistry notes that fine TiO₂ dust is a suspected carcinogen8. In 2006, the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classed TiO₂ as possibly carcinogenic to humans (Group 2B)9. IARC based this on lung tumors in rats that breathed the dust. It found the evidence in humans inadequate99. EU courts annulled a separate EU classification of the dust; see Public debate below.
Who gains and who loses
The Commission said the duties balance the interests of producers and of users3. It exempted pigment for printing inks3. The European Coatings Journal, cited by China’s Global Times, said the duties would hurt the EU paint industry. It said TiO₂ is up to 40% of the cost of raw materials for paint4.
In the United States, the last sponge plant closed in 202410. Sponge makers in Japan, Saudi Arabia and Kazakhstan now supply US metal makers10.
Public debate
In 2021, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) said that TiO₂ as a food additive, E171, could no longer be considered safe11. EFSA could not rule out a concern about damage to genes, but it did not conclude that E171 damages genes1111. The EU ban entered into force on 7 February 2022. Foods with E171 could still be put on the market until 7 August 20221111.
Health Canada did its own review and came to a different conclusion. In 2022 it said there was no conclusive evidence that TiO₂ in food is a concern for human health12. It said that many studies that raised concern used forms of TiO₂ that are not used in food12.
A separate EU decision of 2019 classified some TiO₂ powders as suspected of causing cancer when breathed in. These are powders in which 1% or more of the particles are 10 micrometres or smaller13. Manufacturers, importers and users went to court. The General Court annulled the classification in 2022. It found a manifest error in how the Commission assessed one scientific study13. In August 2025, the Court of Justice confirmed the annulment13.
In Georgia, Twin Pines Minerals planned to mine titanium and zirconium sands near the Okefenokee Swamp14. Critics, among them the US Fish and Wildlife Service, said the mine would likely disturb the water flow of the swamp14. The company said its shallow mining would not harm the swamp. In a draft finding of January 2023, the Georgia regulator said that the swamp’s water level would be minimally affected1515. In June 2025, the company agreed to sell the land to The Conservation Fund for $60 million14.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Attorney's Office, Northern District of California (press release, 11 July 2014), 2014. Walter Liew Sentenced To Fifteen Years In Prison For Economic Espionage .
The conviction and sentence for selling DuPont's chloride-route TiO2 technology to Chinese state-owned companies.
-
conspired to steal trade secrets from E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Company regarding their chloride-route titanium dioxide production technology
-
sold those secrets for large sums of money to state-owned companies of the People’s Republic of China
-
Liew, Maegerle, and USAPTI obtained and sold DuPont’s TiO2 trade secrets to the Pangang Group companies for more than $20 million
-
This case marks the first federal jury conviction on charges brought under the Economic Espionage Act of 1996
-
- 2
Justia, summary of the opinion of the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit of 5 May 2017 (No. 14-10367), 2017. United States v. Liew (opinion summary) .
The appeal court upheld the economic espionage convictions, reversed two other convictions and remanded the case.
-
The Ninth Circuit rejected challenges to the sufficiency of trade secret evidence regarding substantive trade secret counts
-
the Ninth Circuit affirmed in part, reversed in part, vacated in part, and remanded
-
- 3
European Commission, Directorate-General for Trade (news, 9 January 2025), 2025. EU acts to counter dumping of titanium dioxide from China .
Definitive anti-dumping duties on TiO2 from China, their range and the Commission's stated reason.
-
imports of titanium dioxide from China had been dumped on the EU market and were causing damage to the EU industry, which employs almost 5,000 people across the Union
-
strike a fair balance between the need to protect the EU TiO2 industry from injurious dumping and the interests of TiO2 users in the Union
-
An exemption from duties was also granted for imports of graphic TiO2 used in the production of printing inks
-
- 4
Global Times (Chinese state-owned newspaper), 5 December 2024, 2024. China urges EU to avoid escalating trade tensions over titanium dioxide tariffs: MOFCOM .
The Chinese commerce ministry's response to the planned EU duties, and objections from the EU paint industry.
-
China urges the EU to adhere to WTO rules, avoid abusing trade remedy measures
-
accounts for up to 40 percent of raw material costs and 20 percent of the cost of the end product
-
- 5
UK Trade Remedies Authority (news, 7 October 2026), 2026. New duty proposed on imports of Chinese rutile titanium dioxide .
The proposed UK anti-dumping duty on rutile TiO2 from China, and the measures of other countries that the authority names.
-
The TRA has found that rutile titanium dioxide is being dumped into the UK and that there is an imminent threat of injury to the UK industry
-
trade remedy measures that have been imposed on titanium dioxide in other jurisdictions, including the European Union, Brazil, India and Saudi Arabia
-
- 6
U.S. Geological Survey (J. Gambogi), 2025. Titanium, in 2022 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , pp. 79.1 to 79.6, introduction, Production, Consumption, World Review, Outlook.
Processes, uses, world production by stage, company and country events, outlook.
