Niobium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Most niobium comes from a few large mines in Brazil and Canada, not from conflict areas. Some comes from artisanal coltan mining in central Africa, where workers can receive high doses of radiation. In Brazil, CBMM and the state of Minas Gerais share the profits of Araxá.
Last updated 10 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Most niobium comes from large industrial mines in Brazil and Canada. A small share comes from coltan, an ore of tantalum and niobium mined by hand in central Africa. USGS reports that sales of coltan in Congo (Kinshasa) were attributed to rebel forces in a civil war. For this reason, USGS says, a traceable supply chain is needed1.
The conflict continues. In 2025 the M23 rebel group controlled the Rubaya coltan mines in eastern Congo (Kinshasa), the Associated Press reported2. A UN group of experts reported that coltan from Rubaya was smuggled to Rwanda. There, it was mixed with Rwandan production and exported2. Rwanda denied the allegations2.
A US law of 2010 applies to companies that report to the Securities and Exchange Commission. They must say whether they buy minerals from Congo (Kinshasa) or its neighbors1. In 2011 the International Tin Research Institute started a tracing program for columbite-tantalite in Rwanda and Katanga1.
Workers and communities
Niobium ores can be radioactive. In Congo (Kinshasa), artisanal miners who grind and sieve columbite-tantalite ores receive high doses of radiation1. In Brazil, a 1998 study found significant radioactivity in the fine tailings at the Araxá mine1. At a niobium processing plant in Brazil, doses from slag and acid-leaching waste exceeded international guidelines1. The Pitinga mine disposes of at least 10,000 tonnes of naturally radioactive waste every year, by the same 1998 study1.
Niobium itself has low toxicity1.
Small-scale mining often leaves damage behind. In the Jos area of Nigeria, tin and tantalum-niobium mining has drastically changed the land, and little has been done to repair it1. USGS lists low crop yields and land disputes among the effects1.
At Araxá, CBMM has five dams at its industrial site. Three of them hold tailings and residues from niobium concentration3. CBMM reports that it recirculated 96.3% of its water in 20223.
Who gains and who loses
The state of Minas Gerais shares in the profit of Araxá. CBMM and the state company Codemig have been partners in the mine since 1972. Under the partnership, CBMM takes 75% of the net profit and Codemig 25%4. In October 2025 the state renewed this agreement for 30 years. It replaces the old contract, which would have ended in 20324. The state also discussed the transfer of Codemig to the federal government, as part of a program to pay its debts4.
CBMM itself is 70% owned by Grupo Moreira Salles. Japanese and South Korean companies own 15%, and Chinese companies 15%5.
For Brazil as a whole, niobium is small. In 2018 Hugo Nadler, a former CBMM executive, said mining was 5% of Brazil’s GDP. He called the niobium part of it “nothing”6.
Public debate
Niobium became a political topic in Brazil. Jair Bolsonaro made a video about it at the CBMM mine in 2016. In 2018 he made niobium a campaign issue. The news report says he is believed to be the first presidential candidate to do so6. He criticized the sale of a Brazilian niobium mine to China Molybdenum. He said Brazil should invest in research to use the mineral, instead of selling the mine6. In his video he said niobium “can give [Brazil] economic independence”6.
Mining experts quoted in the report said these fears were exaggerated6. Nadler said CMOC’s mine had only about 10% of the world market6.
In June 2025 Codemig classified documents on its partnership with CBMM as secret for 15 years4.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Geological Survey (K.J. Schulz, N.M. Piatak, J.F. Papp), 2017. Niobium and Tantalum, chap. M of Critical mineral resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802) , Abstract; Introduction; Uses; Geochemistry; Mineralogy; Deposit Types and table M3; Carbonatites; Resources and Production; Environmental Considerations.
Crustal abundance, minerals, deposit types, Araxá and Niobec, resources, production history, uses, health, radioactive waste.
