Molybdenum: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Wars raised demand for molybdenum, for armor and aircraft. Today the main disputes concern mine waste and water. The US government lists the closed Questa mine in New Mexico as a Superfund site. In Armenia, a copper and molybdenum company reports that it is the largest taxpayer.
Last updated 10 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
War has shaped the molybdenum industry. USGS writes that demand for molybdenum in armor and aircraft during international conflicts helped make molybdenite mining pay1.
New mines can face legal challenges. In July 2019, a US court blocked all construction at the Rosemont copper project of Hudbay Minerals. The court sent back its mining permits because of environmental concerns. USGS listed it among molybdenum projects2. Hudbay said that it would appeal2. In May 2022, the federal appeals court for the Ninth Circuit upheld the ruling in a split decision. Hudbay said that it would go on with its Copper World project nearby, on its own land33.
Workers and communities
Molybdenum ore is poor, so mines leave large amounts of waste. At arc-related porphyry molybdenum deposits, the tonnage of tailings is about the same as the tonnage of the deposit1. The Thompson Creek mine in Idaho made about 5.7 million cubic meters of tailings a year at full production1. USGS notes that in these deposits, calcite in the rock partly neutralizes the acid that pyrite makes, so mine waters are often near neutral1.
The Questa mine in New Mexico is now a Superfund site. It operated on and off from 1920 until 2014, when Chevron Mining closed it4. According to the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), mining and waste disposal contaminated soil, sediment, surface water and groundwater. The mine left about 328 million tons of acid-generating waste rock in nine piles4. EPA chose a cleanup plan in 2010 and put the site on its Superfund list in September 201144.
In March 2026, the EPA decided not to set a national drinking water standard for molybdenum5. A 2020 assessment by ATSDR, a US health agency, describes several harmful effects of molybdenum. The EPA based its health reference level on kidney effects in rats from that assessment5. But in public water systems, the EPA found that molybdenum is not frequent enough or high enough to be a health concern5. In national monitoring from 2013 to 2015, 0.1% of systems reported results above the EPA’s health reference level of 100 micrograms per liter5.
IMOA, the producers’ association, made a submission in support of the EPA’s preliminary decision of January 20256. IMOA also reports that Canada is working on a federal water quality standard for molybdenum to protect aquatic life6.
Who gains and who loses
Copper miners gain from molybdenum as an extra product. At US copper mines, the accounts put all mining costs on copper2. Primary molybdenum mines have no such support. Some US primary mines have stopped: Thompson Creek in Idaho went on care and maintenance in 2014, and Questa closed the same year2. USGS reports that a Canadian company plans to restart the Idaho mine in the second half of 20277.
Governments of producing countries gain tax income. In Armenia, the Zangezur Copper and Molybdenum Combine reports that it paid 41.6 billion drams in taxes in the first half of 2026. That is twice as much as a year earlier8.
The owners of the company have changed. In 2011, the German group Cronimet owned most of it9. RFE/RL reported that the ownership was not clear after Cronimet sold its controlling stake, reportedly in 201910. In 2021, a subsidiary of GeoProMining, a Russian group, bought 60% of the company. It gave a quarter of this stake, 15% of the company, to the Armenian government1010.
USGS wrote in 2019 that China had many small mines, which could raise or cut output quickly when prices changed2.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Geological Survey (R.D. Taylor, J.M. Hammarstrom, N.M. Piatak, R.R. Seal II), 2012. Arc-related porphyry molybdenum deposit model, chap. D of Mineral deposit models for resource assessment (Scientific Investigations Report 2010-5070-D) , Abstract; Introduction; Deposit size and grade; Geoenvironmental features.
How porphyry molybdenum deposits form, their size and grade, where they are, rhenium, and mine waste.
-
Molybdenum use in armor and airplanes has helped shape the economic viability of mining molybdenite based on demand brought about by international conflicts
-
The tonnages of tailings are essentially the same as the tonnages of the deposits, because of the low volumes of ore minerals
-
At full mill production, the Thompson Creek mine in Idaho produces about 5.7 million cubic meters of tailings each year
-
waters being near-neutral pH because of the acid generating potential of pyrite being partially buffered by late-stage calcite-bearing veins
-
- 2
U.S. Geological Survey (D.E. Polyak), 2021. Molybdenum, in 2019 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , Production; Consumption; Prices; World Review (Chile, China, Armenia).
US mines, the cost allocation at copper mines, Climax, Thompson Creek, Rosemont, producers in Chile and China, uses of chemicals, prices.
