Mercury: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Minamata disease led to decades of lawsuits in Japan. By 2024, 3,000 people were recognized as patients. Over 15 million people work in small-scale gold mining, the largest use of mercury. UNEP reports that illegal trade grew as legal trade came under more control.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

Minamata disease in Japan led to a long dispute. In 1968 the Japanese government named methylmercury as the cause. It came from the acetaldehyde plants of Chisso in Minamata and Showa Denko on the Agano River1. The two companies must compensate the patients and the fishermen, and pay to restore the polluted environment2.

Many patients went to court. A political solution in 1995 ended most cases. New suits followed after a Supreme Court decision of 2004, which found the national government and Kumamoto Prefecture also liable2. A law of 2009 set up more aid2, and some groups settled in March 2011. Some cases are still in court2.

In September 2023 the Osaka District Court recognized all 128 plaintiffs in one case as victims of Minamata disease. It ordered the government, Kumamoto Prefecture and Chisso to pay 2.75 million yen to each3. The plaintiffs said that the 2009 relief program had left them out unfairly. The government had argued that there was no evidence that they had the disease3.

The second dispute is about illegal trade. UNEP reports that as controls on the trade grew and the price stayed high, undocumented and illegal transfers increased4. A German company illegally exported large amounts of mercury to Switzerland, described as waste. Customs officers in Indonesia and the Philippines stopped Indonesian mercury and cinnabar in shipping containers4. Mercury imported by Colombia and Bolivia moved informally to Peru and other neighbors, mostly for gold mining4.

Workers and communities

Mercury mining has harmed workers for centuries. Under Spanish rule, the mita labor draft forced men from the villages around Huancavelica and Potosí to work in the mines5. Men from 18 to 50 years old had to work 2 months at Huancavelica or 12 months at Potosí5. In 1604 an advocate for the native people wrote of a cough and illness from the vapors and dust, called the illness of Huancavelica5. Robins and Hagan write that the mita played a central role in the destruction of indigenous communities5.

Today many of the people exposed to mercury at work are small-scale gold miners. AMAP and UNEP cite over 15 million miners and possibly 100 million people living in mining communities6. Small-scale gold mining is also the largest human source of mercury in the air (see impact).

Who gains and who loses

By March 2001, Japan had certified 2,955 patients, and the companies had paid about 144.1 billion yen in compensation7. By December 2024 the number of recognized patients was 3,000, of whom 304 were alive2. Another 38,320 people get medical aid without being recognized as patients2.

The national and prefectural governments have supported Chisso since 1978. They feared that the company could not go on paying2.

New mercury mines bring income to the places around them. UNEP warns that once communities depend on this income, the mines may be hard to close, as the Convention requires4.

Public debate

Dental amalgam is one debate. In many countries, more people prefer other fillings4. In poorer countries, better dental care has increased amalgam use, because mercury-free fillings may be less available there4. The Convention of 2013 asked parties to phase down amalgam8. In November 2025 the parties agreed to phase it out by 20349.

Skin lightening creams are another. The WHO writes that creams with mercury are hazardous and banned in many countries, but still found for sale10.

Vaccines are a third. Some vaccines hold thiomersal, a preservative that contains ethylmercury. The WHO states that it does not pose a health risk and that it differs from methylmercury10. The CDC vaccine advisory committee recommended the removal of thiomersal from all flu vaccines in the United States. In July 2025 the US Health Secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., signed this recommendation11. Kennedy said that the aim was to protect the most vulnerable people from unnecessary mercury exposure11.

Sources

  1. 1

    Ministry of the Environment, Japan, 2002. Minamata Disease: The History and Measures. Chapter 2, Outbreak and cause .

    The first patients in 1956 and 1965 and the government's finding of 1968.

    • methylmercury compound, which was produced as by-product in the process of manufacturing acetaldehyde at Chisso Co., Ltd. in Minamata City and Showa Denko Co., Ltd. located upstream of Agano River
  2. 2

    National Institute for Minamata Disease, Ministry of the Environment, Japan, 2025. Countermeasures against Minamata disease (questions and answers) .

    Recognized patients to December 2024, the 1995 political solution, the 2004 Supreme Court decision, the 2009 act and state support for Chisso.

    • are liable to compensate the patients, restore the polluted environment and provide compensation for fishing lost due to the pollution
    • Following a political solution reached in 1995 so as to solve the issue of Minamata disease, most of these cases had been withdrawn, but new actions were brought again after a Supreme Court decision came out in 2004
    • (Act No. 81 of 2009
    • a settlement was reached in March 2011. There still are cases in litigation, however
    • there have been 3,000 recognized Minamata disease patients (1,791 in Kumamoto, 493 in Kagoshima and 716 in Niigata), among which 304 patients are alive
    • There are 38,320 recipients under this program
    • the national and prefectural governments have been providing financial support since 1978 by issuing prefectural bonds, due to the concerns that the company might become unable to pay these costs any longer
  3. 3

    Associated Press (via NY1), 2023. Japan's court recognizes more victims of Minamata mercury poisoning and awards them compensation .

