Tin: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
US and EU laws require checks on tin from eastern Congo and other conflict areas. On Bangka, in Indonesia, campaigners link tin mining to deaths of miners and to damage to forests and reefs. A corruption case at the state company PT Timah led to prison terms of up to 20 years.
Last updated 13 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
In eastern Congo (Kinshasa), tin ore is one of the minerals that US law links to the financing of conflict. The rule is Section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Act. It covers cassiterite, columbite-tantalite, gold and wolframite1. Congo and its neighbors produced 3% to 6% of the world’s tin in the five years to 20221. Output in Congo has grown since. By USGS estimates, Congo (Kinshasa) alone mined about 27,000 tonnes in 2025, about 9% of the world total (our calculation)2.
In 2022, 1,005 companies filed conflict minerals reports in the United States. Only 51% could name the country of origin of their minerals1.
In early 2025, fighting reached the area of the Bisie tin mine in North Kivu. The Congolese army was fighting rebels led by the M23 group3. Miningmx reported that armed groups took nearby towns on 9 and 12 March3. The operator, Alphamin, stopped mining on 13 March and evacuated most staff43. Production started again on 15 April, after the rebels withdrew from a nearby town, the company said4. Bisie had produced 17,324 tonnes of tin in 20243.
In Myanmar, most tin came from areas run by the self-administered Wa State. In April 2023 the Wa authorities announced a halt to mining. They said it would protect mineral resources until new rules were in place5. All mining stopped in August 20235. In July 2025 the International Tin Association said that several operators at Man Maw, in Wa State, had new three-year mining permits. It expected shipments to start again in the following months6.
Workers and communities
Bangka is the main source of placer tin in Indonesia7. In 2012 Friends of the Earth Indonesia (Walhi) said more than sixty miners had died that year. Most were buried underground or trapped underwater8. The same group said tin mining had polluted fifteen rivers. It said that more than half of the people on Bangka had problems getting clean water8. These are the campaign group’s figures; we found no official count to compare.
Illegal mining is an old problem on Bangka and Belitung. The USGS reports that from 2002 to 2008 the Indonesian government closed as many as 130,000 illegal tin operations9.
Who gains and who loses
Indonesian courts sent former PT Timah managers and others to prison. They had let other companies mine in the concessions of the state company from 2015 to 202210. The appeal court found state losses of Rp 300 trillion, including environmental damage. That is about $18.5 billion1110. Of this, Rp 271 trillion was counted as environmental damage. Rp 26.65 trillion was payments to illegal miners and Rp 2.28 trillion an irregular lease of smelting equipment10.
In February 2025 the Jakarta High Court raised the sentence of businessman Harvey Moeis from 6.5 to 20 years11. It also raised the sentence of Mochtar Riza Pahlevi, president director of PT Timah from 2016 to 2021, to 20 years11. The first court had found Moeis to be the link between PT Timah and the private smelter PT Refined Bangka Tin10.
In October 2025 the attorney general handed assets seized in the case to PT Timah. They included six smelters and about 680 tonnes of refined tin12. President Prabowo Subianto said he had ordered the closure of about 1,000 illegal tin mines on Bangka and Belitung12. On the same day, small-scale miners protested at PT Timah’s office for better prices for their ore. Police used tear gas and water cannon, the state news agency Antara reported12.
Public debate
In 2012 Friends of the Earth said tin in smartphones was almost certainly linked to damage on Bangka. It said that Samsung and Apple refused to say where their tin came from8. The group called for EU rules that would make companies report such impacts8. We did not find the companies’ answers of 2012.
The first sentence of 6.5 years for Harvey Moeis caused public anger in Indonesia10. Prosecutors had asked for 12 years, and they appealed10. The first court had said the demand was too harsh for his role as a representative of the smelter10.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Geological Survey (Chad A. Friedline), 2026. Tin, in 2022 Minerals Yearbook .
World mine and smelter production, leading refiners, world uses and recycling in 2022, China's consumption, conflict minerals rules, PT Timah and Bisie.
-
which focused on the use of minerals determined to be financing conflict in Congo (Kinshasa) or adjoining countries
-
is defined as cassiterite, columbite-tantalite, gold, wolframite, or their derivatives
-
Tin concentrate production from Congo (Kinshasa) and adjoining countries has constituted 3% to 6% of world production during the previous 5 years
-
In 2022, 1,005 companies filed conflict minerals disclosures
-
In 2022, 51% of companies were able to determine the originating country for minerals used in their products.
-
- 2
U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Tin, pp. 194-195.
World mine production and reserves by country, US uses, imports, recycling, prices and tariffs, the Coatesville project, resources and substitutes.
-
26,000 27,000 e
-
1,570 1,700 294,000 290,000
-
- 3
Miningmx, 2025. Alphamin evacuates Bisie as rebels bear down on Congo mine .
The suspension of the Bisie mine in March 2025 and its share of world output.
-
heavy fighting between the Congolese armed forces (FARDC) and a coalition of rebels led by the Rwanda-backed M23 group
-
the militant groups had recently advanced westward
-
This was after having occupied the town of Nyabiondo on March 9
-
followed by Kashebere a further 13km west of Nyabiondo on March 12
-
all operational mining staff are being evacuated except for essential personnel
-
Contained tin production was 17,324 tons in the 12 months ended December
-
- 4
Alphamin Resources Corp., 2025. Alphamin provides Q1 2025 and current operational update .
