Arsenic: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
In Bangladesh, tube wells installed from the 1970s for safer water exposed tens of millions of people to natural arsenic. Arsenic waste at old mines, such as Giant Mine in Canada, needs long-term care. In 2023, press reports on a Moroccan cobalt mine led BMW to order audits.
Last updated 10 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
In 2023 the German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung reported violations of environmental and labor standards at mines in Morocco, including high arsenic in water samples. BMW, which buys cobalt from the Bou Azzer mine, ordered two independent audits1. BMW gets about 20% of its cobalt from Morocco1.
Managem said that an audit of its water supplies found no irregularities. It also said no arsenic-related illness had been found in its workers or reported in the area1.
In May 2024, German media reported the results of the BMW audit. The auditors found high arsenic in waste and water collection systems at the mine and near it. They could not establish or rule out a link to the mine2. BMW said that Managem had built new water basins and drainage ditches. BMW did not end its supply contract2.
Managem said that two independent audits found that the arsenic is natural, with no link to the mine. Managem also said that the arsenic in the area has been known since the mine opened in 19283. The company announced a lawsuit in Paris against the media that published the claims3.
Workers and communities
In Bangladesh, the government and UNICEF installed tube wells in the 1970s. The aim was to replace pond water, which carried bacteria and made infants and children ill4. Standard water tests did not include arsenic4. The first skin lesions from arsenic were found in 1983, in patients from West Bengal, India. Arsenic in Bangladesh’s wells was confirmed in 19934.
In 2000, Smith and colleagues wrote that 35 to 77 million of Bangladesh’s 125 million people were at risk. They called it the largest poisoning of a population in history4. In 2016, Human Rights Watch reported that about 20 million people still drank water above the national limit of 50 micrograms per liter. It cited one study that estimates 43,000 deaths a year5. In the national household survey of 2018 to 2019 (MICS), 12% of the population drank water above the national standard6.
In Canada, the Giant gold mine left about 237,000 tonnes of arsenic trioxide dust underground in the Yellowknife area7. The Canadian government says that no option it studied lets it fully walk away from the site at present7.
In US wood treatment plants, the EPA found cancer and other health risks for workers who handle the wood preservative chromated copper arsenate (CCA)8.
Who gains and who loses
Human Rights Watch reported in 2016 that politicians in Bangladesh diverted new government water points to their supporters. It said that in one government project, official policy gave members of parliament a say in where half of the new water points went5. Human Rights Watch also found that in some villages, the government’s deep tube wells work and supply safe water to thousands of people5.
Public debate
In the United States, CCA-treated wood was used for decks and playsets until 2003. The makers then stopped making it for homeowner uses8. The EPA found no health risks of concern for the general public8.
Arsenic drugs in poultry feed were also debated. The Center for Food Safety and other groups sued the FDA. In 2013 the FDA agreed to withdraw 98 of 101 arsenic-based animal drugs9. The FDA cited published reports that the organic arsenic in these drugs could change into inorganic arsenic, which causes cancer9. The US National Chicken Council said that by 2013 no arsenic feed additive was still used for broiler chickens10.
Sources
- 1
SupplyChainBrain, 2023. BMW Investigating Moroccan Miner Following Hazardous Water Claims .
The audits of the Bou Azzer mine and Managem's reply.
-
BMW has commissioned two independent audits of the Bou Azzer mine operated by the Moroccan company Managem
-
Sueddeutsche Zeitung said that its reporters found violations of environmental and labor protection standards at Moroccan mines, including excessive levels of arsenic in water samples
-
BMW sources about 20% of its cobalt from Morocco
-
Managem has said that an audit of its water supplies showed no irregularities
-
Since the opening of the mine, no arsenic-related occupational illnesses have been identified, nor have any arsenic-related illnesses in the Bou Azzer mine area been reported
-
- 2
Stefan Krempl, heise online, 2024. E-cars: BMW admits to environmental problems at Moroccan cobalt mine .
The results of the BMW audit at Bou Azzer, as reported by NDR, WDR and Süddeutsche Zeitung.