    The Osaka District Court ruling of 27 September 2023, with the plaintiffs' and the government's positions.

    • The Osaka District Court recognized all 128 plaintiffs as Minamata disease victims and ordered the government, Kumamoto and Chisso Corp., which is held responsible for the pollution, to pay 2.75 million yen
    • saying they were unfairly excluded from a 2009 compensation
    • The central government had argued that there was no evidence to prove the plaintiffs suffered from Minamata disease
  4. 4

    United Nations Environment Programme, 2017. Global mercury supply, trade and demand: Executive Summary .

    Supply, trade and demand of mercury in 2015: new mining in Mexico and Indonesia, two price levels, trade hubs, smuggling, demand in 2015 and the 2015 flow chart.

    • As mercury trade has been subjected to additional scrutiny, and the market price remains relatively high, undocumented or illegal transfers have increased
    • a German company illegally exported large quantities of mercury (improperly characterized as waste) from Germany to Switzerland. Customs agents in Indonesia and the Philippines have intercepted Indonesian mercury and cinnabar ore smuggled in shipping containers
    • Large quantities of mercury imported by Colombia and Bolivia are transferred informally to neighbouring countries such as Peru, primarily for use in artisanal and small-scale gold mining
    • Once such operations are established, however, and mining communities become accustomed to the economic benefits, it may be difficult to phase out these mining activities
    • Many countries are seeing a growing preference for alternatives to amalgam
    • improvements in dental health care in less prosperous countries, where cost-effective mercury-free alternatives to amalgam may be less available, have led to increases in the use of amalgam
  5. 5

    N.A. Robins and N.A. Hagan (Environmental Health Perspectives 120: 627-631), 2012. Mercury Production and Use in Colonial Andean Silver Production: Emissions and Health Implications .

    Mercury mining at Huancavelica, silver refining at Potosí, the mita labor draft and estimated mercury emissions 1564 to 1810.

    • Mining and refining operations in Huancavelica and Potosí depended on a draft labor system known as the mita to ensure sufficient workers
    • Men between 18 and 50 years of age from the areas surrounding Huancavelica and Potosí were subject to this levy and were required to work 2 months in Huancavelica and 12 months in Potosí
    • In 1604, an advocate for the natives, Damían de Jeria, described how the vapors, dust, and candle smoke in the mine led to a … cough and a certain illness . . . called the illness of Huancavelica
    • The mita system played a central role in the destruction of indigenous communities
  6. 6

    Arctic Monitoring and Assessment Programme (AMAP) and UN Environment Programme, 2019. Technical Background Report to the Global Mercury Assessment 2018 , Key findings of chapters 2 and 3; Table 3.3.

    World emissions of mercury to air in 2015 by sector, the share from human activity, and the rise of mercury in surface seawater.

    • over 15 million miners estimated to be directly involved in the sector and potentially 100 million people living in ASGM communities
  7. 7

    Ministry of the Environment, Japan, 2002. Minamata Disease: The History and Measures. Chapter 4, Measures .

    The end of acetaldehyde production in 1968, the dredging of Minamata Bay, fishing limits and compensation to 2001.

    • 2,955 persons have been certified as Minamata Disease patients in the Yatsushiro Sea area and the Agano River basin, and a total of approximately 144.1 billion yen has been paid as compensation from the responsible companies
  8. 8

    United Nations, 2013. Minamata Convention on Mercury (certified text) , Article 3; Annex A.

    Limits on mercury mining and the phase-out dates for mercury-added products.

    • Measures to be taken by a Party to phase down the use of dental
  9. 9

    United Nations Environment Programme, 2025. Minamata Convention COP-6 agrees to end the use of dental amalgam by 2034 .

    Decisions of the sixth Conference of the Parties, Geneva, 3 to 7 November 2025: dental amalgam phase-out by 2034, illegal trade.

    • COP-6 adopted new amendments to Annex A, establishing a global phase-out of dental amalgam by 2034
  10. 10

    World Health Organization, 2024. Mercury and health (fact sheet) .

    Forms of mercury, how people take it in, health effects, dental amalgam, skin lighteners and the 2023 amendment.

    • Mercury-containing skin lightening products are hazardous to health and have been banned in many countries
    • such products may be found being advertised and available to consumers via the Internet
    • Methylmercury is very different to ethylmercury. Ethylmercury is contained in thiomersal as a preservative in some vaccines and does not pose a health risk
  11. 11

    U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2025. HHS Adopts ACIP Recommendation to Remove Thimerosal from All U.S. Influenza Vaccines .

    Press release of 23 July 2025. Text read with Firecrawl (the site refuses scripts).

    • signing the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) recommendations to remove the mercury-based preservative thimerosal from all influenza vaccines distributed in the United States
    • to protect our most vulnerable populations from unnecessary mercury exposure