Lithium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

New lithium mines have met strong opposition. Serbia stopped the Jadar project after protests in 2022. A court reversed that in 2024, and Rio Tinto later put the project on hold. Tribes sued over Thacker Pass in Nevada. Families in Zimbabwe say mines took their land and water.

Last updated 5 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

In Serbia, Rio Tinto planned the Jadar project, a $2.4 billion lithium mine. In January 2022, after large protests by environmental groups, the government revoked its licenses1. Environmental groups collected 30,000 signatures for a law to stop lithium exploration in Serbia. They warned that the mine would add to pollution1.

In July 2024 Serbia’s Constitutional Court ruled that the 2022 revocation was unconstitutional1. Rio Tinto welcomed the ruling1. The project would make 58,000 tonnes of lithium carbonate a year, the largest lithium mine in Europe, according to the report1. By October 2026, Rio Tinto said on its project page that it was moving Jadar into care and maintenance. It gave its focus on capital discipline and on near-term projects as the reason2.

In Nevada, the Thacker Pass mine is planned next to what the US Department of Energy calls the largest confirmed lithium resource in North America3. The Reno-Sparks Indian Colony calls the place Peehee Mu’huh. It says the site is sacred and that its ancestors are buried there4. In 2021 the tribe sued the federal government, and the Burns Paiute Tribe joined the case. The tribes say the Bureau of Land Management did not consult them properly before it permitted the mine4. A local rancher and four environmental groups also sued4. The lawsuits did not stop the mine. Construction started in early March 2023. Lithium Americas announced the start after a federal appeals court denied the opponents’ request to block the work5. In July 2023 the same court rejected the opponents’ appeal against the approval. AP reported that construction was already under way6.

The Department of Energy expects about 1,800 construction jobs and 360 jobs in operation. It also says the lithium could supply batteries for up to 800,000 electric vehicles a year3.

Workers and communities

In Buhera, Zimbabwe, 41 families were moved off their land for the Sabi Star lithium mine, owned by a Chinese company. A social scientist studied their case and reported it in The Conversation7. The families said that the company and government officials coerced them into moving, with promises of new houses and jobs7. They said the new houses were smaller than promised and cracked after four months. They also said the company took over the Mukwasi dam, which they used for crops and animals7. The Business and Human Rights Resource Centre names the company as Max Mind Investments, a subsidiary of China’s Chengxin Lithium8. A company spokesperson told the news site The NewsHawks that the relocation was open and that the families understood its effects8.

At Bikita, another Zimbabwean mine, residents accuse the operator of cutting off their water. A news report collected by the Business and Human Rights Resource Centre says that over 300 villagers lost their clean water supply9. Bikita Minerals replied to the Centre and said that the news report left out facts. It referred to an investigation by the Zimbabwe Human Rights Commission910. In the findings that the company listed, Bikita Minerals had judged the well unsafe for drinking and closed it. It had also drilled a borehole at a nearby school as another water source for the villagers10.

In Chile, the Salar de Atacama is part of the ancestral land of the Atacameño, or Lickanantay, people11. Water there is scarce. Chile’s permits let SQM pump 1,600 liters of brine and 240 liters of fresh water a second. They let Albemarle pump 442 liters of brine and 23.5 liters of fresh water a second11. The authors note these are approved amounts, not measured ones11. Codelco says its partnership with SQM will raise output without pumping more brine or fresh water12.

Who gains and who loses

Producers gained from the price rise of 2022. SQM’s sales went from $936 million in 2021 to $8,153 million in 202213. Chile’s government will take a larger share in the future. According to Codelco, its agreement with SQM gives the state about 70% of the operating margin from 2025 to 2030 and 85% from 203112.

The Zimbabwean government promotes mining for development, and Zimbabwe is Africa’s largest lithium producer. The researcher who studied Buhera says the displaced families lost access to water, grazing land and fruit trees7. The families said they got $1,000 as a first payment, not the $3,000 they had asked for7.

Public debate

Countries argue about who should control lithium. Mexico’s president said in 2022 that the country would develop or buy the technology, “but the lithium is ours”14. Opposition parties and mining companies questioned whether the government had the expertise and the money to build a lithium industry15.

