Nitrogen: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Nitrogen fertilizer feeds about half of the world's people, by published estimates. Nitrate gave Chile much of its state revenue after the War of the Pacific. Ammonium nitrate explosions have killed hundreds of people at a time, as at Oppau, Texas City and Beirut.

Last updated 5 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

The War of the Pacific (1879 to 1883) was fought partly over nitrate. Chile fought Peru and Bolivia. A historian of chemistry, Anthony Travis, writes that disputes over taxes and rights to the Atacama deposits led to the war1. A Library of Congress country study gives two Chilean aims: to get the nitrate fields, and to weaken Peru and Bolivia2. Chile took Tarapacá from Peru and Antofagasta from Bolivia. Bolivia lost its coast on the Pacific2. Bolivia later asked the International Court of Justice to rule that Chile must negotiate a sea outlet for Bolivia. In October 2018 the court found, by twelve votes to three, that Chile had no such legal obligation3.

Nitrogen is also a raw material for explosives. In the First World War, the British Navy blocked German access to Chilean nitrate. Germany made explosives from synthetic ammonia instead1.

War still affects the supply. In 2026 the closure of the Strait of Hormuz cut fertilizer exports from the Middle East. In Iran, which has 9 million tonnes a year of urea capacity, exports stopped4.

Workers and communities

Nitrate miners in Chile organized in the early 1900s and met force. A Library of Congress country study states that the government carried out several massacres of miners. It names Iquique in 1907 as the most notorious5.

Ammonium nitrate, a common fertilizer, can explode in a fire or when it is handled wrongly. The US Chemical Safety Board (CSB) lists several disasters:

  • Oppau, Germany, 1921: workers used explosives to loosen caked fertilizer. The explosion killed 500 to 600 people6.
  • Texas City, Texas, 1947: a ship with 7,000 tons of ammonium nitrate fertilizer exploded in the port and killed 581 people6.
  • West, Texas, 2013: a fire at a fertilizer store led to an explosion that killed 15 people6. Twelve of them were emergency responders6.

In Beirut in 2020, ammonium nitrate stored in the port since 2014 exploded. It killed 218 people, wounded 7,000 and damaged 77,000 apartments7. Human Rights Watch states that several Lebanese authorities were at a minimum criminally negligent under Lebanese law7.

Who gains and who loses

The nitrate boom in Chile lasted four decades. Export taxes on nitrate often gave more than half of all state revenue2. The country study notes that British and then US investors soon controlled the fields2. Synthetic nitrate from Germany ended the boom. Copper became Chile’s main export in the 1930s8.

Peru had a similar boom with guano, a nitrogen-rich fertilizer from seabird droppings. The state earned nearly $500 million from it9. Historian Magnus Mörner called the guano wealth “a developmental opportunity missed”, and most analysts agree, according to the country study9.

When fertilizer prices rise, farmers may use less. The IEA states that even small cuts in fertilizer use can lower crop yields4. It names countries that import all their ammonia or urea, such as Morocco and Brazil, as most at risk4.

Public debate

Nitrogen that farms lose to air and water harms nature. The International Energy Agency lists damage to soil and water and loss of biodiversity10. In the Netherlands, this became a political crisis. In May 2019 the Council of State, the highest administrative court, stopped the national permit system for nitrogen emissions. More than 18,000 projects were blocked11. About 2,500 farmers lost their nitrogen rights11. The government announced a transition fund of 25 billion euros up to 203511. Farmers protested many times. On 1 October 2019 about 2,200 tractors drove to The Hague11.

The dispute continued. In January 2025 the District Court of The Hague ruled on a case that Greenpeace brought. The court found that the new government had dropped the transition fund and the national rural area program12. It ordered the state to bring 50% of nitrogen-sensitive nature below its critical load by 31 December 203012. The critical load is the most nitrogen that a habitat can take without damage.

Sri Lanka tried the opposite direction. In April 2021 its president banned imports of chemical fertilizers and pesticides13. The authors of a 2025 study state that organic fertilizer could not meet demand, and rice and plantation crops suffered severe losses13. The government lifted the ban in November 202113.

Sources

  1. 1

    Anthony S. Travis, Science History Institute (Distillations), 2013. Dirty Business .

    Guano, Chilean saltpeter, the War of the Pacific and the first synthetic ammonia, by a historian of chemical technology.

    • Disputes over taxes and rights to the Atacama mineral deposits led to war between Peru and Chile from 1879 to 1883
    • During World War I the British Navy blocked Germany’s access to Chilean nitrates, and Germany responded by converting its synthetic ammonia
  2. 2

    Library of Congress, Federal Research Division (Rex A. Hudson, ed.), 1994. Chile: A Country Study. The War of the Pacific, 1879-83 .

    Causes and results of the War of the Pacific and the nitrate economy of Chile. The page is a copy of the Library of Congress text.

    • Chile wanted not only to acquire the nitrate fields but also to weaken Peru and Bolivia
    • These territories encompassed most of the Atacama Desert and blocked off Bolivia’s outlet to the Pacific Ocean
    • The boom lasted four decades. Export taxes on nitrates often furnished over 50 percent of all state revenues
    • Soon controlled by British and then by United States investors
  3. 3

    International Court of Justice, 2018. Obligation to Negotiate Access to the Pacific Ocean (Bolivia v. Chile), Judgment of 1 October 2018 , Paragraph 177.

