Seaborgium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

There were two disputes, about credit and about the name. In 1993 an international working group gave the credit to Berkeley and Livermore. IUPAC refused the name seaborgium in 1994 and accepted it in 19973.

Seaborgium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

In 1974 teams at Dubna, in the Soviet Union, and at Berkeley, in the United States, both reported element 106. Dubna fired chromium-54 at lead and saw fission events. Berkeley and Livermore fired oxygen-18 at californium-249 and saw alpha decays123. Because the two experiments came at the same time, the Berkeley team waited before it proposed a name1.

The IUPAC-IUPAP Transfermium Working Group judged the claims in 1993. It found that the two reports came at about the same time2. It found it likely that Dubna had made element 106, but its paper did not give enough confidence2. It gave the credit to Berkeley-Livermore2.

IUPAC invited the laboratories to respond to the report. Albert Ghiorso and Glenn Seaborg agreed with the verdict on element 1064. They wrote that the Dubna fission activity came mainly from rutherfordium-256, and that a second Dubna team had shown this in 19844. Yuri Oganessian and Ivo Zvara, for Dubna, objected only on elements 103, 104 and 105. They wrote that Dubna would respect the decision4. In 1997 the IUPAC nomenclature commission called the Berkeley discovery uncontested5.

Workers and communities

Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with seaborgium, a few atoms at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from seaborgium.

Who gains and who loses

We found no source on income from seaborgium. Berkeley Lab lists seaborgium among the 16 elements that its researchers are credited with6. In 1997 IUPAC also accepted seaborgium, the name that the Berkeley discoverers had proposed5.

Public debate

The name led to a dispute between IUPAC and the discoverers. Kenneth Hulet announced the name seaborgium in March 19947. Later in 1994, an IUPAC commission recommended the name rutherfordium for element 106 instead3. At the time, the commission held that an element should not be named after a living person85.

Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory (LBL) reported that the strongest criticism was about the removal of the name seaborgium. The LBL director, Charles Shank, said: “There has never been any debate about the right of acknowledged discoverers to name an element”9. In November 1994 the nomenclature committee of the American Chemical Society rejected the IUPAC names9. In 1995 the IUPAC executive committee recommended that IUPAC reconsider its decision9.

In 1995 IUPAC asked chemists for comments on the names5. Its commission wrote that chemists in general did not regard the rule on living persons as an important issue5. In March 1997 IUPAC reached a tentative agreement on the name seaborgium10. Glenn Seaborg lived until February 199911.

Sources

  1. 1

    A. Ghiorso, J. M. Nitschke, J. R. Alonso, C. T. Alonso, M. Nurmia, G. T. Seaborg, E. K. Hulet and R. W. Lougheed; Physical Review Letters 33(25) (1974) 1490-1493, 1974. Element 106 , pp. 1490 and 1493.

    The first report of element 106, the reaction, the half-life of 0.9 seconds and the decision to wait with a name. Free to read on the APS site.

    • G. N. Flerov of the Dubna Laboratory reported the observation of spontaneous fission activities
    • In view of the simultaneity of the experiments at the Dubna and Lawrence laboratories, and their very different nature, we shall postpone suggesting a name for element 106 until the situation has been clarified.
  2. 2

    IUPAC/IUPAP Transfermium Working Group (R. C. Barber, N. N. Greenwood, A. Z. Hrynkiewicz, Y. P. Jeannin, M. Lefort, M. Sakai, I. Ulehla, A. H. Wapstra and D. H. Wilkinson); Pure and Applied Chemistry 65(8), 1757-1814, 1993. Discovery of the transfermium elements , Part III, Element Z = 106, pp. 1786-1788, and the summary of conclusions, p. 1796.

    The working group's assessment of the Dubna and Berkeley-Livermore papers of 1974 on element 106, and its verdict.

    • 20 and 31 SF events respectively were found
    • was essentially contemporaneous
    • It seems likely that, in the work reported in … observed and assigned to the right element
    • does not yield sufficient confidence that the isotope
    • The Dubna work is highly important for later developments but does not demonstrate the formation of a new element with adequate conviction
  3. 3

    M. Thoennessen, National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory, Michigan State University (preprint for Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables), 2012. Discovery of Isotopes of Elements with Z ≥ 100 , arXiv:1203.2105v1, section 8, Discovery of 258-271 Sg.

