Thorium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

The disputes are about thorium waste from rare earth plants in Malaysia. At Bukit Merah, residents sued a Mitsubishi joint venture from 1985, and the plant closed in 1994. Since 2012, the residue of the Lynas plant near Kuantan has led to protests and license conditions.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

Asian Rare Earth (ARE) was set up in Malaysia in 1979 to extract rare earths from monazite. Mitsubishi Chemical held 35%1. Its plant at Bukit Merah, near Ipoh, started work in July 19821. The Consumers’ Association of Penang supported the residents. It writes that the plant put its thorium waste in an open field and a pond next to the factory1.

In 1985, eight residents went to court for themselves and the people of Bukit Merah1. In October 1985 the Ipoh High Court ordered ARE to stop producing and storing radioactive waste until it was safe1. In July 1992 the High Court ordered the plant to close1.

In December 1993 the Supreme Court reversed the order. It found ARE’s experts more believable on radiation levels1. It also found that the residents should have asked the AELB to revoke the license1. CAP notes that the law gives the public no way to appeal for this1. Mitsubishi Chemical closed the plant in 19942.

Lynas, an Australian company, started a rare earth plant near Kuantan in 2012. Residents and activists protested against it3. In December 2018 the Malaysian government said that Lynas must remove its radioactive residue from Malaysia3. Lynas had said that the plant ran on a philosophy of zero harm3.

In 2019 the government changed its approach. It renewed the license for six months, on condition that Lynas moved the first processing steps abroad. The Australian federal and Western Australian governments had said they would not accept the residue4. In 2023, Malaysia let these steps continue in the country, on condition that Lynas brought the radioactivity of the residue below 1 becquerel per gram5. The regulator based this on laboratory findings that the thorium can be taken out of the residue5. In March 2026 it renewed the license for 10 years. Lynas must stop producing radioactive waste after five years6.

Workers and communities

Workers in mining, in processing and in making gas lantern mantles get the highest doses of thorium7. ATSDR links cancer of the lung and of the blood-forming tissues to this work. The workers were also exposed to other substances7.

At Bukit Merah, residents and activists report more leukemia, birth defects and infant deaths after the plant opened2. No formal epidemiological study of the village has been made8. Mitsubishi denies any health effects8. The Malaysian government has neither admitted nor denied radiation poisoning in the village2.

Who gains and who loses

The Lynas plant employed 600 people in 20183. At Bukit Merah, the only payment by the company was a lump sum of 500,000 ringgit to the local community in 19942. The cleanup of the site is estimated to cost far more. The New York Times put it at $100 million, as reported by Mother Jones8.

Public debate

People disagree on whether thorium fuel lowers the risk that nuclear power helps to make weapons. The World Nuclear Association, an industry group, writes that thorium fuels would be a poor source of material for a bomb9. The chemist Lars Öhrström, in a podcast for the Royal Society of Chemistry, calls the hopes for waste with less risk of weapons largely unfounded10. The United States tested a device with uranium-233 in 19559.

Sources

  1. 1

    Consumers' Association of Penang (an advocacy group), 2011. Chronology of events in the Bukit Merah Asian Rare Earth development .

    The owners of Asian Rare Earth, the thorium waste, the court cases from 1985 to 1993, and the residents' account of their health.

    • Mitsubishi Chemical Industries Ltd (35%), Beh Minerals (35%)
    • ARE factory begins operations at 7.2 km Jalan Lahat in Bukit Merah New Village.
    • ARE continues operating, dumping the thorium waste into an open field and pond next to the factory.
    • Eight residents on behalf of themselves and the Bukit Merah residents file an application in the Ipoh High Court
    • grants an injunction to the Bukit Merah residents to stop ARE from producing and storing radioactive waste until adequate safety measures are taken
    • The factory is ordered by the Ipoh High Court to shut down within 14 days.
    • The Court was of the opinion that ARE’s experts were more believable in terms of the results of the tests conducted by them showing that radiation was within permissible levels.
    • the residents should have gone back to the AELB to ask that it revoke ARE’s licence
    • does not have any provision for appeals by affected communities or the public
  2. 2

    AFP (via Arab News), 2012. Toxic legacy in Malaysian village stays .