-
attributed to rebel forces waging a civil war in Congo (Kinshasa) has been of recent concern and has highlighted the need for a transparent and traceable global supply chain
-
companies that report to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission must reveal whether they buy minerals from Congo (Kinshasa) or any of its neighbors
-
A program related to establishing a conflict-free supply chain for columbite-tantalite was launched by the International Tin Research Institute in 2011 in Rwanda and the Katanga Province of Congo (Kinshasa)
-
the grinding and sieving of columbite-tantalite ores during artisanal mining has been shown to expose workers to high doses of radioactivity
-
significant radioactivity (approximately 100 kBq/kg of 226Ra) for fine-grained tailings at the Araxá Mine in Brazil
-
disposed of in alternating layers in waste dumps at a niobium processing facility in Brazil yielded higher radionuclide concentrations than did ores and other waste materials, and doses associated with them exceed international exposure guidelines
-
at least 10,000 metric tons of naturally occurring radioactive wastes are disposed of every year
-
Niobium and tantalum are generally considered nonessential for humans and have low toxicity
-
tin (and tantalum-niobium) mining in the Jos area of Nigeria has drastically changed the landscape, and little has been done in the way of remediation efforts
-
low crop yields on agricultural lands, local land disputes from soil erosion problems
-
- 2
Associated Press (Monika Pronczuk), 4 July 2025, as published by WSLS, 2025. UN experts say Rwanda supported rebels in Congo and smuggled minerals at 'unprecedented levels' .
The UN group of experts on coltan from the M23-controlled Rubaya mines, and Rwanda's denial.
-
The M23-controlled Rubaya mines produce coltan
-
particularly coltan from the AFC-controlled Rubaya mine, continued to be smuggled to Rwanda
-
These minerals were then mixed with production of Rwandan origin and exported downstream
-
Rwanda denied the allegations from the U.N. report
-
- 3
Companhia Brasileira de Metalurgia e Mineração (CBMM), 2023. Sustainability Report 2022 , CEO message; 2022 highlights; The CBMM; The Niobium; Waste and dams.
CBMM's founding year, revenue, emissions per tonne, tailings dams, and its claim about niobium in steel.
-
Our industrial hub has five dams
-
three for residues and tailings disposal from the Niobium concentration process
-
96.3% water
-
- 4
O Fator (Lucas Ragazzi), 30 October 2025, 2025. Codemig e CBMM renovam acordo para exploração do nióbio de Araxá (Codemig and CBMM renew the agreement to mine Araxá niobium) .
The partnership of Codemig and CBMM since 1972, the 75/25 split of net profit, and the renewal of 2025.
-
A parceria entre as duas empresas existe desde 1972
-
a CBMM fica com 75% dos lucros líquidos e a Codemig, com 25%
-
renovaram nesta quinta-feira (30), por mais 30 anos, o contrato com a Companhia Brasileira de Metalurgia e Mineração (CBMM) para exploração de nióbio em Araxá
-
O contrato substitui o anterior, que venceria em 2032
-
para as negociações do Programa de Pleno Pagamento das Dívidas dos Estados (Propag) e para a possível federalização da Codemig
-
Em junho, a Codemig impôs sigilo de 15 anos sobre documentos da parceria com a CBMM
-
- 5
U.S. Geological Survey (C.A. Friedline), 2026. Niobium, in 2022 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , pp. 52.1 to 52.3: Government Actions, Production, Consumption, Prices, World Review, Outlook; tables 2, 4 and 5.
World end uses, producers and owners, CBMM, Niobec, China's imports, ferroniobium production by country, stockpile history, prices.
-
70% of its capital owned by Grupo Moreira Salles, 15% by a Japanese and South Korean consortium, and 15% by a Chinese consortium
-
- 6
VOA Learning English (Jonathan Evans), adapted from a report by Jake Spring, 26 October 2018, 2018. Presidential Candidate Says a Rare Metal Important to Brazil's Future .
Jair Bolsonaro's campaign statements about niobium, and replies from a former CBMM executive and from CBMM. VOA's credit line says that Jake Spring reported the story for the Associated Press, but its text says that CBMM 'told Reuters'. We cite VOA only and do not name the agency in the text.
-
Mining makes up 5 percent of GDP, if you take the portion that is niobium, it’s nothing
-
The 2016 video was recorded at a mine owned by a privately-held Brazilian company known as CBMM
-
Bolsonaro is believed to be the first presidential candidate to make niobium a campaign issue
-
It’s something only we have, we should invest in technology and research to use this mineral. Instead we sell and deliver the mine to them
-
can give [Brazil] economic independence
-
Mining experts say Bolsonaro’s niobium fears are exaggerated
-
He says CMOC’s Brazil mine makes up just 10 percent of the global market
-