Cobalt: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Amnesty International reported in 2016 that children as young as seven dug cobalt in small Congolese mines. In 2023 it reported forced evictions near large mines. In 2024 a US appeals court upheld the dismissal of a child labor case against Apple, Tesla and others.
Last updated 10 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
In 2019 a group of plaintiffs sued Apple, Alphabet, Dell Technologies, Microsoft and Tesla in the United States. The group was four former miners and the representatives of child miners, some of them killed in cobalt mines1. The group International Rights Advocates brought the case. It said that the children were hurt in mines linked to Glencore, Umicore and Huayou Cobalt, which supply the companies2.
A district court dismissed the case. On 5 March 2024 the federal appeals court in Washington, DC, upheld the dismissal. The court found that the plaintiffs had standing to sue for damages. But it said that buying cobalt through the global supply chain did not make the companies part of a venture with the suppliers1. Judge Neomi Rao wrote that the companies own no interest in their suppliers and do not share in their profits and risks1. The opinion also gives the plaintiffs’ claim that the suppliers force children to work to meet the companies’ demand11. At this stage of a case, a court accepts the facts in the complaint as true and does not test them1.
Workers and communities
In 2016 Amnesty International traced cobalt from small mines where children as young as seven worked3. It counted at least 80 deaths of artisanal miners underground in 18 months, and said that the true number is unknown3. It cited a UNICEF estimate of 40,000 children in mines in the south of the Congo in 20143.
USGS reports that large miners and the Chinese refiner Huayou stopped buying artisanal cobalt, because of environmental, social and governance concerns4. In late 2019 the Congo set up Entreprise Générale du Cobalt (EGC), a state company. Its stated aim is to improve the working conditions of artisanal miners, by control of their production and sales4.
Large mines also affect the people near them. In 2023 Amnesty International and a Congolese group reported forced evictions near six mining projects around Kolwezi5. One case is the Kolwezi mine of COMMUS, a joint venture of the Chinese company Zijin and the state company Gécamines. The mine is growing into Cité Gécamines, a district of about 39,000 people5. COMMUS told Amnesty that it aimed to improve communication with the people affected5.
In another case, residents said that soldiers burned the village of Mukumbi in 2016, near a project of the company Chemaf. Chemaf later agreed to pay $1.5 million5. Chemaf denies that it had any part in the destruction5.
Mining can also pollute. In 2023 the Congo suspended the Boss Mining operation after rain flooded a tailings dam6. In sulfide ores, mining can cause acid mine drainage, which carries metals into water7.
Who gains and who loses
The Congo’s tax on cobalt exports depends on the market price. When prices fell in 2024, its income from cobalt fell too, by the Cobalt Institute8. Prices rose after its export ban of 2025. The Cobalt Institute’s reasons for the rise are in the market chapter. Under the quotas, companies must pay a 10% royalty in advance before they export8.
Artisanal miners lose when prices are low. The Cobalt Institute says that the low prices of late 2024 and early 2025 made artisanal mining less attractive. The quotas also left fewer buyers able to export88.
Public debate
The debate is about who is responsible for abuses far down the supply chain. In 2016 Amnesty contacted 16 multinational companies. None gave enough detail to check where its cobalt came from3. Five denied that they bought cobalt through Huayou, and six said they were investigating3. Amnesty noted that cobalt was not covered by the US rules on conflict minerals3.
Sources
- 1
United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit (Judge N. Rao), 2024. John Doe 1 v. Apple Inc., No. 21-7135 (opinion of the court) , pp. 3 to 6 (summary and background); part III.
The court found standing for the damages claims and affirmed the dismissal for failure to state a claim. The court restates the plaintiffs' allegations in part I.
-
The plaintiffs are four former miners, seven legal representatives of former miners who are still children, and five representatives of child miners who were killed in cobalt mining operations
-
Although we conclude that the plaintiffs have standing to pursue their damages claims, they have failed to state a claim for relief. Purchasing an unspecified amount of cobalt through the global supply chain is not
-
The Tech Companies own no interest in their suppliers. Nor do the Tech Companies share in the suppliers
-
As alleged in the complaint
-
the cobalt suppliers and their subsidiaries actively solicit and force children to work in order to meet the Tech Companies
-
accepting the pleaded facts as true
-
- 2
CNN (D. Cole), via KTVZ, 2024. Federal appeals court throws out lawsuit against Apple, Google, Tesla and other tech giants over alleged child labor in Congo .
