Germanium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Germanium is part of the trade dispute about chips and minerals between China and the United States. Since 2023 buyers outside China have paid much higher prices. We found few reports about workers or towns that germanium affects directly.
Last updated 10 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Germanium is part of a trade dispute between China and the United States and its allies. China put export controls on germanium in August 2023. China’s Ministry of Commerce said that the controls would protect national security and interests1. China banned exports to the United States in December 2024 and suspended the ban in November 2025 (see the power chapter).
The effect on shipments was large. In August and September 2023, China exported almost no germanium metal. It sent none to the United States from August to December 20231.
The Fastmarkets price service reported a debate about the effect of the ban of December 2024. Fastmarkets wrote that China had made no direct exports of the controlled materials to the United States since August 20232. The USGS still listed China among the main sources of US imports for January to August 20243.
The UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre expected the controls to hurt gallium supply more than germanium supply. More germanium is produced outside China4.
Workers and communities
We found few reports of effects on workers or towns that come from germanium itself. Germanium comes from zinc mines and coal mines, so their effects belong mostly to zinc and coal.
Mine jobs depend on zinc. In November 2023, Nyrstar stopped production at its Middle Tennessee zinc mines, which also produced germanium. The company gave lower zinc prices and higher costs as reasons1. The mines were still closed in 20255.
In 2019, several producers in China stopped production for a time, for maintenance or because of low prices. A large producer in Yunnan reportedly shut a production line of 10,000 kg a year in June, for an expected six months. In the first half of 2019 it received government subsidies of 3.6 million yuan6.
Workers who make chips can meet germane, a toxic germanium gas (see the impact chapter).
Who gains and who loses
Buyers outside China pay more than buyers inside China. In 2026, the IEA gives European prices of about three times Chinese domestic prices (see the market chapter)7. Before the controls, the metal cost about $1,350 to $1,400 per kg. By October 2024 it cost about $3,000, the UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre says4.
Companies in Belgium, Congo (Kinshasa), South Korea and the United States have plans or projects (see the production and power chapters). The IEA says that new supply from outside China can often come without new mines, because germanium is recovered when other metals are processed7.
In 2025, US imports of germanium metal fell by 67% (see the power chapter). Imports of germanium dioxide rose by 55%. The USGS says buyers probably bought ahead of possible new tariffs on goods from Canada5.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Geological Survey (Amy C. Tolcin), 2026. Germanium, in 2023 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) .
US mines and plants, the refining route, uses, import unit values and prices in 2023, world output range, producers in Belgium, Canada, China and Russia, China's export controls and exports, outlook.
-
On July 4, China’s Ministry of Commerce announced that it would implement export controls on gallium and germanium beginning on August 1 to … safeguard national security and interests
-
there were virtually no exports of germanium metal in August (0 kg) and September (1 kg)
-
There were no exports of germanium metal to the United States between August and December following the export controls
-
In late November, Nyrstar suspended production at the Middle Tennessee mines owing to market conditions, which included decreasing zinc prices and increasing operating costs owing to inflation
-
- 2
Fastmarkets (Solomon Cefai), 2025. China suspends export prohibition on gallium, germanium, antimony, superhard materials to US .
The suspension of China's ban runs until 27 November 2026; the ban on dual-use exports to US military users was not addressed.
-
The impact of the original ban was debated at the time, given that no direct exports of the controlled materials from China to US had been made since the first export controls on gallium and germanium
-
- 3
U.S. Geological Survey (Amy C. Tolcin), 2025. Germanium, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2025 .
US funding for the St. George wafer plant, the Lubumbashi tailings agreement, China's exports and producers, prices in 2024.
-
More than 94% of total imports of metal and dioxide (germanium content) for the year through August were from Belgium, Germany, Canada, and China
-
- 4
UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre, British Geological Survey, 2024. UK 2024 Criticality Assessment , Section 4.5.2, Table 10 and section 3.
The UK assessment, China's share of refined germanium, export licenses of 2023 and prices.
-
However, the effect is expected to be more pronounced for Ga due to its limited production outside China compared to Ge
-
Ge metal prices have risen from about $1350 to $1400/kg before the announcement to about $3000/kg in October 2024
-
- 5
U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Germanium, pp. 88-89.
US imports, exports and prices 2021 to 2025, uses, China's export ban and exports, European prices in 2025, DOE funding, producing countries, resources and substitutes.
-
Operations at a mine in Tennessee that also produced germanium-containing zinc concentrates have been suspended since November 2023
-
Imports of germanium dioxide increased by 55% from those in 2024 to an estimated 17,000 kilograms, likely owing to increased purchasing before potential tariff changes on imported goods from Canada
-
- 6
U.S. Geological Survey (Amy C. Tolcin), 2020. Germanium, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2020 .
World production 2018 and 2019, the Teck force majeure, the Fanya auction, fiber optics share, Chinese production cuts.
-
several germanium producers temporarily stopped production during the year either for maintenance or in response to low germanium prices
-
a leading germanium producer in Yunnan Province reportedly shut down a 10,000-kilogram-per-year germanium metal production line in June
-
The shutdown was expected to last 6 months
-
This company received nine Government subsidies totaling 3.6 million yuan between January 1, 2019, and June 27, 2019
-
- 7
International Energy Agency, 2026. Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026 .
Price gap between Europe and China, supply risk ranking, Korea Zinc, the Congo reserve, uses in chips and defense.
-
around three times higher for germanium
-
In many instances, this can be achieved without developing new mines
-
A large share of these minerals are produced as co-products
-