The company's account of the stop and restart of Bisie in 2025.
-
following a cessation of mining and processing activities on 13 March 2025 due to security concerns
-
On April 9, 2025 the Company announced the initiation of a phased resumption of operations following the withdrawal of insurgents from the town
-
Tin production recommenced on 15 April 2025
-
- 5
U.S. Geological Survey (Chad A. Friedline), 2024. Tin, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2024 .
US uses in 2023, the Wa State mining halt, Bolivia's force majeure, Indonesia's critical list.
-
In April, Burma’s selfadministered Wa State announced that beginning in August it would halt mining operations in areas under its control. The suspension is expected to protect mineral resources until new mining regulations are implemented.
-
In August, all mining, processing, and raw ore transportation activities ceased. Most of Burma’s tin was mined within areas administered by the Wa State.
-
- 6
Reuters, via Mining Weekly, 2025. Tin shipments from Myanmar's Wa State due to resume, tin group says .
Mining permits at Man Maw in Wa State in 2025, as the International Tin Association reported them.
-
several operators at Man Maw have now secured three-year mining permits
-
Shipments from the autonomous region are expected to resume in the coming months.
-
- 7
U.S. Geological Survey (R.J. Kamilli, B.E. Kimball and J.F. Carlin Jr.), 2017. Tin, chapter S of Critical Mineral Resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802) .
History, crust content, minerals, deposits and districts, uses, recycling, health and environment, producer agreements.
-
Bangka Island is the major source of placer tin
-
- 8
Friends of the Earth Europe, 2012. Mining for smartphones: the true cost of tin .
Press release of 26 November 2012 on tin mining on Bangka, with figures from Friends of the Earth Indonesia (Walhi).
-
more than sixty miners have died this year, most of them buried underground or trapped underwater
-
Fifteen rivers are now contaminated by tin mining waste and access to clean water has become a problem for more than half of Bangka’s population.
-
Tin used in some of the best-selling brands of smartphones is almost certainly linked to the devastation of forests, farmland, coral reefs and communities in Indonesia
-
Samsung and Apple refuse to tell us where their tin comes from.
-
We are asking the European Union to urgently draw up regulations forcing companies to disclose the resources they use
-
- 9
U.S. Geological Survey (James F. Carlin Jr.), 2013. Tin, in Metal Prices in the United States Through 2010 (Scientific Investigations Report 2012-5188) , Tin (Sn), pp. 181-183.
Early history, the tin agreements, the tin crisis of 1985 and prices to 2010.
-
From 2002 to 2008, the Indonesian Government gradually eliminated as many as 130,000 illegal tin mining operations.
-
- 10
Asia News Network (The Jakarta Post), 2025. Public anger over Indonesian businessman Harvey Moeis 'lenient' sentence .
The first verdict in the PT Timah case and how the state losses were calculated.
-
for enabling other companies to mine in Timah’s concession areas in Bangka Belitung from 2015 to 2022, and to profit from the illegal mining
-
Rp 300 trillion (US$18.5 billion)
-
comprised of Rp 2.28 trillion from the irregular lease of tin processing equipment, Rp 26.65 trillion in payments made to illegal miners and Rp 271.07 trillion in environmental damage
-
The Jakarta Corruption Court found Harvey to be the link between PT Timah and private smelter PT Refined Bangka Tin (RBT)
-
Public anger has ensued following a court verdict that sentenced businessman Harvey Moeis to 6.5 years in prison
-
a much lighter sentence than the 12 years sought by prosecutors
-
the Attorney General’s Office (AGO) filed an appeal
-
the judges however said the prosecutor’s sentence demand was too harsh in view of the offenses for which Harvey had been convicted in his role as a representative of RBT
-
- 11
Indonesian National Police (INP), 2025. Harvey Moeis' Prison Sentence Increased to 20 Years in Tin Corruption Case .
The appeal ruling of February 2025 in the PT Timah corruption case.
-
which caused Rp 300 trillion in state losses, including environmental damage
-
prison sentence to 20 years for his role in a massive corruption scheme
-
which had sentenced him to six and a half years
-
Mochtar Riza Pahlevi, President Director of PT Timah Tbk from 2016 to 2021, had his sentence increased to 20 years from the previous 8 years.
-
- 12
Reuters, via Malay Mail, 2025. Indonesia's Prabowo hands seized assets to state tin miner in anti-corruption push .
The handover of seized smelters to PT Timah in October 2025 and the closure of illegal tin mines on Bangka and Belitung.
-
The assets transferred to state tin miner Timah included six smelters, about 680 metric tonnes of refined tin and 108 units of heavy equipment
-
Prabowo said he had ordered the closure of about 1,000 illegal tin mines on Bangka and neighbouring Belitung Island
-
a number of small-scale miners held a protest outside PT Timah’s office in Pangkalpinang to demand the state company pay them better prices for the ore they supply to Timah
-
Police fired tear gas and deployed water cannon against the demonstrators to disperse protesters, state media Antara reported.
-