    The Berkeley and Dubna reports of 1974, the TWG verdict, the naming dispute of 1994 to 1997 and the discovery of each isotope up to 2010.

    • A 95 MeV 18 O beam from the Berkeley SuperHILAC bombarded a 249 Cf target
    • The suggestion for the name seaborgium was not accepted by the 1994 Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry of IUPAC recommending the name rutherfordium instead
    • This decision was changed in 1997 when the name seaborgium was officially accepted
  4. 4

    A. Ghiorso and G. T. Seaborg (Berkeley), Yu. Ts. Oganessian and I. Zvara (Dubna), the GSI group, and the Transfermium Working Group; Pure and Applied Chemistry 65 (1993) 1815-1824, 1993. Responses on the report 'Discovery of the transfermium elements' , Section I (Berkeley, element Z = 106 and summary item 6) and section II (Dubna).

    Berkeley's agreement with the verdict on element 106 and its account of the Dubna fission activity, and Dubna's statement that it would respect the decision. Read with Firecrawl; the quote cache holds an excerpt.

    • Although we agree with the TWG CONCLUSION
    • the observed spontaneous fission activity was due primarily to 256104, the daughter of 260106, and not to element 106 (as demonstrated in 1984 by another team of Dubna investigators)
    • It seems to us that the TWG conclusions underestimate the importance of some Dubna papers on the elements 103, 104 and 105. But we have agreed to cooperate with the TWG and have thus assumed an obligation to respect its decision.
  5. 5

    IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 69(12), 2471-2473, 1997. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1997) , Recommendations, p. 2472, and the table of names and symbols, p. 2473.

    The acceptance of the name seaborgium, the change of the rule on living scientists, and the reasons.

    • The discovery of element 106 by the Berkeley laboratory is uncontested
    • the name proposed by the discoverers, seaborgium, was accepted
    • it also decided to modify its decision that the name of a living scientist should not be used as the basis for an element name
    • requesting submission of comments to CNIC
    • The responses from the NAOs and the chemical community showed quite clearly that chemists in general do not regard this as an important issue
  6. 6

    Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 2024. A New Way to Make Element 116 Opens the Door to Heavier Atoms , 23 July 2024, list of elements.

    Seaborgium in the list of the 16 elements that Berkeley Lab researchers are credited with.

    • Berkeley Lab researchers are credited in the discovery of 16 elements
    • 106 – Seaborgium
  7. 7

    Lynn Yarris, Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory (LBL Currents), 1994. Element 106 named in honor of Glenn T. Seaborg , 18 March 1994.

    The announcement of the name, Seaborg's words, the 1993 confirmation, and Seaborg's career.

    • The announcement was made by Kenneth Hulet
  8. 8

    IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 66(12), 2419-2421, 1994. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1994) , Recommendations, pp. 2420-2421.

    The 1994 vote (16 to 4) that an element should not be named after a living person, and the recommended name rutherfordium for element 106. Read in a browser; the quote cache holds the text.

    • that an element should not be named after a living person
  9. 9

    Lynn Yarris, Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, 1995. Element 106 name change being reconsidered , 12 May 1995.

    The IUPAC names of 1994, the reaction of LBL and the ACS, and the IUPAC executive committee's recommendation to reconsider.

    • The strongest criticism was directed towards the removal of the name seaborgium from element 106.
    • There has never been any debate about the right of acknowledged discoverers to name an element.
    • the nomenclature committee of the American Chemical Society (ACS) rejected the IUPAC names and unanimously endorsed the names given elements 104 to 108
    • has recommended that the organization’s decision be reconsidered
  10. 10

    The Berkeleyan, University of California, Berkeley, Office of Public Affairs, 1997. Finally, It's Seaborgium , 19 March 1997.

    The IUPAC agreement of March 1997 on the name and the support of the American Chemical Society in 1994.

    • After more than three years of sometimes fierce debate, the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC) has tentatively reached agreement to name element 106 Seaborgium
  11. 11

    Nobel Prize Outreach (from Nobel Lectures, Chemistry 1942-1962, Elsevier, 1964), 1964. Glenn T. Seaborg - Biographical .

    The birth and death of Glenn Seaborg and his work on the transuranium elements.

    • Glenn T. Seaborg died on February 25, 1999.