Magnesium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Trade is the main dispute. The US government and European industry say China dumped magnesium, and China defended its export limits at the WTO. Near plants and mines, the problem is pollution: a contaminated smelter site in Utah and alkaline dust near magnesite mines in Liaoning.

Last updated 5 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

Trade is the main dispute. In 1995 the United States put antidumping duties on pure magnesium from China, Russia and Ukraine1. In 2022 the US Department of Commerce found that ending the duties on China would likely lead to more dumping. It kept them1.

European Aluminium, an industry association, says Europe had to close its last magnesium plant in 2001 because of dumped Chinese imports2. It asked the European Commission to act against Chinese state support, which it said breaks WTO rules, and against dumping2. We found no reply from China to this claim.

China’s export limits went to the WTO. In 2009 the United States asked for consultations about Chinese export restraints on raw materials, among them magnesium3. The complainants said the restraints caused scarcity and higher prices abroad, and gave Chinese industry an advantage3. China said some duties and quotas served to conserve exhaustible natural resources3. The panel found that China had not limited its own production or use of the materials at the same time3. The Appellate Body report came out on 30 January 2012. China removed the duties and quotas from 1 January 20133.

In Russia, in May 2022, a court upheld a ruling that the 1992-93 privatization of the Solikamsk Magnesium Plant was not authorized. Four people lost shares that together were 89.5% of the company4.

Workers and communities

On 5 March 2022, a construction worker died in an accident during repairs to the Utah smelter4.

The Utah site is on the EPA’s National Priorities List5. The EPA says plant operations and waste disposal polluted soil, air, surface water and groundwater. It says the pollution threatens the workers’ health, and birds and wildlife5. In 2024 an EPA risk study found that dioxins are the main risk to birds and mammals at the site5. In 2023 the EPA said the company had exceeded its emission limits for chlorine5.

In China, dust from magnesite mines and kilns has damaged land around Haicheng, in Liaoning Province. One study says hardly any plants survive near the mining sites and the kiln plant6. Soils near the mine had a pH of 9.9 to 10.3, against 7.1 in clean farmland6. The authors say remediation there had not succeeded6.

Who gains and who loses

China’s smelters gained most of the world market. China’s share of production rose from 12% in 2000 to 87% in 2021, by an industry estimate2. Since 1998, two of the three US producers have closed, and the US share of world capacity fell from 30% to 3%4.

Buyers outside China carry the risk of supply cuts. In 2021, twelve European industry associations and a trade union said the shortage threatened thousands of businesses and millions of jobs7. When deliveries from the Utah smelter stopped, a US aluminum mill declared force majeure for two months in 20224.

USGS reports the aim of the 2021 cuts in China. The regulators wanted the industry to modernize its equipment, use less energy and cause less pollution8.

Public debate

Magnesium can make cars lighter, but primary metal from China comes with high greenhouse gas emissions (see the production chapter). Sulfur hexafluoride (SF₆) is a gas used to protect molten magnesium from oxidation4. Over 100 years, one kilogram of SF₆ traps as much heat as 24,300 kilograms of carbon dioxide. The IPCC gives this value in its Sixth Assessment Report of 20219. USGS gives 23,5004, the value from the IPCC’s Fifth Assessment Report10. In 1999, the US magnesium industry, its association and the EPA began a voluntary program to cut these emissions4.

The second debate is about dependence on one supplier. After the 2021 shortage, European industry asked the EU to restart magnesium production in Europe2. The EU now lists magnesium as a strategic raw material (see the power chapter).

Sources

  1. 1

    U.S. Department of Commerce, International Trade Administration (Federal Register vol. 87, no. 113), 2022. Pure Magnesium From the People's Republic of China: Final Results of the Expedited Fifth Sunset Review of the Antidumping Duty Order , Background, footnote 1; Final Results of Sunset Review.

    The 1995 antidumping order on pure magnesium and its renewal in 2022, with margins of up to 108.26%.

    • Notice of Antidumping Duty Order: Pure Magnesium from the People’s Republic of China, the Russian Federation and Ukraine
    • revocation of the antidumping duty (AD) order on pure magnesium from the People’s Republic of China (China) would be likely to lead to continuation or recurrence of dumping
  2. 2

    European Aluminium, the association of the aluminium industry in Europe, 2021. Call on EU policymakers to address imminent supply shortage of Chinese magnesium (position paper, 27 September 2021) .

    China's share of world production, Europe's dependence, the closure of the last European plant, and world end-use shares.

    • In 2001, Europe was forced to close its remaining magnesium production as a consequence of dumped Chinese imports
    • the European Commission must act fiercely against China’s WTOincompliant state support and dumping
    • Between 2000 and 2021, China’s magnesium production increased from 12% of the global supply to 87%
    • a restart of raw materials production in Europe, including magnesium
  3. 3

    World Trade Organization, 2013. DS394: China – Measures Related to the Exportation of Various Raw Materials , Summary of the dispute; Panel and Appellate Body proceedings; Implementation.