In Chile, there is a legal debate about brine. Officials of Chile’s water agency (DGA) told the researchers that water use falls under water rights, while brine extraction falls under environmental assessment11. The researchers call the treatment of brine as a mining resource a legal loophole. Some indigenous groups and academics say brine is a type of water11.

Sources

  1. 1

    Business and Human Rights Resource Centre (excerpt of a mining.com article of 11 July 2024), 2024. Serbia: Decision to revoke Rio Tinto's licence for Jadar lithium mine project ruled unconstitutional .

    The 2022 revocation, the 2024 court ruling, the project size and the positions of activists and the company.

    • Belgrade revoked licences for the Australian miner’s $2.4 billion lithium project in western Serbia in January 2022 after massive protests by environmental groups over the proposed mine
    • Serbian environmentalists collected 30,000 signatures in a petition demanding that parliament enact legislation to halt lithium exploration in the country
    • Green activists have repeatedly warned that the mining projects will cause more pollution in Serbia
    • The Serbian Constitutional Court said in a ruling on Thursday that the government’s decision in 2022 to revoke Rio Tinto’s spatial plan permit for the Jadar lithium mine project was unconstitutional
    • Rio Tinto welcomes the decision of the Constitutional Court in Serbia
    • Europe’s biggest lithium mine, with a production of 58,000 tonnes of refined battery-grade lithium carbonate per year
  2. 2

    Rio Tinto, 2026. Jadar (project page) .

    Rio Tinto's own statement that it is moving the Jadar project into care and maintenance. The page gives no date for the decision.

    • We are transitioning the Jadar Project into care and maintenance. This decision reflects our global focus on capital discipline and prioritising near-term opportunities
  3. 3

    U.S. Department of Energy, Loan Programs Office, 2024. Thacker Pass .

    The $2.26 billion loan of October 2024 and the planned output of the project.

    • The project is located next to a mine site that contains the largest confirmed lithium resource in North America
    • The project is expected to create approximately 1,800 jobs during construction and 360 jobs in operations
    • could support the production of batteries for up to 800,000 electric vehicles (EVs) annually
  4. 4

    Reno-Sparks Indian Colony, 2023. Why is Thacker Pass (Peehee Mu'huh) so important? .

    The tribe's reasons for opposing the mine and its 2021 lawsuit.

    • Thacker Pass, known as Peehee Mu … in our Paiute language, is a culturally, spiritually, and historically important place
    • Our ancestors are buried in Thacker Pass
    • alleges that the Federal Government and Bureau of Land Management failed to properly consult with tribes before permitting the mine
    • We have been joined in our lawsuit by the Burns Paiute Tribe
    • Additional lawsuits have been filed by Ed Bartell, a local Orovada rancher
    • by four environmental organizations
  5. 5

    Gabriela Aoun Angueira, Grist, 2023. Construction begins on controversial lithium mine in Nevada .

    Start of construction at Thacker Pass in the week of 3 March 2023, after the Ninth Circuit denied the opponents' request.

    • Construction began this week on an open-pit mine at the largest lithium deposit in the United States
    • Lithium Americas Corp. announced that it began construction on the Thacker Pass lithium project in Humboldt County, Nevada, after the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals denied a request
  6. 6

    Scott Sonner, Associated Press, 2023. 9th Circuit denies bid by environmentalists and tribes to block Nevada lithium mine .

    The appeals court ruling of 17 July 2023 on Thacker Pass. Read in a browser.

    • The latest bid by conservationists and tribal leaders to block construction of a huge lithium mine already in the works along the Nevada-Oregon line was denied by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday
  7. 7

    The Conversation (article by a social scientist who studied the Buhera displacement), 2024. Lithium mining in Zimbabwe: a story of loss for one community .

    The resettlement of 41 families for the Sabi Star lithium mine in Buhera, Zimbabwe, as told by the families.