    The operative clause of the judgment. Read in a browser.

    • Finds that the Republic of Chile did not undertake a legal obligation to negotiate a sovereign access to the Pacific Ocean for the Plurinational State of Bolivia
    • By twelve votes to three
  4. 4

    International Energy Agency, 2026. Global Hydrogen Review 2026 , Chapter 1, pp. 20-23: fertilisers and the conflict in the Middle East; Figure 1.1.

    Ammonia and urea trade in 2024, the 2026 closure of the Strait of Hormuz, prices and government measures.

    • In Iran, which has a total capacity of 9 Mtpa of urea, exports have ceased due to the conflict
    • Even modest reductions in fertiliser use can lead to declines in crop yields
    • The risk is particularly acute in import-dependent agricultural economies, such as … Morocco, which meets all its demand for ammonia with imports … Brazil, Australia, South Africa and Thailand, which meet all their demand for urea with imports
  5. 5

    Library of Congress, Federal Research Division (Rex A. Hudson, ed.), 1994. Chile: A Country Study. The Parliamentary Republic, 1891-1925 .

    Labor movement and massacres in the nitrate camps.

    • The government carried out several massacres of miners in the nitrate camps; the most notorious took place in Iquique in 1907
  6. 6

    U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board, 2016. Investigation Report: West Fertilizer Company Fire and Explosion , Section 3.4 (consequences); 4.1.4 (previous incidents); Section 7 (Texas City).

    The 2013 West, Texas explosion and earlier ammonium nitrate disasters at Oppau (1921) and Texas City (1947).

    • workers fired explosives into a caked mixture of fertilizer to loosen 4,500 tons … The explosion killed 500 to 600 people
    • a ship containing 7,000 tons of wax-coated FGAN 263 exploded in the port of Texas City, Texas, killing 581 people
    • a massive explosion occurred, killing 15 people
    • 12 emergency responders and 3 members of the public
  7. 7

    Human Rights Watch, 2021. 'They Killed Us from the Inside': An Investigation into the August 4 Beirut Blast , Summary.

    The 2020 Beirut port explosion, its cause and its casualties.

    • The Beirut port explosion killed 218 people … It wounded 7,000 people … damaged 77,000 apartments
    • multiple Lebanese authorities were, at a minimum, criminally negligent under Lebanese law
  8. 8

    Library of Congress, Federal Research Division (Rex A. Hudson, ed.), 1994. Chile: A Country Study. The Postwar Period .

    Effect of German synthetic nitrate on Chilean exports.

    • German development of artificial nitrates was especially damaging, and thereafter copper would gradually surpass nitrates as the leading export, taking over conclusively in the 1930s
  9. 9

    Library of Congress, Federal Research Division (Rex A. Hudson, ed.), 1992. Peru: A Country Study. The Guano Era .

    Peruvian guano exports and state revenue, 1840s to 1870s.

    • a truly enormous flow of revenue to the state (nearly US$500 million)
    • guano wealth was, on the whole, a developmental opportunity missed
  10. 10

    International Energy Agency, 2021. Ammonia Technology Roadmap: Towards more sustainable nitrogen fertiliser production , Executive summary pp. 8-12; Chapter 1 pp. 14-16, 22-30, 34.

    Uses, energy, CO2, production by country, trade, process and scenarios for ammonia, mostly for 2020.

    • Soil and water quality degradation and biodiversity loss from excess nitrogen
  11. 11

    Trond Selnes, Food System Economics Commission, 2023. The Netherlands Food System Policy: Nitrogen Emission Reduction , Summary and section 1.

    The 2019 Dutch court ruling on nitrogen permits, its effects and the farmer protests.

    • agreed with the European ruling in May 2019 … PAS was frozen and over 18,000 projects blocked
    • About 2500 farmers lost their nitrogen rights
    • A transition fund worth a cumulative 25 billion euros up to 2035 is announced
    • On 1 October 2019 about 2,200 tractors took off for The Hague
  12. 12

    Rechtbank Den Haag (District Court of The Hague), 2025. Greenpeace Nederland v. the State of the Netherlands, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2025:578 , Sections 5.96 and 6.2.

    Judgment of 22 January 2025, in Dutch. The court ordered the state to meet the legal nitrogen target for 2030.

    • de huidige regering belangrijke pijlers onder de stikstofdepositiereductie, te weten het NPLG en het Transitiefonds, heeft geschrapt
    • beveelt de Staat het nog niet gerealiseerde deel van het stikstofdoel van 50% van het areaal stikstofgevoelige natuur uiterlijk op 31 december 2030 onder de toepasselijke KDW-en te brengen
  13. 13

    P. Drechsel, P. Madhuwanthi, D. Nisansala, D. Ramamoorthi and T. Bandara, Food Security 17, 2025. On the feasibility of an agricultural revolution: Sri Lanka's ban of chemical fertilizers in 2021 , Abstract; 'The Sri Lankan context'.

    The April 2021 ban on chemical fertilizer imports in Sri Lanka and its end in November 2021.

    • Sri Lanka’s president at that time, Gotabaya Rajapaksa, announced a ban on importing agrochemicals
    • the ensuing rush for organic fertilizers failed to meet the national demand, resulting in severe losses in rice and export-oriented plantation crops
    • Facing decreasing yields and food insecurity, the government lifted the ban in November 2021