Tantalum: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Coltan from eastern Congo (Kinshasa) has long been linked to armed groups. M23 rebels have held the Rubaya mines since 2024. UN experts say the ore is smuggled to Rwanda, which denies it. Officials reported over 200 deaths in each of two 2026 landslides; neither toll is verified.
Last updated 14 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Eastern Congo (Kinshasa) has had armed conflict for decades, and coltan is one of its minerals. In a report of 2017, USGS refers to conflict coltan sold by rebel forces1. In a fact sheet of 2015, USGS reports claims about Rwanda. Some of the country’s reported production may have come from ore smuggled from North and South Kivu2.
In April 2024, the M23 armed group took control of Rubaya and much of the Masisi territory in North Kivu3. M23 says that its aim is to overthrow the government in Kinshasa and protect the Congolese Tutsi minority4.
In 2025, a UN group of experts reported that coltan smuggling from M23 areas had reached “unprecedented levels”5. The experts said that coltan from Rubaya went to Rwanda and was mixed with Rwandan production5. According to the UN experts, as cited by Argus, taxing and selling the ore could raise up to $800,000 a month for M233.
Rwanda denies that it backs M23 and that it exploits Congo’s minerals54. The conflict has displaced more than 7 million people, according to the Associated Press5.
In September 2026, Amnesty International reported that M23 fighters killed, tortured and forced miners to work at Rubaya and at a gold mine6. It said that the minerals were trafficked to Rwanda with the help of Rwandan authorities6. Neither M23 nor the Rwandan government answered Amnesty’s request for comment6.
Workers and communities
Much of the coltan of central Africa is dug by artisanal miners. At Rubaya, people dig by hand for a few dollars a day4. In 2011, artisanal mining gave about 29% of world tantalum supply1.
The work is dangerous. In late January 2026, part of the Rubaya mine collapsed. A spokesperson for the provincial governor appointed by the rebels told Reuters that more than 200 people were killed4. Reuters reported that the exact toll was still unclear two days later4. An adviser to the same governor said that at least 227 people were confirmed dead4.
In early March 2026, a second landslide hit Rubaya. The Congolese mines ministry said that more than 200 people died, 70 of them children, and blamed M23 for unsafe illegal mining. A source in Rubaya told the BBC that only six died, and that government attacks caused the collapse7. The BBC could not verify the toll7. Bellingcat counted at least four reported landslides at Rubaya in early 20268.
In 2012, US agencies added coltan from Congo (Kinshasa) to a list of goods that may be made with forced or indentured child labor9. Coltan from Congo (Kinshasa) is still on the online list of the US Department of Labor. The entry cites reports that children ages 5 to 17 are forced to work in some mines10.
Mining can pollute water. In Rwanda, USGS reports arsenic in stream sediments below the Ruhanga and Nyatubindi mines. It was above the level at which harm to water life becomes possible. It was below the level at which harm is probable1.
Who gains and who loses
Ore that cannot be shown to be conflict free may sell for less. USGS reports claims that such ore sold to Chinese and other buyers at a discount of about 30% to 60%2.
US imports of concentrates from Congo (Kinshasa) and Rwanda fell to zero, while China’s imports from Rwanda rose (see Market). Large technology companies, among them Apple, have urged their suppliers to avoid central Africa3.
This affects the miners. Some isolated parts of Congo (Kinshasa) rely heavily on income from artisanal tantalite mining (see Power). Avoiding the region can cut that income3.
Governments also discuss the future of the mines. In March 2026, the BBC cited a Reuters report on Rubaya. The Congolese government had put it on a shortlist of assets offered to the United States7. Amnesty International asked the United States and EU states not to make mining agreements on Rubaya without independent human rights observers6.
Public debate
According to a Royal Society of Chemistry podcast, demand for phones made tantalum a raw material linked to conflict11. Some people now speak of “blood tantalum”11.
Governments answered with reporting rules. The US Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 and an EU regulation in force since 2021 require companies to check where their tantalum comes from (see Power). Industry set up tracing schemes. The aim of the iTSCi program, started in 2011, is to identify legitimate mines1.