-
high concentrations of arsenic in waste and water collection systems on the mine site itself and in the immediate vicinity
-
They were neither able to establish nor rule out a link to mine operations
-
BMW has now told the reporting team that Managem has implemented construction measures
-
new water basins have been built and drainage ditches dug
-
BMW refused to withdraw from the supply contract with Managem
-
- 3
Hespress English, 2024. Managem denies allegations of causing pollution .
Managem's reply to the audit reports.
-
These audits confirmed the natural presence of arsenic and found no link between mining activities and the detected arsenic levels
-
the natural presence of arsenic in the area has been known since the mine’s operation began in 1928
-
announcing a lawsuit in Paris against the media outlets that published the claims
-
- 4
Allan H. Smith, Elena O. Lingas and Mahfuzar Rahman, Bulletin of the World Health Organization 78(9), 2000. Contamination of drinking-water by arsenic in Bangladesh: a public health emergency .
History of the tube wells and the discovery of arsenic in them, and the number of people at risk.
-
Infants and children suffered from acute gastrointestinal disease resulting from bacterial contamination of stagnant pond water
-
during the 1970s the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF)worked with the Department of Public Health Engineering to install tube-wells
-
standard water testing procedures did not include tests for arsenic
-
In 1983, the first cases of arsenic-induced skin lesions were identified by K.C. Saha
-
The first patients seen were from West Bengal, but by 1987 several had already been identified who came from neighbouring Bangladesh
-
arsenic contamination of water in tube-wells was confirmed in 1993 in the Nawabganj district
-
of the 125 million inhabitants of Bangladesh between 35 million and 77 million are at risk of drinking contaminated water
-
The contamination of groundwater by arsenic in Bangladesh is the largest poisoning of a population in history
-
- 5
Human Rights Watch, 2016. Nepotism and Neglect: The Failing Response to Arsenic in the Drinking Water of Bangladesh's Rural Poor .
People still exposed in Bangladesh, deaths, and the siting of new wells.
-
some 20 million people continue to drink water above 50
-
Bangladesh standard (50 micrograms of arsenic per liter of water.)
-
an estimated 43,000 people die each year from arsenic-related illness in Bangladesh, according to one study
-
politicians undermine the allocation of new government water points by diverting these life-saving public goods to their political supporters and allies
-
official policy recognized the influence of parliamentarians in siting 50 percent of all new water points
-
In some villages, the government’s deep tubewells are functional, accessible, and supply abundant and life-saving water for thousands
-
- 6
REACH programme, University of Oxford, 2021. Drinking water quality in Bangladesh: 2021 updates. Key findings from the Bangladesh MICS 2018-2019 water quality thematic report .
Summary of the national survey of arsenic in household drinking water.
-
Key findings from the Bangladesh MICS 2018-2019
-
12% of the population is exposed to arsenic above the Bangladesh standard in drinking water
-
- 7
Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada, 2026. Managing arsenic at Giant Mine .
The arsenic trioxide waste at Giant Mine and the plan to freeze it.
-
The bedrock in the Yellowknife area, including the Giant Mine site
-
During the life of the mine, the roasting process created about 237,000 tonnes of arsenic trioxide waste
-
In fact, no total … solution currently exists
-
- 8
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2026. Chromated Arsenicals (CCA) .
History and risks of CCA wood preservatives.
-
Chromated arsenicals pose cancer and non-cancer health risks of concern to workers in wood treatment facilities
-
Prior to 2004, wood treated with chromated arsenicals was used in residential structures such as decks and playsets
-
In December 2003, chromated arsenicals manufacturers voluntarily discontinued manufacturing chromated arsenicals-treated wood products for homeowner uses
-
EPA did not find health risks of concern for the general public
-
- 9
Food Safety News, 2015. FDA to Withdraw Approval for Arsenic-Based Drug Used in Poultry .
The end of arsenic-based animal drugs in the United States.
-
The agency agreed in 2013 to withdraw 98 of 101 arsenic-based animals drugs after CFS and eight other groups filed a lawsuit over the issue
-
organic arsenic, the less toxic form of arsenic present in the arsenic-based animal drugs, could transform into inorganic arsenic, a known carcinogen
-
- 10
Agri-Pulse, 2013. FDA withdraws approval for arsenic in poultry, pig feed .
The FDA withdrawal of three arsenic feed drugs in 2013.
-
No other feed additives containing arsenic are currently used in broiler meat production in the United States
-