-
In June 2021, Rio Tinto suspended operations at RBM and declared force majeure on customer contracts after a security incident at the mine. Operations restarted in August 2021
-
- 7
U.S. Geological Survey (L.G. Woodruff, G.M. Bedinger, N.M. Piatak), 2017. Titanium, chap. T of Critical mineral resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802) , Abstract; Introduction; Uses and Applications; Geology; Resources and Production; Environmental Considerations.
Uses, minerals, deposit types, history of processes, health and environment, recycling.
-
At Tellnes, about 2 million metric tons per year of tailings were deposited into a local fjord throughout the 1980s, which resulted in the reduction in number and diversity of species. After underwater tailings deposition ceased in 1994, bottom fauna in the fjord began to recover
-
Waste-rock piles at Lac Tio are estimated to be more than 72 million metric tons and to cover approximately 100 hectares of land
-
Human health concerns related to titanium are minimal
-
- 8
Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Titanium (Periodic Table) , History; Uses; Biological role.
Discovery by Gregor and Klaproth, the name, Hunter's pure metal, uses and biological role.
-
Fine titanium dioxide dust is a suspected carcinogen
-
- 9
International Agency for Research on Cancer (Working Group of February 2006; copy on INCHEM), 2010. Carbon Black, Titanium Dioxide, and Talc (IARC Monographs on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans, vol. 93) , Titanium dioxide, section 6, Evaluation and Rationale (pp. 275 to 276).
IARC classification of titanium dioxide as possibly carcinogenic to humans (Group 2B), and its basis.
-
Titanium dioxide is possibly carcinogenic to humans (Group 2B)
-
On the basis of the results of an increased incidence of lung tumours in rats
-
There is inadequate evidence in humans for the carcinogenicity of titanium dioxide
-
- 10
U.S. Geological Survey (S.M. Ewing), 2026. Titanium and Titanium Dioxide, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , p. 1, Domestic Production and Use, Salient Statistics, Import Sources, Tariff; p. 2, Government Stockpile, Events, World Sponge Metal Production and Sponge and Pigment Capacity, Substitutes.
World sponge production, sponge and pigment capacity, US sponge plants, imports, prices and uses.
-
The last domestic sponge plant closed in 2024
-
Sponge metal: Japan, 77%; Saudi Arabia, 13%; Kazakhstan, 8%
-
- 11
European Commission, Directorate-General for Health and Food Safety, 2022. Re-evaluation of food additives: Titanium dioxide (E171) , Titanium dioxide (E171).
The EU ban of E171 in food, its dates, and EFSA's reasons.
-
a scientific opinion from EFSA, published on 6 May 2021, which concluded that E171 can no longer be considered as safe when used as food additive
-
a genotoxicity concern could not be ruled out
-
EFSA did not conclude that E171 is genotoxic
-
The Regulation entered into force on 7 February 2022
-
the Regulation allowed, until 7 August 2022, to place on the market foods containing titanium dioxide
-
- 12
Health Canada, Food Directorate (issued 14 July 2022), 2022. Titanium dioxide (TiO2) as a food additive: Current science report .
Health Canada's conclusion on TiO2 as a food additive, which differs from the EU's.
-
the Food Directorate’s position is that there is no conclusive scientific evidence that the food additive TiO2 is a concern for human health
-
Many studies that raised concern about the safety of TiO2, including the concern for genotoxicity, used forms of TiO2 that are not considered acceptable for use in food
-
- 13
Court of Justice of the European Union, 2025. Press release No 99/25: Judgment of the Court in Joined Cases C-71/23 P and C-82/23 P, France v CWS Powder Coatings and Others .
The history of the EU carcinogen classification of TiO2 powder and its final annulment.
-
that substance was suspected of being carcinogenic to humans, by inhalation, in powder form containing 1% or more of particles of a diameter equal to or below 10 μm
-
the Commission had committed a manifest error in its assessment of the acceptability and reliability of a scientific study on which the classification had been based
-
the Court of Justice dismisses those appeals and thus upholds the judgment of the General Court
-
- 14
The Current GA (T. Davis and M. Coker), 20 June 2025, 2025. $60 million deal ends mining threat to Georgia's Okefenokee Swamp .
The planned titanium mine near the Okefenokee Swamp, the objections to it, and the sale of the land.
-
planned to strip-mine for titanium and zirconium in the mineral-rich ridge of land east of the Okefenokee
-
Many critics, including the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, argued that plans to mine titanium dioxide would likely disrupt the swamp’s water flow, risking drought and fire
-
has agreed to sell its land in south Georgia to The Conservation Fund for $60 million
-
- 15
FOX 5 Atlanta (Associated Press report), 20 January 2023, 2023. Regulators move mine plan near Okefenokee Swamp a big step forward .
The Georgia regulator's draft finding on the swamp's water level, and the Twin Pines president's statement that the mine would not harm the swamp.
-
the absurdity of allegations that our shallow mining-to-land-reclamation process will … or harm it in any way
-
concluded that water level in the swamp will be minimally impacted
-