Copernicium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

The disputes were about the evidence. In 2009 the joint working party of IUPAC and IUPAP gave priority to GSI. It judged that Dubna had very likely made copernicium too. It did not accept a claim based on CERN data1.

Copernicium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →

Last updated 15 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

Three groups claimed element 112. The joint working party (JWP) of IUPAC and IUPAP judged the claims in 20091.

  • GSI, Darmstadt. The JWP gave the priority to the GSI papers of 1996 and 20022. A RIKEN team made two atoms by the same reaction and duplicated the GSI decay chains1.
  • JINR, Dubna. In 1999 Dubna reported copernicium-283 from uranium and calcium-481. A Berkeley team failed to reproduce the result, and chemists in Germany did not see the element1. In 2007 GSI published a repeat of the Dubna reaction2. GSI reported four events of copernicium-283: two by alpha decay and two by fission1. The JWP found it very likely that Dubna had made copernicium-2831. It wrote that it did not intend to invalidate the other results1.
  • A. Marinov and colleagues claimed element 112 from tungsten targets hit by protons at CERN2. Brandt, a member of that group, rejected the negative results of other teams, because they had not repeated the exact experiment1. The JWP was not persuaded1.

Workers and communities

Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with copernicium, a few atoms at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from copernicium.

Who gains and who loses

We found no source on income from copernicium. GSI lists copernicium among the six elements that it discovered3. IUPAC accepted the name that the GSI discoverers proposed4.

Public debate

Victor Ninov worked on the GSI experiments of 1994 to 19965. In December 2001 GSI reported a re-analysis of those experiments. Two reported decay chains were not in the data5. One was a chain of element 110 from 1994, and the other was the first chain of element 112 from 19966. The JWP wrote that GSI retracted the first of its two 1996 chains of element 1121. The JWP considered only the second chain1.

Hofmann told Physics Today that Ninov was in charge of the data analysis at the time. He said that GSI did not have to retract any main conclusion on elements 110 to 1125. Ninov denied the accusations of fabrication made at Berkeley5. He said that people go after the past of someone they want to frame5. The Berkeley case is on the superheavy elements page.

Sources

  1. 1

    R. C. Barber, H. W. Gäggeler, P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, E. Vardaci and E. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 81(7), 1331-1343, 2009. Discovery of the element with atomic number 112 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Sections 112;01 to 112;18, the JWP assessments, and the summary of conclusions, pp. 1334-1340.

    The working party's review of the GSI, RIKEN, Dubna and Marinov claims for element 112, and its verdict. The publisher refuses scripts; the text was read with Firecrawl.

    • The element with atomic number 112 has been reviewed and assigned priority of discovery
    • indeed do duplicate two decay chains commencing with 277112
    • This collaboration used the reaction 48Ca + 238U
    • with a spontaneous fission half life of 3 min
    • failed to reproduce the observation
    • in Germany failed to observe the element with atomic number 112
    • reported two events with α-energies of 9.52 MeV ascribed to 283112 and two other events
    • The 283112 lifetime for the four events was 10 s
    • appears very likely
    • Collectively, the Dubna and GSI results above
    • It must be recognized that there is no intent by the JWP to suggest
    • in which he rejects the negative results because thesame exact experiment
    • is not persuaded of the validity of their interpretations
    • Existence of the first chain was subsequently retracted
    • showing that it was not in the original data
    • the properties of the second chain are considered
  2. 2

    M. Thoennessen, National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory, Michigan State University (preprint for Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables), 2012. Discovery of Isotopes of Elements with Z ≥ 100 , arXiv:1203.2105v1, section 14, Discovery of 277-285 Cn.

    The discovery of 1996, the JWP verdict of 2009, the CERN claim, the name, and the discovery of each copernicium isotope up to 2010.

    • the JWP has agreed that the priority of the Hofmann et al. 1996 [155] and 2002 [156] collaborations
    • could not be reproduced by Gregorich et al. [179] but were confirmed by Hofmann et al. [180]
    • Eur. Phys. J. A 32 (2007) 251
    • 112 in tungsten targets bombarded with 24 GeV protons at CERN
  3. 3

    GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung, 2026. History of GSI: milestones , Milestones of GSI History, 1981 until 2010.

    GSI lists copernicium among the six elements that it discovered.

    • Discovery of six new chemical elements
  4. 4

    Kazuyuki Tatsumi and John Corish, IUPAC Inorganic Chemistry Division; Pure and Applied Chemistry 82(3), 753-755, 2010. Name and symbol of the element with atomic number 112 (IUPAC Recommendations 2010) , Recommendation and Note, pp. 753-754.

    The proposal of the name copernicium and the symbol Cn, the reasons for the name, and the refusal of the symbol Cp. The publisher refuses scripts; the text was read with Firecrawl.

    • proposed the name copernicium and the symbol Cn
  5. 5

    Bertram M. Schwarzschild, Physics Today (American Institute of Physics), 2002. Lawrence Berkeley Lab Concludes that Evidence of Element 118 Was a Fabrication , September 2002, section A formal investigation.

    The GSI re-analysis of its experiments on elements 110 to 112, the two decay chains that were not in the data, and the statements of Hofmann and Ninov.

    • Ninov, who got his PhD at GSI in 1992, was a major participant in those experiments before he came to Berkeley in 1997.
    • revealed that two alpha-decay chains reported in the original papers were not to be found in the data
    • he was, in fact, in charge of our data analysis at that time
    • we have not had to retract any of our substantive conclusions for elements 110 to 112
    • emphatically denies the accusations
    • If you’re trying to frame someone, you also go after his past.
  6. 6

    S. Hofmann, F. P. Heßberger, D. Ackermann and others; European Physical Journal A 14 (2002) 147-157, 2002. New results on elements 111 and 112 , Abstract.

    The second GSI chain of element 112 and the re-analysis of 34 decay chains, which named the two chains that were not in the data. Only the abstract was read, in a browser; the full paper is paywalled.

    • the second chain of 269110 measured in 1994 and the first chain of 277112 measured in 1996