Flerovium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

The disputes were about the evidence. The joint working party of IUPAC and IUPAP did not accept the early reports. In 2011 it credited the later Dubna-Livermore work of 20046.

Flerovium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →

Last updated 15 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

The first claim came from one decay chain, which a Dubna and Livermore team recorded in November and December 19981. The team assigned it to flerovium-2891. Later experiments did not confirm this assignment2.

In 2016 Sigurd Hofmann and colleagues proposed a new reading of the 1998 chain. It could be flerovium-290, or element 11334. In 2020 Hofmann and co-authors wrote that the chain could not be accepted as a discovery of either element4.

The joint working party (JWP) of IUPAC and IUPAP first judged the Dubna claims in 2003. The JWP found that a discovery was not yet proven5. In 2011 the JWP judged them again. For a 1999 experiment with plutonium-242, it counted one event and found it to be inadequate evidence6. In 1999 the CERN Courier had reported two events from that experiment1. The JWP credited the Dubna-Livermore work of 2004, because the decay chains pass through copernicium-283, a known nucleus6.

A Berkeley paper of 1999 by V. Ninov and others claimed element 118. Its three decay chains passed through flerovium-2855. The authors retracted the report in 20027. The Berkeley case is on the superheavy elements page.

Workers and communities

Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with flerovium, a few atoms at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from flerovium.

Who gains and who loses

We found no source on income from flerovium. The name honors the Flerov Laboratory of Nuclear Reactions at JINR8. The partner laboratory, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, gave its name to element 116, livermorium8.

Public debate

The first claim reached the press in January 19999. Albert Ghiorso of Berkeley told Physics World that it put researchers only on the shore of the island of stability10. Ken Moody, leader of the US team, said that he was not yet fully convinced. He named random events as a possible cause10.

Berkeley Lab confirmed element 114 in 2009. Ken Gregorich said that it was unusual for such a result to go unconfirmed for so long11. Heino Nitsche said that the confirmation removed any doubts about the Dubna claims11.

Sources

  1. 1

    CERN Courier, 1999. First postcard from the island of nuclear stability , 30 August 1999.

    The 34-day experiment of November and December 1998, the one decay chain, and the plutonium-242 experiment of March and April 1999.

    • The experiment was performed in Dubna’s Flerov Laboratory of Nuclear Reactions in November and December of 1998 in collaboration with the US Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory.
    • a parent nucleus with atomic number 114 and mass 289
    • Two similar events were recorded as a short decay chain.
  2. 2

    M. Thoennessen, National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory, Michigan State University (preprint for Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables), 2012. Discovery of Isotopes of Elements with Z ≥ 100 , arXiv:1203.2105v1, section 16, Discovery of 285-289 114; section 10, 277Hs.

    The isotopes 285 to 289 with year, team and reaction, the JWP verdict of 2011, the earlier reports that could not be confirmed, and the GSI production of 289 at TASCA in 2010.

    • Earlier reports of 287 114 [175] and 289 114 [161, 175] could not be confirmed.
  3. 3

    FRIB Nuclear Data Group, Discovery of Nuclides Project, 2023. 290Fl, in the Discovery of Nuclides Project isotope database .

    Flerovium-290 is not discovered; the proposals of 2016 and 2023 to assign old chains to it.

    • In 2016, Hofmann et al. (2016Ho09) proposed to reassign a decay chain
  4. 4

    Sigurd Hofmann, Sergey N. Dmitriev, Claes Fahlander, Jacklyn M. Gates, James B. Roberto and Hideyuki Sakai; Pure and Applied Chemistry 92(9), 2020. On the discovery of new elements (IUPAC/IUPAP Report) , Section 6, on anchor nuclei; section 5, on the first decay chain of 1998.

    Flerovium-287 and its anchor daughter copernicium-283, and the later reading of the 1998 chain as flerovium-290 or element 113.

    • one can now make a tentative assignment of that first measured chain of a nucleus of a spherical superheavy element to an electron capture decay branch of 290Fl or the production of 290Nh in a pn evaporation channel
    • With good reason this result could not be accepted as discovery whether of element 114 nor of element 113.
  5. 5

    P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, B. W. Petley and E. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 75(10), 1601-1611, 2003. On the claims for discovery of elements 110, 111, 112, 114, 116, and 118 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Sections 114;01 to 114;04.

    The first JWP judgement of the Dubna claims for element 114, and the Berkeley element 118 report that passed through flerovium-285.

    • whose acknowledgement as discoveries is unfortunately not yet warranted
    • 86Kr +208Pb leading to observation of three chains terminating in 269Sg that pass through observed interme-diate 285114
  6. 6

    R. C. Barber, P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, E. Vardaci and E. W. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 83(7), 1485-1498, 2011. Discovery of the elements with atomic numbers greater than or equal to 113 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Sections 114;01 to 114;07 and the summary of JWP conclusions.

    The working party's assessment of each Dubna report on element 114 and its credit to the Dubna-Livermore collaboration.

    • The one event and inconclusive identification of the now-known nuclide
    • is not adequate evidence for the discovery of
    • the establishment of the identity of the isotope 283Cn by a large number of decaying chains
    • Livermore collaboration be credited with discovery of this new element
  7. 7

    FRIB Nuclear Data Group, Discovery of Nuclides Project (on Ellison and others, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 182701, 2010), 2013. 285Fl, in the Discovery of Nuclides Project isotope database .

    The discovery of flerovium-285 at Berkeley in 2010, and the retraction of the 1999 report.

    • A previously reported observation of 285 Fl (1999Ni03) was later retracted (2002Ni10).
  8. 8

    Robert D. Loss and John Corish, IUPAC Inorganic Chemistry Division; Pure and Applied Chemistry 84(7), 1669-1672, 2012. Names and symbols of the elements with atomic numbers 114 and 116 (IUPAC Recommendations 2012) , Abstract, Introduction and Recommendation, pp. 1669-1670.

    The names flerovium and livermorium, the dates of the JWP report and of adoption, and the life of Georgiy Flerov. The publisher refuses scripts; the text was read with Firecrawl.

    • will honour the Flerov Laboratory of NuclearReactions where superheavy elements are synthesised
    • honours the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
  9. 9

    Physics Today (American Institute of Physics), 1999. Is the island of stability in sight? , 1 April 1999, first paragraph (the rest is a PDF for subscribers).

    The claim made in January 1999.

    • claimed in January that they had produced element 114
  10. 10

    Physics World (Institute of Physics), 1999. First hint of element 114 seen in Dubna , 29 January 1999.

    The first claim, the 30-second lifetime, and the statements of Ghiorso and Moody.

    • The creation of this element puts us only on the shore of the island
    • Ken Moody, leader of the US team, is still not 100% convinced by the result
    • You have to consider the possibility of random events correlating to give you something that looks like a real event
  11. 11

    Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (press release), 2009. Superheavy Element 114 Confirmed: A Stepping Stone to the Island of Stability , 24 September 2009.

    The Berkeley confirmation of element 114, two nuclei in eight days, the expected six, and the statements of Nitsche and Gregorich.

    • But it’s unusual for important results like the Dubna group’s claim to have produced 114 to go unconfirmed for so long.
    • By verifying the production of element 114, we have removed any doubts about the validity of the Dubna group’s claims