    The closure of the Bukit Merah plant in 1994, the payment to the community, and residents' reports of illness.

    • Mitsubishi Chemicals closed the plant in 1994 after a mounting public outcry
    • Residents and activists say the village and surrounding areas have seen increased rates of leukemia, birth defects, infant deaths, congenital diseases, miscarriages and lead poisoning
    • the government has neither admitted nor denied radiation poisoning in the village
    • The only payout by the company was a 500,000-ringgit ($158,000) lump sum to the local community to aid victims in 1994.
  3. 3

    Al Jazeera, 2018. Malaysia tells Lynas to remove rare earths radioactive waste .

    The Malaysian government order of December 2018 on the Lynas residue, its amount and its radioactivity, and the protests.

    • Residents and activists had held mass protests in Kuantan against the construction of the Lynas plant in February 2012
    • The accumulated Water Leached Purification (WLP) Residue, which contains radioactive materials must be removed from Malaysia.
    • Lynas had previously said that the processing facility was run on a philosophy of … zero harm
    • It employs 600 people at the site.
  4. 4

    Malay Mail, 2019. Lynas gets six-month operating licence extension, with conditions including overseas residue processing facility .

    The licence conditions of August 2019, the 580,000 t of residue, and Australia's refusal to take the residue.

    • These conditions were imposed after the Australian federal government and the Western Australia state government informed Malaysia that it would not accept Lynas’ WLP radioactive residue.
  5. 5

    Free Malaysia Today, 2023. Lynas Malaysia's operating licence renewed .

    The 2023 licence change and the plan to take thorium out of the residue, then at laboratory scale.

    • contingent on Lynas ensuring the radioactive content in water leach purification (WLP) residue is below 1 becquerel (Bq) per gramme
    • preliminary laboratory findings indicating that thorium radioactive elements can be extracted from WLP residues
  6. 6

    Reuters (via Kitco News), 2026. Malaysia renews Lynas Rare Earths operating licence for 10 years .

    The 10-year licence of March 2026 and its conditions on radioactive residue and thorium extraction.

    • After five years, Lynas must stop producing any radioactive waste
  7. 7

    Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (US), 2019. ToxGuide for Thorium .

    Thorium in the crust, Thorotrast, workers exposed to thorium, health effects and the IARC classification.

    • Occupational exposures to higher levels of thorium isotopes occur primarily in uranium, thorium, tin, and phosphate mining, milling, and processing industries, radium dial workers, and gas lantern mantle workers.
    • Cancer of the lung and blood-producing tissues has been associated with occupational exposure to thorium and other radionuclides and non-radioactive substances.
  8. 8

    Kiera Butler, Mother Jones, 2012. Your Smartphone's Dirty, Radioactive Secret .

    The Bukit Merah waste and its cleanup, the lack of a health study, and Mitsubishi's denial of health effects.

    • Though there has never been a formal epidemiological study of the area
    • (Mitsubishi denies any health effects.)
    • The New York Times recently called the $100 million Asian Rare Earth recovery
  9. 9

    World Nuclear Association (an industry association), 2026. Thorium .

    Thorium in nature, monazite, thorium as a nuclear fuel, reactors that used it, China's and India's programs, and U-233 in weapons.

    • thorium-based power reactor fuels would be a poor source for fissile material usable in the illicit manufacture of an explosive device
    • in 1955 the USA detonated a device with a plutonium-U-233 composite pit, in Operation Teapot
  10. 10

    Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Thorium - Element information, properties and uses , Sections History, Uses and properties, Biological role, Supply risk; podcast transcript by Lars Öhrström.

    Discovery, name, radioactivity, uses, biological role, gas mantles and Thorotrast.

    • or producing waste with reduced risks of nuclear arms proliferation are largely unfounded