Plutonium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Plutonium for weapons left contaminated sites and harmed people nearby. A waste tank explosion at Mayak in 1957 forced more than 10,000 people to move6. US researchers injected eighteen patients with plutonium. Governments still disagree about surplus plutonium.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

Plutonium was made for war first. A plutonium bomb was used on Nagasaki on August 9, 1945. Los Alamos National Laboratory gives the deaths as over 40,0001. The Radiation Effects Research Foundation, a Japanese and US research body, gives a higher estimate. It counts 60,000 to 80,000 deaths in Nagasaki within two to four months2. It says that the exact number is not known2.

The United States and Russia disagreed about the disposal of surplus weapons plutonium. They signed an agreement in 2000. As amended in 2010, it committed each to eliminate 34 tonnes3. Russia suspended it in October 2016. It named “unfriendly actions of the United States”3. The IPFM, a group of independent experts, says the suspension came mostly from a dispute about the US decision to change its disposal method3. The United States had stopped its plan to use the plutonium as MOX fuel. In 2016 the NNSA said that the MOX approach would cost much more than expected4. The United States chose to dilute the plutonium and dispose of it underground5. Russia withdrew from the agreement in 20253.

Workers and communities

On September 29, 1957, a tank of liquid high-level waste exploded at the Mayak plant in the Soviet Union. It released about 740 PBq of radioactivity6. About a tenth spread beyond the site and formed the East Urals Radioactive Trace6. Twenty-two settlements with more than 10,000 people were moved6. For more than 30 years, neither the public nor scientists could get information about the accident6.

In the United States, the Rocky Flats Plant near Denver made plutonium pits from 19527. In June 1989 the FBI and the EPA opened an investigation into the plant for alleged environmental crimes7. Landowners near the plant sued its operators in 1990. In 2016 Rockwell and Dow Chemical agreed to pay them $375 million8.

From 1945 to 1947, Manhattan Project researchers injected eighteen patients with plutonium9. The researchers wanted data on the safety of workers who made nuclear weapons9. A US advisory committee reported in 1995 that none of the patients could expect a medical benefit. The committee wrote that, with one exception, the record suggests the patients were not told. It concluded that it is unlikely that they consented. All but one member of the committee accepted this reading9. The committee could not say whether any of them was physically harmed9.

Who gains and who loses

The costs of the weapon programs fall partly on governments and partly on people near the plants. The US Department of Energy and its contractor took 10 years and $7 billion to clean up Rocky Flats7. Rockwell expected the US Department of Energy to pay it back for its part of the 2016 settlement, under its contract8.

Projects to use surplus plutonium have also cost much without a result so far. The US MOX plant was cancelled in 2018 after “sharply rising costs” and long delays10. The Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA) says the new UK plan will bring work to Sellafield and support “thousands of skilled jobs for decades”11.

Public debate

The main debate is whether separated plutonium is a fuel or a waste. In 2011 the UK government made a preliminary decision to use its plutonium in MOX fuel. In January 2025 it decided to immobilize it for disposal1211. Japan still plans to use its plutonium as fuel, and says it holds no plutonium without a specific purpose13.

The WNA, an industry association, sees plutonium as a source of energy. It notes that civil stocks grow because reprocessing separates more than MOX uses5. In the United States, the WNA says, the plans of the early 1970s for a “plutonium economy” stopped in the 1976 presidential campaign14. In October 1976 President Ford said that reprocessing should not go ahead unless the world could control the risk of nuclear proliferation15. In April 1977 President Carter deferred commercial reprocessing indefinitely. In 1981 President Reagan lifted this ban15. The company that was building the Barnwell reprocessing plant then stopped the project. It said reprocessing was not practical on a commercial basis15. The WNA says reprocessing was “banned until 2005”. The Congressional Research Service gives the end of the ban as 198114.

Sources

  1. 1

    Los Alamos National Laboratory, 2025. Plutonium, in the Periodic Table of Elements .

    Hesperium, the first bombs, natural traces, the symbol and the secrecy.

    • it was detonated above Nagasaki on August 9, 1945, killing over 40,000 people
  2. 2

    Radiation Effects Research Foundation, 2025. Frequently Asked Questions about the Atomic-bomb Survivor Research Program .

    Estimates of the acute deaths in Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

    • Nagasaki 250,000-270,000 persons 60,000-80,000 persons
    • The total number of deaths is not known precisely
  3. 3

    International Panel on Fissile Materials (IPFM Blog), 2025. Russia withdraws from the Plutonium Management and Disposition Agreement .

    The history of the US-Russian plutonium disposition agreement, its suspension in 2016 and Russia's withdrawal in 2025.

    • committed the United States and Russia each to eliminate 34 tonnes of plutonium
    • Russia suspended the implementation of the agreement in October 2016, citing … unfriendly actions of the United States.
    • To a large extent the suspension was a result of a dispute about the United States unilaterally changing its plutonium disposition method
    • Russia withdraws from the Plutonium Management and Disposition Agreement
  4. 4

    Arms Control Association (Arms Control Today), 2016. Terminate MOX Fuel Plant, Budget Says , March 2016.

    The NNSA estimate of the yearly cost of the MOX approach.

    • the MOX fuel approach will be significantly more expensive than anticipated
  5. 5

    World Nuclear Association, 2026. Mixed Oxide (MOX) Fuel .

    Industry association. MOX use, fabrication plants, reactors that used MOX, and the US MOX plant.