News report on the ruling in Doe v. Apple, March 2024. Cited only for the group that brought the case and its claim.
-
The class action lawsuit was brought on behalf of the plaintiffs by International Rights Advocates, which had claimed that the children were exploited and hurt in mining operations linked to the mining companies Glencore, Umicore and Huayou Cobalt
-
- 3
Amnesty International, 2016. Exposed: Child labour behind smart phone and electric car batteries .
Press release on the report 'This is what we die for'. Child labor and deaths in artisanal cobalt mining; the supply chain through Huayou Cobalt.
-
from mines where children as young as seven and adults work in perilous conditions
-
At least 80 artisanal miners died underground in southern DRC between September 2014 and December 2015 alone. The true figure is unknown
-
In 2014 approximately 40,000 children worked in mines across southern DRC, many of them mining cobalt, according to UNICEF
-
Crucially, none provided enough details to independently verify where the cobalt in their products came from
-
Six said they were investigating the claims. Five denied sourcing cobalt from via Huayou Cobalt
-
Cobalt does not fall under existing
-
- 4
U.S. Geological Survey, 2023. Cobalt, in 2020 Minerals Yearbook , World Review, Congo (Kinshasa) and China.
The closure of the Mutanda Mine; EGC and Trafigura; refiners that stopped buying artisanal cobalt.
-
decisions by large-scale mechanized mining companies and leading Chinese refiner Huayou to stop sourcing artisanally mined cobalt owing to environmental, social, and governance concerns
-
was established in late 2019 to improve the working conditions of artisanal miners by managing and controlling production, purchasing, processing, and marketing of cobalt produced by artisanal methods
-
- 5
Amnesty International, 2023. DRC: Cobalt and copper mining for batteries leading to human rights abuses .
Forced evictions near Kolwezi; the answers of COMMUS and Chemaf; cobalt in batteries.
-
interviewed more than 130 people at six different mining projects in and around the city of Kolwezi
-
The affected neighbourhood of Cité Gécamines is home to about 39,000 people
-
COMMUS told Amnesty International that it aimed to improve communication with stakeholders
-
in 2019 Chemaf agreed to pay via the local authority US$1.5 million, but some former residents received as little as US$300
-
Chemaf denies any wrongdoing, liability, or involvement in the destruction of Mukumbi, or directing military forces to destroy it
-
- 6
U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Cobalt, in 2023 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , pp. 19.1 to 19.8 (text, World Review, Outlook); table 1 (salient statistics); table 7 (world mine production); table 8 (world refinery production).
World mine and refinery production in 2023, artisanal mining, companies and events in the Congo, China and Indonesia, uses.
-
a suspension of Boss Mining after heavy rains in late March flooded a tailings dam and sparked concerns of environmental pollution in the Kakanda River
-
- 7
U.S. Geological Survey (J.F. Slack, B.E. Kimball, K.B. Shedd), 2017. Cobalt, chap. F of Critical Mineral Resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802-F) , Summary; Uses; Strategic and Critical Resource Issues; Geology (deposit types, mineralogy, geochemistry); Resources and Production; Environmental Considerations.
Deposit types, ore minerals, grades, resources, by-product supply, the crust and seawater content, health and mine waste.
-
potentially causing the environmental problem known as acid mine drainage (AMD)
-
- 8
Cobalt Institute (prepared by Benchmark Mineral Intelligence), 2026. Cobalt Market Report 2025 , Executive summary; sections 3 (supply), 4 (demand), 5 (prices), 6 (geopolitics), 7 (outlook).
Industry association. World demand by use, mined and refined supply, companies, prices, the export ban and quotas of the Congo, policy, forecasts to 2035.
-
As the DRC government tax on cobalt exports is based on market prices, this low-price environment resulted in a significant decline in the country’s cobalt revenue
-
Companies are expected to prepay a 10% mining royalty to ARECOMS
-
the historical low prices in late 2024 and early 2025 disincentiv
-
quota allocations and new legal restrictions mean many prior purchasers are no longer able to export, limiting purchasing interest
-