Darmstadtium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Three laboratories claimed element 110, and an international working party gave the credit to GSI in 2001. One of the four GSI decay chains of 1994 was later retracted, but the credit stayed910.

Darmstadtium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →

Last updated 15 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

Three laboratories claimed element 110: Dubna, GSI and Berkeley. In 2001 the IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party gave the credit to GSI alone1.

The working party gave a reason for each claim that it did not accept:

  • Dubna, 1987: preliminary work, not enough to show element 1101.
  • Berkeley, 1995: one sequence of events. The team had to postulate unproven steps, and an electronic failure disabled a detector for a fraction of a millisecond1.
  • Dubna, 1996: one chain from plutonium-244 and sulfur-34, in which only three of the alpha particles were observed1.

The working party added that it did not mean to invalidate any of these results. It called the Berkeley work “consistent with possible discovery”1. In 2003 Sigurd Hofmann told IUPAC that the eight years before the name were not due to major objections from other laboratories. Some points about the Dubna and Berkeley work needed clarification2.

IUPAC wrote in 2003 that “revelations” at Berkeley and GSI of some apparently fabricated or partly changed decay chains made a reassessment necessary. The history chapter describes the GSI chain of 1994 that could not be reconstructed from the original data. After that reassessment, the working party confirmed the GSI discovery again3.

Workers and communities

Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with darmstadtium, one atom at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from darmstadtium.

Who gains and who loses

We found no source on income from darmstadtium. GSI lists darmstadtium among the six elements that it discovered and that IUPAC recognized4.

The science and congress center in Darmstadt is named after the element. The center opened on 6 December 20075. The operator writes that Darmstadt is the only German city after which an element is named5. In 2019 GSI and the congress center marked 25 years since the discovery with a display in the foyer6.

Public debate

We found no public debate about darmstadtium itself. The writer Brian Clegg said on a podcast of the Royal Society of Chemistry that the name “wixhausium” was briefly considered. Wixhausen is the part of Darmstadt where GSI is located7. Los Alamos writes that the team also joked about the name “policium”8. In Germany, 110 is the emergency telephone number8.

Sources

  1. 1

    P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, B. W. Petley and E. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 73(6), 959-967, 2001. On the discovery of the elements 110-112 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Element Z=110, items 110;01 to 110;07, and the summary of conclusions, pp. 960-964.

    The working party's assessment of the claims from Dubna (1987), GSI (1995), Berkeley (1995) and Dubna (1996), and its verdict for GSI. Read with Firecrawl; the publisher refuses scripts.

    • it was determined that the claim by the Hofmann et al. research collaboration for the discovery of element 110 at GSI has fulfilled those criteria
    • describes interesting preliminary work but is insufficient to give confidence that element 110 has been produced
    • the need to postulate unproven steps and to explain unfavorable observations
    • an unfortunate electronic failure which necessitated use of a detector that was disabled for a fraction of a millisecond
    • However, only three of the alpha particles are observed.
    • There has been no intent by the JWP to convey invalidation of any of the results.
    • Resourceful work done at Berkeley is certainly consistent with possible discovery of element 110, but nevertheless is unable to fulfill the criteria sufficiently.
  2. 2

    International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry, answers by Sigurd Hofmann of GSI, 2003. Darmstadtium: Questions and Answers .

    The date of the first nucleus, the interim name, the reasons for the time before the name, and the list of 48 nuclei measured by 2003 by laboratory and reaction. Read with Firecrawl; the site refuses scripts.

    • was not based on uncertainties or major objections from other laboratories
    • some clarification was needed concerning experimental work made in Dubna and Berkeley on element 110
  3. 3

    J. Corish and G. M. Rosenblatt, IUPAC Inorganic Chemistry Division; Pure and Applied Chemistry 75(10), 1613-1615, 2003. Name and symbol of the element with atomic number 110 (IUPAC Recommendations 2003) , Recommendation, and note 7.

    The proposal of the name by the GSI discoverers, the tradition of names after places, the approval in Ottawa, and the confirmations of darmstadtium-271 at Berkeley and RIKEN. Read with Firecrawl; the publisher refuses scripts.

    • the JWP reendorses the confirmed synthesis of element 110 by the team at GSI led by S. Hofmann (after reassessment necessitated by revelations at the Berkeley and GSI laboratories of some apparently fabricated or partially modified decay chains)
  4. 4

    GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung, 2026. History of GSI: milestones .

    GSI discovered six elements, bohrium to copernicium.

    • Discovery of six new chemical elements and their official recognization by IUPAC in the Periodic Table of the Elements
  5. 5

    Wissenschafts- und Kongresszentrum Darmstadt GmbH & Co. KG (operator of the darmstadtium congress center), 2026. The darmstadtium: facts and information .

    The opening of the congress center on 6 December 2007, the reason for its name, and the room names from the periodic table.

    • Opening: 6 December 2007
    • It is named after the chemical element Darmstadtium (Ds110)
    • Darmstadt is the only German city after which an element is named.
  6. 6

    Wissenschafts- und Kongresszentrum Darmstadt GmbH & Co. KG, 2019. Photopoint zum Jubiläum: Vor 25 Jahren wurde das chemische Element 'Darmstadtium' entdeckt (press release, in German) .

    The time of the first synthesis (9 November 1994, 16.39), the display for the 25th anniversary, and the claim that Darmstadt is the only German city in the periodic table.

    • An die Entdeckung vor 25 Jahren erinnern GSI und Kongresszentrum mit einem eigens dafür gestalteten Photopoint im Foyer
  7. 7

    Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Darmstadtium - Element information, properties and uses , Sections Uses and properties, History, and the podcast transcript by Brian Clegg.

    The use in research only, the biological role, the leaders of the GSI team, the name 'wixhausium' that was briefly considered, and the 3 trillion ions per second of the 1994 experiment.

    • The alternative name of wixhausium was briefly considered for the element, after Wixhausen, the part of Darmstadt where the institute is located
  8. 8

    Los Alamos National Laboratory, 2026. Darmstadtium, in the Periodic Table of Elements , Sections History, Properties, Forms, Sources and Fun Facts.

    The production only in a laboratory, the expected likeness to the platinum metals, the statement that its properties cannot be measured, and the joke name 'policium'. The page has errors (see the research notes), so only these statements are cited.

    • joked about calling the element
    • because in Germany, the emergency telephone number is 1-1-0
  9. 9

    M. Thoennessen, National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory, Michigan State University (preprint for Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables), 2012. Discovery of Isotopes of Elements with Z ≥ 100 , arXiv:1203.2105v1, section 12, Discovery of 267-281 Ds.

    The dates of submission of the GSI and Berkeley papers in 1994, and the discovery of each isotope up to 2010.

    • The observation of one of the decay chains was later retracted
  10. 10

    P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, B. W. Petley and E. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 75(10), 1601-1611, 2003. On the claims for discovery of elements 110, 111, 112, 114, 116, and 118 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Element Z=110, items 110;03 and 110;04.

    The chain of 1994 that GSI could not reconstruct from the original data, and the working party's view that the GSI priority did not change. Read with Firecrawl; the publisher refuses scripts.

    • Priority of element 110 discovery by this collaboration has not changed.