Neodymium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Patents on neodymium magnets led to trade cases in the US in 1996 and 2012. In 2025, carmakers could not get enough magnets after China's export controls. Doctors supported a US rule of 2022 on small strong magnets; many magnet users opposed it. A court upheld it in 2025.
Neodymium is one of the rare earth elements. How they are mined, separated, sold and controlled →
Last updated 13 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Patents shaped the magnet industry. The US Department of Energy cites a US trade case of 1996. It found that Chinese companies had skirted intellectual property rights when they exported magnets to the US1. Hitachi holds patents on the standard ways to make sintered magnets. Four of them were the subject of a complaint to the US International Trade Commission in 20121. These patents were due to expire in 2021 and 20221. The DOE says that patents held by Japanese companies helped to stop Chinese magnet makers from flooding the Japanese market1.
In 2025, China’s export controls cut the supply of magnets to carmakers in the US and Europe (see the power chapter). For the trade disputes over all rare earths, such as the case at the World Trade Organization, see the rare earths page.
Workers and communities
Neodymium comes from the same mines and separation plants as the other light rare earths. For the workers and communities near them, see the rare earths page. The DOE notes a hazard in magnet making: the fine magnet powders can catch fire in air1.
Who gains and who loses
Magnet makers in China can buy metal at home. The DOE says that the supply of rare earth metals in China was a main reason why Hitachi, Shin-Etsu, TDK and Vacuumschmelze opened factories there1. The DOE adds that magnet-making equipment from China costs one third to one half as much as Western equipment1.
Public debate
Small, strong magnets can hurt children who swallow two or more of them (see the impact chapter)2. Many such magnets are neodymium magnets2. The US Consumer Product Safety Commission estimates 26,600 swallowed magnets treated in emergency departments from 2010 to 20212. Its staff knew of seven deaths from 2005 to 2021, two of them outside the US2.
In November 2016, a US appeals court vacated a first CPSC rule, of 20142. A new rule took effect on 21 October 2022. It limits the strength of small loose magnets in products for play, jewelry and stress relief2.
Doctors, medical associations and consumer groups supported the rule. They said that warnings are not enough2. Most opponents were individual consumers, some magnet makers and hobby groups2. Many said that warnings were a better way, and that adults should be free to buy the products2.
Magnetsafety.org and two hobby trade groups asked a US appeals court to set the rule aside3. In March 2025, the court denied the petition3.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Department of Energy, 2022. Rare Earth Permanent Magnets: Supply Chain Deep Dive Assessment , Executive summary; sections 2.1, 2.2.5 (recycling) and 3.3 (magnet alloys and magnets, patents).
China's shares along the magnet supply chain, sintered and bonded magnets, magnet recycling, patents and trade cases.
-
a 1996 USITC case from 1996 determined that Chinese companies skirted IP rights when exporting magnets to the U.S. market
-
Hitachi holds patents covering the standard techniques for producing sintered magnets
-
Four Hitachi patents were the subject of a 2012 complaint to the International Trade Commission (ITC)
-
those were set to expire in 2021 and 2022
-
U.S. and foreign patents owned by Japanese companies such as Hitachi have helped to keep Chinese magnet producers from flooding the Japanese domestic markets
-
These powders are pyrophoric, or prone to igniting when exposed to air
-
The availability and stability of supply of rare earth metals in China has been a key driver of this shift
-
China also manufactures equipment to manufacture magnets that is about one-third to one-half the cost of Western equipment
-
- 2
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Federal Register, 2022. Safety Standard for Magnets (Final rule, 87 FR 57756) , Summary; Dates; sections on the incident data, the court case and the comments.
The US rule on small, strong magnets in consumer products, the injury estimates behind it, and the earlier court case.
-
small, powerful magnets that, when ingested, can interact internally through body tissue, which can lead to acute and long-term health consequences or death
-
NIB is typically used in smaller magnets
-
estimated 26,600 (2,800 in 2021) ED-treated magnet ingestions involving magnet products of various types from 2010 through 2021
-
Staff is aware of seven deaths that occurred in the period November 24, 2005, to January 5, 2021, involving ingestion of hazardous magnets
-
Two of these deaths occurred abroad
-
vacated and remanded by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit Court in November 2016
-
This rule is effective on October 21, 2022
-
must have a flux index of less than 50 kG2 mm2
-
These commenters argued that safety messaging and safeguards are insufficient to address the magnet ingestion hazard
-
most who commented in opposition to the proposed rule were individual consumers, along with several subject magnet product manufacturers and hobbyist groups
-
Numerous individual commenters argued that approaches involving safety messaging and warnings are more appropriate than strength and size limitations
-
Most who oppose the proposed rule requested that adult products be excluded from the scope of the rule
-
- 3
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, 2025. Magnetsafety.org v. Consumer Product Safety Commission, No. 22-9578 (opinion) , Pp. 1-3 (parties, holding) and the conclusion.
The court denied the petition of magnet sellers and hobby groups against the CPSC magnet rule of 2022, on 3 March 2025. Copy of the opinion hosted by Washburn University School of Law.
-
HOBBY MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION; NATIONAL RETAIL HOBBY STORES ASSOCIATION, INC., Petitioners
-
Because this rule is supported by substantial evidence and the Commission is constitutionally structured, we deny this petition for review.
-