The schemes are disputed. Argus calls the state of due diligence “muddied”3. The Responsible Minerals Initiative is an industry group. In 2022, it removed iTSCi from its approved tracing schemes12. iTSCi criticized the group’s own processes and defended its work in Congo (Kinshasa)12.
In December 2024, the government of Congo (Kinshasa) filed criminal complaints in France and Belgium against subsidiaries of Apple. Its lawyers said that Apple uses minerals taken illegally from Congo and laundered through supply chains12. Apple said that it strongly disputed the claims, and that it had told its suppliers not to use these minerals from Congo or Rwanda13. In February 2025, the Paris prosecutor closed the French case as “not sufficiently well-founded”. Congo’s lawyers said that they would challenge it, and Belgium appointed an investigating magistrate13.
Sources
- 1
U.S. Geological Survey (K.J. Schulz, N.M. Piatak, J.F. Papp), 2017. Niobium and Tantalum, chap. M of Critical mineral resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802) , Abstract; Introduction; Uses; Geochemistry; Mineralogy; Deposit Types; Rare-Metal Granites and LCT Pegmatites; Resources and Production; Environmental Considerations.
Crustal abundance, minerals, deposit types, Greenbushes, Wodgina and Tanco, resources, production history, processing, recycling, the iTSCi program, mine-site pollution.
-
attributed to rebel forces waging a civil war in Congo (Kinshasa) has been of recent concern
-
artisanal mining accounted for 29 percent
-
were above the threshold effect concentrations for aquatic organisms … but below probable effect concentrations
-
the overall goal being to provide a way to exclude illegal columbite-tantalite from the conventional market while discerning legitimate small-scale artisanal mine productio
-
- 2
U.S. Geological Survey (D.I. Bleiwas, J.F. Papp, T.R. Yager), 2015. Shifts in Global Tantalum Supply, 2000–2014 (Fact Sheet 2015–3079) .
The shift of tantalum mining from Australia and Brazil to Congo (Kinshasa) and Rwanda, how the ore is traded, the Dodd-Frank Act, and claims of smuggling.
-
at least some portion of Rwanda’s reported production for the period analyzed originated from concentrates smuggled across the border from conflict areas in North Kivu and South Kivu
-
they could allegedly sell to Chinese or other buyers at an approximately 30 to 60 percent discount
-
- 3
Argus Media, 12 February 2026, 2026. How the Rubaya mine collapse impacts global tantalum supply .
The Rubaya collapse and its effect on prices, M23 control of Rubaya, UN findings on smuggling, trade flows to China and the United States, new supply from lithium mines, the sale of Taboca.
-
M23 took control of Rubaya in late April 2024 and much of the surrounding Masisi territory in North Kivu
-
The taxation and sale of this material could raise as much at $800,000/month to fund M23
-
major tech companies such as Apple that have urged their supply chains to avoid sourcing from central Africa
-
disengaging from central Africa raises its own issues
-
As a result of the muddied due diligence
-
- 4
Reuters, 31 January 2026, as published by TimesLIVE, 2026. More than 200 killed in coltan mine collapse in eastern DRC, official says .
The death toll at Rubaya, its share of world coltan, how the miners work, and the UN claim and Rwanda's denial.
-
whose stated aim is to overthrow the government in Kinshasa and ensure the safety of the Congolese Tutsi minority
-
The UN says AFC/M23 has plundered Rubaya’s riches to help fund its insurgency, backed by the government of neighbouring Rwanda, an allegation Kigali denies
-
The site, where locals dig manually for a few dollars per day
-
More than 200 people were killed this week in a collapse at the Rubaya coltan mine
-
the precise toll was still unclear on Friday evening
-
An adviser to the governor said the number of confirmed dead was at least 227
-
- 5
Associated Press (Monika Pronczuk), 4 July 2025, as published by WSLS, 2025. UN experts say Rwanda supported rebels in Congo and smuggled minerals at 'unprecedented levels' .