-
In July, Hudbay Minerals Inc.’s (Canada) Rosemont copper project received a court ruling that blocked all construction, and the court remanded all of Rosemont’s mining permits owing to environmental concerns
-
Hudbay intended to appeal the court’s ruling
-
all mining costs associated with molybdenum concentrate production were allocated to the primary metal (copper)
-
The Thompson Creek Mine in Idaho was placed on careand-maintenance status in 2014 and did not produce any molybdenum in 2019. The Ashdown Mine in Nevada and the Questa Mine in New Mexico remained closed
-
China had many small-scale mining operations that were susceptible to changes in prices but were able to quickly increase or decrease production during price fluctuations
-
- 3
Hudbay Minerals Inc., press release, 12 May 2022, 2022. The U.S. Department of Justice and Hudbay Receive Rosemont 9th Circuit Court Ruling; Hudbay Continues to Advance Copper World .
The appeals court ruling of May 2022 on the Rosemont project, and the company's plan for Copper World. The company's own statement.
-
received a split decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit … which affirmed the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona’s … decision in July 2019
-
Hudbay has successfully discovered the Copper World deposits located on patented mining claims adjacent to Rosemont
-
- 4
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2026. Chevron Questa Mine, Superfund site: cleanup activities , Background; What Has Been Done to Clean Up the Site?.
The history of the Questa mine, its waste rock and tailings, and its Superfund listing.
-
operated intermittently from 1920 until 2014, when Chevron Mining Inc. (CMI) permanently closed the mine
-
Mining operations and waste disposal contaminated soil, sediment, surface water and groundwater. While the mine was operating, about 328 million tons of acid-generating waste rock were excavated and deposited in nine large waste rock piles
-
EPA selected the remedy in a December 20, 2010 Record of Decision (ROD)
-
The site was placed on the NPL on September 16, 2011
-
- 5
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Federal Register Vol. 91, No. 53, pp. 13227-13236 (FR Doc. 2026-05452), 2026. Announcement of Final Regulatory Determinations for Contaminants on the Fifth Drinking Water Contaminant Candidate List , Section E, Molybdenum (pp. 13232-13233).
The final decision of the EPA, March 2026, not to regulate molybdenum in drinking water, with its reasons and the monitoring data.
-
The EPA is therefore making a final determination not to regulate molybdenum with an NPDWR
-
The 2020 ATSDR health assessment describes multiple adverse health effects for molybdenum, and ATSDR selected kidney effects in female rats as the critical effect
-
the EPA has determined that molybdenum does not occur with a frequency and at levels of public health concern in PWSs
-
The EPA derived an HRL for molybdenum of 100 [micro]g/L … UCMR 3 program (2013-2015) … 0.1% of systems reported results above the HRL
-
- 6
International Molybdenum Association (IMOA), 2026. IMOA Annual Review 2025/2026 , President's and Secretary-General's report; Molybdenum-in-scrap study; chart 'Molybdenum end use sectors 2025'.
World end use in 2025, the scrap study, end use by sector, and the IMOA submission to the EPA on drinking water.
-
This final determination is the outcome of the EPA’s January 2025 preliminary determination, for which IMOA also made a supportive submission
-
Canada continues to advance a federal water quality standard for molybdenum to protect aquatic life
-
- 7
U.S. Geological Survey (D.E. Polyak), 2026. Molybdenum, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , p. 1, Domestic Production and Use, Salient Statistics, Recycling, Import Sources; p. 2, Events, World Mine Production and Reserves, World Resources, Substitutes, footnotes.
World production and reserves by country, US production, prices, recycling, China's export controls, substitutes.
-
A Canadian company remained on schedule to restart its idled molybdenum mine in Idaho during the second half of 2027
-
- 8
Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine, 24 July 2026, 2026. ZCMC: the First Taxpayer Again .
The company's own statement that it was Armenia's largest taxpayer in the first half of 2026.
-
During the first 6 months of 2026, the Company paid 41.6 billion drams in taxes to the state budget, which is twice as much compared with the same period in 2025
-
- 9
Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, Armenian Service, August 2011, 2011. Mining Giant Becomes Armenia's Largest Taxpayer .
The Zangezur Copper and Molybdenum Combine as Armenia's largest taxpayer in the first half of 2011, its owner Cronimet, and the role of molybdenum prices.
-
Mining Giant Becomes Armenia’s Largest Taxpayer … The ZCMC, which is based in the southeastern town of Karajan and majority owned by the German metals group Cronimet
-
- 10
Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, Armenian Service (Naira Nalbandian), 1 October 2021, 2021. Armenian Mining Giant Changes Hands .
The sale of 60% of the Zangezur Copper and Molybdenum Combine to a GeoProMining subsidiary in 2021, and the gift of 15% of the company to the Armenian government.
-
ZCMC’s ownership structure changed significantly but remained opaque after Cronimet reportedly sold its controlling stake in 2019
-
a GeoProMining subsidiary acquired 60 percent of ZCMC on Thursday and then
-
constitute 15 percent of the equity of ZCMC that will consequently belong to the Republic of Armenia
-