Indium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
The main indium dispute was over the Fanya exchange in China. It collapsed in 2015. Victims say that about 220,000 investors lost about 43 billion yuan. In 2019 a court sent its founder to prison for 18 years. Workers who handle indium dust can get a serious lung disease.
Last updated 13 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
The Fanya Metal Exchange in Kunming, China, drew private investors into indium from 2011. In 2015 investors protested. Some said that they could not withdraw their money1. Investors met China’s securities regulator and provincial authorities to dispute Fanya’s actions1.
The Kunming government took over Fanya in November 2015 and opened a criminal investigation in December1. The owner was arrested in February 2016. In 2018 the chairman and 21 other executives were charged with embezzlement and with breaking financial laws2.
In March 2019 a court in Kunming fined Fanya 1 billion yuan for illegal fundraising. It sent the founder and chairman to prison for 18 years3. Victims told the magazine Caixin that about 220,000 investors lost about 43 billion yuan, or $6.2 billion3.
Kunming Rongke New Materials, owned by Vital Materials, was the only bidder when the indium stock was sold in January 20204. The sources we read do not say how much investors got back.
Workers and communities
Workers who breathe indium dust can get lung disease. The authors of a 2012 study called it a new disease, caused by work with indium compounds such as ITO5. The impact chapter gives the number of cases.
Indium output also depends on the zinc smelters that recover it. The Auby smelter in France stopped in December 2022 because of market conditions, and reopened in March 20236. Some smelters in Sichuan and Yunnan, China, cut output in 2022 because of power shortages7.
Who gains and who loses
Bolivia has large indium deposits. It has exported zinc ores to Europe, where the indium is recovered6. In 2023 Bolivia’s Minister of Mining said the country was finalizing a $350 million loan from China’s Export-Import Bank. The loan is for a zinc refinery in Oruro that could also process indium6.
Japan and Korea recover the most indium from ITO scrap8.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Geological Survey, 2015. Indium, in 2015 Minerals Yearbook .
The rise and collapse of the Fanya exchange, purchases by China's State Reserve Bureau, China's export quota, ITO recycling.
-
investors began to protest the exchange’s actions with some investors claiming they had not been able to retrieve their funds since April
-
investors reportedly met with the China Securities Regulatory Commission (China’s stock market regulator) and Provincial-level authorities to dispute Fanya’s actions
-
By November, the Kunming government took over Fanya.
-
In December, the Kunming municipal government announced that it had launched a criminal investigation into Fanya
-
- 2
U.S. Geological Survey, 2019. Indium, in 2019 Minerals Yearbook .
The arrest of the Fanya owner and the trial of its executives.
-
on February 5, 2016, the owner of the Fanya Metal Exchange was arrested on suspicion of unlawfully raising funds from the public
-
The chairman and 21 other Fanya Metal Exchange executives were charged with embezzlement and violating financial management laws and regulations.
-
- 3
Caixin Global (Hu Yue and Tang Ziyi), 2020. Fanya Metal Exchange scandal nets small fry who raised funds from investors .
Investor losses at Fanya as victims give them, and the court sentence of 2019.
-
the Kunming Intermediate People’s Court fined (link in Chinese) Fanya 1 billion yuan for illegal fundraising
-
Shan, the exchange’s founder, chairman and general manager, was sent to prison for 18 years.
-
leaving about 220,000 investors facing combined losses of about 43 billion yuan, according to victims of the scheme
-
220,000 investors nursing losses of 43 billion yuan ($6.2 billion)
-
- 4
U.S. Geological Survey, 2020. Indium, in 2020 Minerals Yearbook .
The sale of the Fanya indium stock in 2020.
-
Kuning Rongke New Materials was the only participant in the auction
-
- 5
K.J. Cummings and others, Chest, 2012. Indium lung disease .
Cases of lung disease in workers who made or used indium compounds.
-
occupational exposure to indium compounds including indium oxide and ITO causes a novel, potentially fatal lung disease
-
- 6
U.S. Geological Survey (Andrew A. Stewart), 2024. Indium, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2024 .
No reserve estimates, the West Desert deposit, Bolivia, the Auby smelter.
-
An indium-producing zinc smelter in Auby, France, was placed on care-and-maintenance status in December 2022 owing to unfavorable market conditions.
-
The facility was reopened in March 2023, but with variable production.
-
Bolivia has large indium deposits and has been exporting zinc ores to Europe for indium recovery.
-
In Bolivia, the Minister of Mining and Metallurgy announced that it was finalizing a $350 million loan
-
Bank of China to aid in the construction of a zinc refinery, also capable of processing indium
-
The refinery would be built in the city of Oruro.
-
- 7
U.S. Geological Survey (Amy C. Tolcin), 2023. Indium, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2023 .
Auby output in 2018, China's exports in 2022, power cuts at Chinese zinc smelters.
-
Some zinc smelters in Sichuan and Yunnan Provinces temporarily cut production during the year in response to power supply issues
-
- 8
U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Indium, pp. 99-100.
World refinery production and capacity by country, US imports and prices, export restrictions in China, resources and substitutes.
-
Indium is most commonly recovered from ITO scrap in Japan and the Republic of Korea.
-