Oganesson: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
The dispute was about the evidence. In 2011 the joint working party of IUPAC and IUPAP found that the decay chains reached no known nucleus. In its report of 2016 it accepted the claim of Dubna and Livermore4.
Oganesson is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →
Last updated 15 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
The first claim for element 118 came from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in 1999. The laboratory withdrew it in 20011. We give the reason, and the reply of the accused physicist, on the superheavy elements page.
The Dubna claim had a problem of its own. Its three decay chains of 2006 did not connect to any nucleus that was already well known. In 2006 Ken Moody, of the US team, told Nature that no other laboratory had confirmed the results. He added that the team checked everything twice2. In 2011 the joint working party (JWP) of IUPAC and IUPAP found that this did not meet the criteria3.
New evidence came from cross bombardments. Other experiments made livermorium-290 and flerovium-286, the descendants of oganesson-294, from curium and plutonium targets. Two of these were at Berkeley, in 2009 and 20104. A fourth chain of oganesson-294 in 2012 matched the first three4. In 2016 the JWP wrote that this gave solid evidence for the new atomic number4.
Workers and communities
Only research staff in accelerator laboratories have worked with oganesson. Its targets are radioactive. For the 2015 target, Oak Ridge moved only about 2 milligrams of californium at a time into a shielded glove box, to limit exposure5. We found no report of an injury or illness.
Who gains and who loses
We found no source on income from oganesson. The name honors a living scientist, Yuri Oganessian6. In 2026 he was the scientific leader of the Flerov Laboratory at JINR, where he has worked since 19587. In 2023 JINR announced an Oganesson Prize, set up by him, for young scientists and for people who explain science to the public8.
Public debate
IUPAC received many public comments on the four new names in 2016. Some people proposed other names, in some cases with petitions. IUPAC did not accept them, because only the discoverers may propose names9.
Sources
- 1
Bertram M. Schwarzschild, Physics Today (American Institute of Physics), 2002. Lawrence Berkeley Lab Concludes that Evidence of Element 118 Was a Fabrication , September 2002.
The 1999 Berkeley claim for element 118 and its retraction in July 2001.
-
LBNL had, in fact, already retracted the element-118 discovery claim in July 2001
-
- 2
Nature news (published online 17 October 2006), 2006. Russian-US team claims to have created element 118 , 17 October 2006.
The targets used, the comment on the difficulty of repeating the work, and the three atoms in more than 1,000 hours of experiments.
-
At this point none of our experiments has been confirmed by another lab
-
everything that we do is checked and double-checked
-
- 3
R. C. Barber, P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, E. Vardaci and E. W. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 83(7), 1485-1498, 2011. Discovery of the elements with atomic numbers greater than or equal to 113 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Profile 118; 01 with the JWP assessment; Summary of JWP conclusions.
The 2011 assessment that the three chains of element 118 had no anchor to known nuclei and did not meet the criteria.
-
The three events reported for the Z = 118 isotope have very good internal redundancy but with no anchor to known nuclei
-
- 4
P. J. Karol, R. C. Barber, B. M. Sherrill, E. Vardaci and T. Yamazaki (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 88(1-2), 155-160, 2016. Discovery of the element with atomic number Z = 118 completing the 7th row of the periodic table (IUPAC Technical Report) , Section 3.1, discovery profile for Z = 118, Table 1 and JWP assessment; section 5, summary.
The working party's review of the four decay chains of oganesson-294 (2002, 2005 and 2012), the cross bombardments that linked them to known nuclei, and the verdict for the Dubna-Livermore collaboration. The publisher refuses scripts; the text was read with Firecrawl.
-
is enhanced by the several cross bombardments independently producing descendants 290Lv and 286Fl
-
showing the results of fusion reactions of 48Ca with 245Cm or 242Pu
-
A (LBNL) Lawrence-Berkeley collaboration of Stavstra
-
at Berkeley in 2010
-
This result was confirmed in 2012.
-
This provides solid evidence that the new atomic number has been observed.
-
has satisfied the criteria for discovery and its claim is now acknowledged as validated
-
- 5
N. T. Brewer, V. K. Utyonkov, K. P. Rykaczewski, Yu. Ts. Oganessian and others, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, JINR Dubna and partners; Physical Review C 98, 024317, 2018. Search for the heaviest atomic nuclei among the products from reactions of mixed-Cf with a 48Ca beam (accepted manuscript) , Abstract; sections I, II.A, III.A, IV; figure 5; conclusions; acknowledgments.
The history of the five atoms, the mixed californium target from old sources at Oak Ridge, the runs of 2015 and 2016, the damaged target, the fifth atom and the funders.
-
Only enough Cf material for two target segments, about 2 mg, was moved into the shielded processing glove box at one time in order to limit exposure.
-
- 6
Lars Öhrström and Jan Reedijk, IUPAC Inorganic Chemistry Division; Pure and Applied Chemistry 88(12), 1225-1229, 2016. Names and symbols of the elements with atomic numbers 113, 115, 117 and 118 (IUPAC Recommendations 2016) , Section 1 (the 2016 guideline on endings) and section 2.4, element 118, with note 3.
The reason for the name, the ending -on for group 18, and the note that oganesson is the second element named after a living person.
-
This is the second element named after a living person
-
- 7
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (JINR), Dubna, 2026. Academician Yuri Oganessian celebrates 93rd birthday , 14 April 2026.
Yuri Oganessian's role at JINR in 2026, his work from 1958, and the elements his group made from 1999 to 2010.
-
Scientific Leader of the
-
Since 1958, Yuri Oganessian’s scientific activity has been inextricably linked with the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research.
-
- 8
Flerov Laboratory of Nuclear Reactions, JINR, Dubna, 2023. Academician Yuri Oganessian established the annual Oganesson Prize for young scientists , 17 April 2023.
The announcement of the Oganesson Prize on Yuri Oganessian's 90th birthday.
-
The establishment of the Prize was announced on the day of Yuri Oganessian’s 90th anniversary
-
Young scientists as well as popularizers of science will be able to become laureates of
-
- 9
International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry, 2016. IUPAC Announces the Names of the Elements 113, 115, 117, and 118 , 30 November 2016.
The approval of the name oganesson on 28 November 2016, the reason for the name and the public comments.
-
comments were received suggesting other names, in some cases accompanied by petitions from large groups of people
-
only the discoverers have the right to propose names and symbols
-