    • The USA has instead adopted a ‘dilute and dispose’ approach, blending the 34 tonnes of surplus weapons-grade plutonium with inert material for disposal at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) in New Mexico.
    • At present the output of Western reprocessing plants exceeds the rate of plutonium usage in MOX, resulting in inventories of (civil) plutonium in several countries.
  6. 6

    A. V. Akleyev and others, Journal of Radiological Protection 37, 2017. Consequences of the radiation accident at the Mayak production association in 1957 (the ‘Kyshtym Accident’) .

    The 1957 waste tank explosion at Mayak, the East Urals Radioactive Trace, the relocation and the health studies.

    • when 20 MCi (740 PBq) of radionuclides were released by a chemical explosion in a radioactive waste storage tank
    • 2 MCi (74 PBq) spread beyond the Mayak PA site to form the East Urals Radioactive Trace (EURT).
    • In total, 22 settlements (including Berdyanish, Satlykovo, Galikaeva evacuated within 7–14 days) with the population over 10 000 people were relocated
    • Information about the causes of the accident and its consequences was unavailable for more than 30 years not only for the general population but also for the scientific community.
  7. 7

    U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Legacy Management, 2025. Rocky Flats Site, Colorado, Fact Sheet .

    The history of the Rocky Flats Plant, the 1989 investigation and the cleanup.

    • Construction of the Rocky Flats Plant began that same year and production began in 1952.
    • In June 1989, the FBI and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) opened an investigation into the Plant for alleged environmental crimes.
    • contractor completed a 10-year, $7 billion cleanup
  8. 8

    Rockwell Automation, 2016. Rocky Flats Case Settled , Press release, 19 May 2016.

    The settlement of the Cook v. Rockwell class action of landowners near Rocky Flats.

    • The parties agreed yesterday to settle Cook v. Rockwell International, a case that has been pending since 1990
    • Rockwell Automation and Dow Chemical will pay $375 million to resolve the claims of a class of landowners near Rocky Flats
    • Under Rockwell International’s contract and federal law, it is entitled to indemnification by the DoE for the settlement amount.
  9. 9

    Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments, 1995. ACHRE Report, Part II, Chapter 5: Conclusion .

    The plutonium injections of 1945 to 1947 and the committee's findings.

    • From 1945 through 1947 Manhattan Project researchers injected eighteen human
    • to obtain metabolic data related to the safety of those working on the production of nuclear weapons
    • All but one member of the Advisory Committee believe that what follows is the most plausible interpretation of the available evidence
    • In no case was there any expectation that these patient-subjects would benefit medically from the injections.
    • With one exception, the historical record suggests that these patients-subjects were not told
    • it is unlikely they consented to this use of their person
    • On the basis of available evidence, we could not conclude that any individual was or was not physically harmed as a result of the plutonium injections.
  10. 10

    Arms Control Association (Arms Control Today), 2018. DOE Terminates Troubled MOX Project , November 2018.

    The end of the US MOX plant and the reasons given.

    • Sharply rising costs, long construction delays, and doubt about the financial feasibility of the project
  11. 11

    Nuclear Decommissioning Authority, Sellafield Ltd and Nuclear Waste Services, 2025. NDA group welcomes Government decision on plutonium disposition , 24 January 2025.

    The UK decision to immobilize its civil plutonium.

    • bringing major investment to the area and supporting thousands of skilled jobs for decades
    • The NDA group has welcomed today’s UK Government policy decision to immobilise the UK’s inventory of civil separated plutonium at Sellafield.
  12. 12

    International Panel on Fissile Materials (IPFM Blog), 2025. United Kingdom plans to immobilize civilian plutonium .

    Earlier UK plans for its plutonium, and the amount in UK custody at the end of 2023.

    • In 2011, the government made a preliminary decision to use the plutonium in MOX fuel, but also stated that it is open to other options.
  13. 13

    Cabinet Office of Japan, Office of Atomic Energy Policy, 2026. The Status Report on Plutonium Management in Japan 2025 , 5 August 2026.

    Japan's separated plutonium at the end of 2025, in Japan and abroad, and its policy.

    • As a rule, this plutonium is to be fabricated into MOX fuels overseas and utilized at commercial reactors in Japan.
    • Japan upholds the principle of not possessing plutonium without specific purposes
  14. 14

    World Nuclear Association, 2026. Plutonium , Updated 30 March 2026.

    Industry association. Plutonium in power reactors, isotopes and grades, stocks, Pu-238 for spacecraft, weapons and disposition.

    • In the USA, the early 1970s objectives of developing a … were derailed in the 1976 presidential campaign
    • fuel reprocessing to recover and recycle plutonium was banned until 2005
  15. 15

    Congressional Research Service (copy hosted by EveryCRSReport), 2008. Nuclear Fuel Reprocessing: U.S. Policy Development (RS22542) , 27 March 2008.

    A timeline of US policy on reprocessing, including the Ford and Carter decisions and the Reagan reversal of 1981.

    • the reprocessing and recycling of plutonium should not proceed unless there is sound reason to conclude that the world community can effectively overcome the associated risks of proliferation
    • We will defer indefinitely the commercial reprocessing and recycling of plutonium produced in the U.S. nuclear power programs.
    • lifting the indefinite ban which previous administrations placed on commercial reprocessing activities in the United States
    • Convinced that the project could not proceed on a private basis and that reprocessing was commercially impracticable, Allied halted the Barnwell