    • My latest research traces how 41 families in Buhera were displaced from their homes to make way for Zimbabwe’s third largest lithium mine, owned by China’s Sabi Star mining company
    • this community said that the mining company, allied with government technocrats, manipulated and coerced them into accepting forced resettlements by promising new houses and jobs on the mine
    • received smaller homes that developed cracks four months after they moved in
    • the Mukwasi dam which they had depended on for irrigation and livestock drinking water was taken over by the mining company
    • Zimbabwe is the largest producer of lithium in Africa
    • The Zimbabwean government promotes mining to stimulate socio-economic development
    • community members lost access to natural resources such as water, grazing land and fruit trees
    • We had said we wanted (an initial payment of) US$3,000 (and not US$1,000 that we were given)
  8. 8

    Business and Human Rights Resource Centre (excerpt of The NewsHawks, via Daily Maverick, May 2024), 2024. Zimbabwe: Families displaced say compensation agreements remain unfulfilled as global giant continues to exploit lithium; incl. company comments .

    Reply of the Max Mind Investments spokesperson on the Buhera relocation for the Sabi Star mine.

    • Allegations against Max Mind investments (subsidiary of Chinese Chengxin Lithium)
    • Max Minds spokesperson Emmerson Njanjamangezi told The NewsHawks that the relocation exercise was done in a transparent manner and evicted families were fully aware of the implications
  9. 9

    Business and Human Rights Resource Centre (summary of a NewsHub Zimbabwe report of 10 September 2024), 2024. Zimbabwe: Lithium curse: Bikita Minerals isolates villagers from water source .

    Residents' allegations against Bikita Minerals (Sinomine Resource Group) about water and displacement.

    • Residents have accused Bikita Minerals of causing a severe water and livelihood crisis following the construction of a slime dam
    • leaving over 300 villagers without clean water and forcing them to travel over 4 km for access
    • Bikita Minerals responded
  10. 10

    Bikita Minerals (published by the Business and Human Rights Resource Centre, 10 March 2025), 2025. Response from Bikita Minerals .

    The company's reply on the closed well and the borehole at Beardmore Primary School. It cites a Zimbabwe Human Rights Commission investigation that we did not read.

    • The article erroneously omitted facts
    • the Zimbabwe Human Rights Commission was compelled to investigate
    • the water source (well) was regarded as unsafe for human consumption by Bikita Minerals and had to be closed
    • Bikita Minerals installed a borehole at Beardmore Primary School in Murape village as an alternative water source for the villagers
  11. 11

    C. Flores Fernández and R. Alba (Frontiers in Water), 2023. Water or mineral resource? Legal interpretations and hydrosocial configurations of lithium mining in Chile , Table 1; section 3.

    Approved brine and freshwater extraction at the Salar de Atacama, and the Atacameño communities there.

    • Many salt flats are part of the ancestral territories of indigenous communities, such as the Atacameño/Lickanantay in the Salar de Atacama
    • SQM CORFO Salar de Atacama 1.600 l/s 240 l/s
    • Albemarle CORFO Salar de Atacama 442 l/s 23,5 l/s
    • Approved figures, not necessarily total amount extracted
    • what is water extraction is under the tutelage of the DGA through water use rights and what is brine extraction is regulated through the environmental impact assessment system
    • We show that the interpretation of brines as mining resources supported by mining companies and endorsed by environmental State agencies is based on a legal loophole
    • an interpretation of brines as a type of water. The latter is in line with the position of some indigenous groups and academics
  12. 12

    Codelco, 2024. Questions and answers: Codelco-SQM partnership agreement .

    Terms of the joint venture in the Salar de Atacama, 2025 to 2060, and the state's share of the margin.

    • does not entail increased brine extraction or use of continental waters
    • The Chilean state will receive approximately 70% of the operating margin that the new production generates between 2025 and 2030. Starting in 2031, the state will receive 85%
  13. 13

    B.W. Jaskula, U.S. Geological Survey, 2025. Lithium, in 2022 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , pp. 44.1-44.4.

    World production and consumption in 2022, producers by country, prices, uses and company results.

    • SQM’s value of sales increased nearly ninefold to $8,153 million in 2022 from $936 million in 2021
  14. 14

    AFP (France 24), 2022. Mexican lawmakers pass lithium nationalization plan .

    The April 2022 vote in Mexico's Congress and the president's reason.

    • We’re going to develop the technology (to exploit the deposits) or acquire it, but the lithium is ours
  15. 15

    D. Trevedan and H. González, Norton Rose Fulbright, 2022. Mexico moves to nationalize lithium mining .

    What the Mexican lithium reform does, and the critics' objections.

    • questioned whether the Mexican government has the expertise, funds and capabilities to develop a lithium value chain