    The dispute over China's export duties and quotas on raw materials including magnesium, 2009 to 2013.

    • On 23 June 2009, the United States requested consultations with China with respect to China’s restraints on the export from China of various forms of raw materials
    • The complainants argued that the use of export restraints creates scarcity and causes higher prices of the raw materials in global markets. They also provide Chinese domestic industry with a significant advantage
    • China had argued in its defence that some of its export duties and quotas were justified because they related to the conservation of exhaustible natural resources
    • But China was not able to demonstrate that it imposed these restrictions in conjunction with restrictions on domestic production or consumption
    • On 30 January 2012, the Appellate Body report was circulated to Members … Both notices had taken effect on 1 January 2013
  4. 4

    U.S. Geological Survey (E.L. Bray), 2025. Magnesium, in 2022 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , pp. 45.1 to 45.4, introduction, Government Actions, Production, Consumption, Prices, World Review, Outlook.

    Uses and properties, US Magnesium's production failure, contracts and prices, sulfur hexafluoride, Russia tariffs, Solikamsk, China outlook.

    • The ruling stripped four individuals of their share of ownership of the company, which combined was 89.5% of the total shares of SMZ
    • On March 5, 2022, a construction worker died in an accident while working on repairs to the smelter
    • Since 1998, the U.S. share of the world’s primary magnesium capacity has decreased to 3% from 30%. During that time period, two of the three domestic producers closed
    • On July 7, 2022, Kaiser Aluminum Corp. declared force majeure at its Warrick rolling mill in Indiana … until September 7, 2022
    • a cover gas used to protect molten magnesium from oxidation
    • 23,500 times the global warming potential of carbon dioxide (CO2)
    • In 1999, the U.S. magnesium industry, the International Magnesium Association, and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) began a voluntary SF6 emissions reduction partnership
  5. 5

    U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2026. US Magnesium, Tooele County, UT: Cleanup Activities , Site Background; What Has Been Done to Clean Up the Site?.

    The Rowley plant from 1972, its contamination and its listing as a Superfund site in 2009.

    • The National Priorities List is a list of some of the nation … most contaminated sites
    • Facility operations and waste disposal practices contaminated soil, air, surface water and groundwater with hazardous chemicals. In addition to threatening the health of US Magnesium workers, the contamination poses a threat to birds and wildlife
    • dioxins (TCDD TEQ) are the main risk to birds and mammals at the site
    • exceedances of emissions limits for chlorine
  6. 6

    Yang D., Zeng D.-H., Zhang J., Li L.-J., Mao R. (Land Degradation & Development 23: 256-262), 2012. Chemical and microbial properties in contaminated soils around a magnesite mine in northeast China , Introduction; Abstract.

    Dust from magnesite mines and kilns near Haicheng, Liaoning, and its effect on soils and crops.

    • Hardly any vegetation can survive near the mining sites and the calcination factory there
    • pH were significantly higher in contaminated soils … respectively) than in uncontaminated soils
    • Remediation measures have not been successful
  7. 7

    European Aluminium, Eurofer, ACEA, Eurometaux, industriAll Europe, IMA and others (joint statement), 2021. Cross-industry group of European metals-producing and -using industries and their workers warn against catastrophic impact of Chinese magnesium supply shortage .

    The joint warning of October 2021 and the prices paid for remaining imports.

    • this issue, if not resolved, threatens thousands of businesses across Europe, their entire supply chains and the millions of jobs that rely on them
  8. 8

    U.S. Geological Survey (E.L. Bray), 2024. Magnesium, in 2021 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , pp. 45.1 to 45.3, introduction, Prices, World Review (China).

    The 2021 production cuts in China and their effect on prices; China's share of capacity and output.

    • These regulatory actions were intended to encourage the industry to modernize equipment to decrease energy consumption and pollution
  9. 9

    Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (C. Smith, Z.R.J. Nicholls and others), 2021. The Earth's Energy Budget, Climate Feedbacks, and Climate Sensitivity: Supplementary Material, in Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis (IPCC Sixth Assessment Report, Working Group I, Chapter 7) , Table 7.SM.7, row 'Sulphur hexafluoride', column GWP-100 (PDF p. 21).

    Global warming potential of SF6 over 100 years (GWP-100), 24,300, with a lifetime of 1,000 years.

    • Sulphur hexafluoride SF6 1000 0.567 442 18200 2180 24300
  10. 10

    Greenhouse Gas Protocol, 2024. IPCC Global Warming Potential Values, Version 2.0 , Table, row 'Sulfur hexafluoride'.

    GWP-100 of SF6 in the IPCC's Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Assessment Reports: 22,800, 23,500 and 24,300.

    • Sulfur hexafluoride SF6 22,800 23,500 24,300