Technetium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
The main dispute was about technetium-99 from the Sellafield plant in England, which reached the coast of Norway. The UK cut the discharges in 2004, after years of demands from Norway, the other Nordic countries and Ireland2.
Last updated 10 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Sellafield. The Sellafield site in England reprocessed spent nuclear fuel. In the UK government’s words, the main source of its technetium-99 discharges into the sea was the reprocessing of Magnox fuel1. The discharges increased in 1994, and Norway measured higher levels on its coast from 19972. The Norwegian group Bellona said the levels in Norwegian lobster and seaweed had increased “dramatically”. It also said that technetium was found as far north as Spitsbergen3.
The UK government’s position in 2002 was that the levels were no credible threat to people or sea life. It also said the discharges were a concern to other countries1. It proposed to cut the limit from 90 to 10 TBq a year by 20061. The UK stopped the discharges for a time in June 20032. In April 2004 UK regulators approved a new treatment that cut the discharges by over 90%. The Norwegian government called it “an important victory for Norway”2.
The MAPLE reactors. In 1996 MDS, the parent company of Nordion, contracted Atomic Energy of Canada Limited (AECL) to build two MAPLE reactors. The reactors were to make medical isotopes. The reactors went critical in 2000 and 2003, but had major technical problems during commissioning. AECL cancelled them in May 2008 after spending $680 million4. Nordion took the case to arbitration. In 2012 a tribunal found, by majority, that a supply agreement of 2006 barred Nordion’s claim5. In 2013 the two settled. AECL paid Nordion CAD 15 million, and both dropped their other claims4.
Workers and communities
For the people on the Norwegian coast, the Sellafield dispute was about seafood. Prime Minister Kjell Magne Bondevik said the end of the discharges meant “clean seafood supplies for all of us”2.
We found no source on the health of workers who make molybdenum-99.
Who gains and who loses
Patients lose when supply fails. In the crisis of 2008 and 2009, appointments were cancelled in many countries6.
New producers find it hard to enter. NorthStar, a US producer, stopped making molybdenum-99 in 2023. It named rising costs and competition from foreign producers with government subsidies6. The NEA says that some existing producers get support that could be called state subsidies6.
Public debate
The debate is about who pays for the reactors. The NEA recommends full-cost recovery, so that prices pay for building and running them. In its words, some stakeholders want a fast change to cut subsidies and bring in private money. Others warn that a sudden change could raise costs and limit patient access6. As one option, the NEA suggests fixed capacity payments for all producers, included in the price of every dose6.
Sources
- 1
UK House of Commons (Hansard), 2002. Technetium-99, written ministerial statement , 11 December 2002, column 21WS.
The UK government's view of Tc-99 discharges from Sellafield and the plan to cut them.
-
The dominant source of Tc-99 discharges from Sellafield is the reprocessing of spent Magnox reactor fuel.
-
There is no evidence that Tc-99 at these levels, or the levels found in UK waters pose any credible threat to human health or that of marine organisms. Nevertheless, its presence has been a source of concern to a number of our international partners.
-
allow the Tc-99 discharge limit to be reduced from 90 TBq per year to 10 TBq per year by 2006
-
- 2
Norwegian Ministry of the Environment, 2004. Sellafield discharge issue solved , Press release, 21 April 2004.
The UK decision to cut Tc-99 discharges, and Norway's position.
-
the higher levels of technetium measured along the coast of Norway since 1997 are expected to decrease over the next few years to the same low level as before 1994, when the technetium discharges increased
-
Already in June last year, British authorities imposed a temporary stop to the discharges
-
This is an important victory for Norway.
-
reduce the discharge of Technetium 99 from the Sellafield nuclear plant by over 90 per cent
-
the end to the radioactive discharges will mean clean seafood supplies for all of us in the years ahead
-
This is in line with the demands made over several years by Norway, the other Nordic countries and Ireland.
-
- 3
Bellona Foundation, 2004. Final decision today: Radioactive Technetium-99 to be cleansed from Sellafield discharges .
The view of the Norwegian environmental group Bellona on Tc-99 from Sellafield, and measurements in Norwegian seafood.
-
The discharges in recent years have led to a dramatic increase of Tc-99 among Norwegian coastal sea products such as lobster and seaweed. Tc-99 has also been measured in the Barents Sea as far north as the Arctic island of Spitsbergen.
-
- 4
World Nuclear News, 2013. Settlement deal over MAPLE cancellation , 21 August 2013.
The settlement between AECL and Nordion.
-
In May 2008, AECL decided to cancel two MAPLE reactors at Chalk River Laboratories after spending $680 million on the project. Although the reactors went critical in 2000 and 2003 respectively, major technical problems during commissioning led to AECL’s decision to abandon the project.
-
Healthcare company MDS had contracted AECL to build the reactors in 1996
-
Under the terms of the settlement agreement, Nordion will receive CAD15 million ($14 million) in cash from AECL
-
- 5
World Nuclear News, 2012. Case dismissed for isotope arbitration , 12 September 2012.
The cancellation of the MAPLE reactors and the arbitration between Nordion and AECL.
-
The tribunal has now reached a majority decision that Nordion’s claim was precluded under the terms of an interim and long-term supply agreement (ILTSA) the company signed with AECL in 2006
-
- 6
OECD Nuclear Energy Agency, 2025. Current Trends in the Supply and Utilisation of Medical Radioisotopes , NEA No. 7743; chapter 2 and table 2.
Use of Tc-99m, the Mo-99 supply chain, the reactors that make Mo-99, HEU to LEU conversion, costs, subsidies, full-cost recovery, demand growth and new projects.
-
led to widespread cancellations of medical appointments, jeopardising patient outcomes globally
-
NorthStar attributed its decision to withdraw due to rising production costs and competition from foreign government-subsidised producers.
-
current producers sometimes receive what could be characterised as state subsidies that obscure the actual cost of production
-
Some stakeholders advocate for a swift transition to FCR to reduce reliance on subsidies and encourage private investment. In contrast, others caution that abrupt changes could increase costs and limit patient access.
-
one could start with fixed capacity payments for all, whose cost would be included in the price of every single dose
-