Bohrium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
There were disputes about credit and about the name. In 1993 an international working group found only the Darmstadt work convincing. In 1997 IUPAC called the discovery joint, and chose bohrium over the discoverers' name nielsbohrium5.
Bohrium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →
Last updated 15 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Two laboratories claimed element 107 (see the history chapter). In 1976 a Dubna team reported fission events from chromium and bismuth. It assigned them to a short-lived isotope of element 10712. In 1981 a GSI team in Darmstadt reported alpha decay chains of bohrium-2623.
The IUPAC-IUPAP Transfermium Working Group judged the claims in 1993. It found the Darmstadt work convincing2. It found the Dubna assignment of the millisecond fission events to element 107 unconvincing2. The Dubna team had seen events of element 105. The group wrote that they quite probably came from the formation of element 107, but that this work alone did not give enough confidence2.
Dubna wrote that the working group underestimated some of its papers, on elements 103 to 105. It said it would respect the decision4. In 1997 the IUPAC nomenclature commission described element 107 as discovered jointly by Darmstadt and Dubna5. In 2020 an IUPAC-IUPAP report wrote that for elements 107 and 108, contributions from a second laboratory had counted as co-discovery6.
Workers and communities
Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with bohrium, a few atoms at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from bohrium.
Who gains and who loses
Public debate
The debate was about the name. A Dubna team had first proposed nielsbohrium for element 1052. In its response to the working group, published in 1993, GSI proposed the name for element 107. It made the proposal together with its Dubna colleagues. GSI wrote that this would also help to settle the dispute over the name of element 1054.
In 1994 an IUPAC commission recommended the name bohrium instead, with 20 votes in favour. It wanted the name to match other elements named after people8. In 1997 the commission wrote that the name nielsbohrium had no precedent, because it held both the first name and the family name of Bohr5. IUPAC asked the Danish national chemistry body, which preferred bohrium5.
Sources
- 1
Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Bohrium - Element information, properties and uses , Sections Uses, Biological role, Natural abundance, History.
The absence in nature, the research use, the biological role and the leaders of the Dubna and GSI teams.
-
They published the results of their successful run in 1976 and submitted a discovery claim.
-
- 2
IUPAC/IUPAP Transfermium Working Group (R. C. Barber, N. N. Greenwood, A. Z. Hrynkiewicz, Y. P. Jeannin, M. Lefort, M. Sakai, I. Ulehla, A. H. Wapstra and D. H. Wilkinson); Pure and Applied Chemistry 65(8), 1757-1814, 1993. Discovery of the transfermium elements , Element Z = 105, paper 71Fl02 (the name nielsbohrium); element Z = 107, pp. 1788-1790; summary of conclusions.
The working group's assessment of the Dubna papers of 1976 and the Darmstadt paper of 1981 on element 107, and its verdict.
-
The authors therefore conclude that both activities are due to the formation of the isotope 261 107
-
The Darmstadt work 81MuO6 provides convincing evidence for the formation of element 107.
-
The assignment of the 1-2 (or 2.8) ms SF events to one of the two
-
must be considered unconvincing
-
which quite probably were due to the formation of element 2=107; yet, taken alone, this work does not give sufficient confidence
-
The authors propose for this element the name nielsbohrium
-
- 3
M. Thoennessen, National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory, Michigan State University (preprint for Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables), 2012. Discovery of Isotopes of Elements with Z ≥ 100 , arXiv:1203.2105v1, section 9, Discovery of 260-274 Bh.
The 1981 discovery, the reaction, the name, and the discovery of each isotope up to 2010.
-
Our results show the discovery of the α decay of element 107.
-
- 4
A. Ghiorso and G. T. Seaborg (Berkeley), Yu. Ts. Oganessian and I. Zvara (Dubna), the GSI group, and the Transfermium Working Group; Pure and Applied Chemistry 65 (1993) 1815-1824, 1993. Responses on the report 'Discovery of the transfermium elements' , Darmstadt response, 'Element 107 should be named Nielsbohrium (Ns)'.
The GSI proposal of the name nielsbohrium, made together with Dubna. Read in the cached excerpt.
-
It seems to us that the TWG conclusions underestimate the importance of some Dubna papers on the elements 103, 104 and 105. But we have agreed to cooperate with the TWG and have thus assumed an obligation to respect its decision.
-
we propose the name for element 107 together with our colleagues from JINR. This suggestion will also help to solve the controversy of naming element 105.
-
- 5
IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 69(12), 2471-2473, 1997. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1997) , Recommendations, p. 2472, and the table of names and symbols, p. 2473.
The joint credit to Darmstadt and Dubna, the debate on nielsbohrium, and the preference of the Danish NAO.
-
The discoveries of elements 107 (jointly by the Darmstadt and Dubna laboratories)
-
The name nielsbohrium is long and includes the first name of Niels Bohr as well as his family name. Such an element name is without precedent.
-
Finally it was decided to refer the matter to the Danish NAO. Its preference for bohrium rather than nielsbohrium was ultimately accepted.
-
Its preference for bohrium rather than nielsbohrium was ultimately accepted.
-
- 6
Sigurd Hofmann, Sergey N. Dmitriev, Claes Fahlander, Jacklyn M. Gates, James B. Roberto and Hideyuki Sakai; Pure and Applied Chemistry 92(9), 2020. On the discovery of new elements (IUPAC/IUPAP Report) , Sections 2.2, 5 and 7.1.
The cold fusion reactions with lead and bismuth targets, the separator SHIP, and co-discovery in the cases of elements 107 and 108. Read in the cached Firecrawl copy.
-
the discovery of elements 107 and 108, important contributions from a second laboratory were considered as co-discovery
-
the laboratory announcing a discovery first and presenting convincing data, was respected with priority of discovery and was asked to suggest a name for that element
-
- 7
GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung, 2026. Discovery of new elements , Table 'Elements made at GSI', row 107.
The date of discovery, the beam and target, the date of official recognition and the origin of the name.
-
Elements discovered at GSI (atomic number): bohrium (107), hassium (108), meitnerium (109), darmstadtium (110), roentgenium (111), copernicium (112)
-
- 8
IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 66(12), 2419-2421, 1994. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1994) , Recommendations, pp. 2420-2421.
The 1994 vote, with 20 votes in favour of the name bohrium, and the reason to prefer it to nielsbohrium. Read in the cached browser copy.
-
107 Bohrium Bh 20
-
instead of the proposed Nielsbohrium, so that it conforms to the names of the other elements named after individuals
-