The UN group of experts on coltan from the M23-controlled Rubaya mines, and Rwanda's denial.
-
The report said that smuggling of coltan, considered a critical mineral, from M23-controlled territories in recent months reached
-
These minerals were then mixed with production of Rwandan origin and exported downstream
-
Rwanda has denied any involvement
-
with more than 7 million people displaced
-
- 6
Amnesty International, 21 September 2026, 2026. DRC: M23 fighters abused miners and trafficked gold and coltan to Rwanda .
Abuses of miners by M23 at Rubaya, trafficking of coltan to Rwanda, and Amnesty's call on the US and EU about mining deals.
-
M23 violations including summary killings, torture and ill-treatment, arbitrary detention, forced labour
-
while facilitating the trafficking of gold and coltan to neighbouring Rwanda with the help of Rwandan authorities
-
Neither M23 nor Rwandan government officials responded to Amnesty International’s request for comment
-
not to establish any mining agreements involving the Rubaya mine or other M23-controlled mines in the DRC unless international human rights observers
-
- 7
BBC News (Emery Makumeno), 5 March 2026, 2026. DR Congo government says 200 killed after landslide at rebel-held mine .
The second landslide at Rubaya in March 2026, the two accounts of the toll, and Rubaya on the list of assets offered to the United States.
-
More than 200 people, including 70 children, have been killed
-
the mines ministry blamed the tragedy on M23 rebels and said they were allowing illegal mining without proper safety standards
-
the collapse was caused by attacks from government forces and only six had died
-
The BBC was unable to independently verify the death toll
-
according to the Reuters news agency
-
The Rubaya mining site was recently added to a shortlist of assets that is being offered to the US by the Congolese government
-
- 8
Bellingcat, 12 May 2026, 2026. DRC's Coltan Belt: Verifying Deadly Landslides at Mines Under M23 Control .
At least four reported landslides at Rubaya in early 2026, checked with satellite images and videos.
-
Since the beginning of 2026, at least four landslides are reported to have
-
- 9
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of International Labor Affairs, 3 April 2012, 2012. US Department of Labor releases updated list of goods produced by child labor and forced labor .
The addition of coltan and cassiterite from Congo (Kinshasa) to the US list of goods that may be made with forced or indentured child labor.
-
cassiterite and coltan from the Democratic Republic of the Congo … might have been mined, produced or manufactured by forced or indentured child labor
-
- 10
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of International Labor Affairs, online list, read 2026-10-14, 2026. List of Goods Produced by Child Labor or Forced Labor .
The current entry for tantalum ore (coltan) from Congo (Kinshasa). Read in a browser; the page gives no date for the entry.
-
There are reports that children ages 5-17 are forced to work in the production of coltan, or tantalum ore, in some mines in the Democratic Republic of the Congo
-
- 11
Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Tantalum (Periodic Table) , Uses and properties; History; podcast transcript (John Whitfield).
Discovery, the name, capacitors, implants, tantalum in phones.
-
made tantalum one of those raw materials that fuel and provoke conflict
-
leading to some people talking about ‘blood tantalum’
-
- 12
Reuters, 17 December 2024, as published by the Daily Nation, 2024. Congo files criminal complaints against Apple in Europe over conflict minerals .
The complaints of Congo (Kinshasa) against Apple subsidiaries, and the dispute between the Responsible Minerals Initiative and iTSCi.
-
The RMI, whose members include more than 500 companies, announced in 2022 it was
-
from its list of approved traceability schemes
-
ITSCI criticised the RMI’s own processes and
-
Apple uses minerals pillaged from Congo and laundered through international supply chains
-
- 13
Reuters, 28 February 2025, as published by Engineering News, 2025. Paris prosecutor drops case against Apple over Congo minerals, document shows .
Apple's response to the complaints, the end of the French case, and the Belgian investigating magistrate.
-
Apple said then it strongly disputed the allegations and had told its suppliers they must not use the minerals in question sourced from Congo or Rwanda
-
not sufficiently well-founded
-
Belgium appointed an investigating magistrate in response
-