Sodium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Salt taxes and monopolies caused protest for centuries, as in India in 1930. Today the main problems are local. Examples are salt mining under the city of Maceió in Brazil and low pay for salt farmers in India. There is also a debate on how much salt people should eat.
Last updated 5 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Governments have taxed and controlled salt for a long time, because everyone needs it. In 1930, Mahatma Gandhi led a march of 387 km to Dandi in India, in protest against the British salt laws1. France ended its salt tax, the gabelle, for the last time in 19452. China has had a state salt monopoly, in some form, for more than 2,000 years. It started to open the market in 20173. A Shanghai lawyer who works on salt cases did not agree that the monopoly had ended: “The monopoly is still on, and it is improper”3.
In 2007 and 2008, the two Western makers of sodium metal accused each other of dumping4. DuPont said that French sodium was sold in the United States below fair value4. At the request of MSSA, the European Commission opened two trade investigations of DuPont. MSSA said DuPont sold below market prices in Europe and received electricity subsidies4. The dispute ended without lasting government action5.
Workers and communities
In India, families called Agariyas make salt by hand in the Little Rann of Kutch. In 2021, the International Finance Corporation (IFC) reported that they earned about 150 rupees ($2.10) per tonne of salt. The market price was about 17,000 rupees per tonne6. The IFC does not say which market price this is, or if it includes refining and packing. The IFC says intermediaries take most of the money, and diesel for the brine pumps takes about 60% of a family’s income6. A women’s union, SEWA, and a bank now give low-cost loans to its 15,000 salt farmer members6.
In Maceió, Brazil, salt was mined under the city from 1976 through 35 mine shafts7. After heavy rains in February 2018, large cracks appeared in floors and walls7. Brazil’s Geological Survey linked the damage to the salt mining8. More than 14,000 buildings were declared unfit to live in, and more than 60,000 people had to leave their homes7. Braskem says that it stopped mining after the events of 20187.
Who gains and who loses
In Maceió, Braskem reached a settlement with public prosecutors in January 2020. By March 2024, the company had made 19,129 compensation offers, and 18,256 were accepted7. Many residents say the sums were too low and were not negotiated7. In a Dutch court, Braskem called its program the most beneficial possible7.
Road salt keeps roads open in winter, but people near the roads carry some of the cost. Salt from roads often collects in lakes and other fresh water. It can change the water chemistry and affect the people who use this water8.
In 2015, Chemours said that 200 jobs would go when it closed the last US sodium metal plant, at Niagara Falls, in December 20165. The French producer said it would supply the former customers5.
Public debate
There is a public debate on how much salt is too much. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends less than 2,000 mg of sodium a day for adults. In 2021, adults ate on average 4,278 mg a day9. The WHO links about 1.7 million deaths a year to too much sodium9.
The PURE study followed 94,000 people in 18 countries. Its authors found higher risk of heart disease and stroke only where average intake was more than 5 grams of sodium a day10. Other researchers criticized the study. Francesco Cappuccio of the University of Warwick said it “is not fit to address any of the issues regarding salt consumption and cardiovascular outcomes”11. One criticism is that spot urine samples do not measure salt intake well11.
Sources
- 1
Wikipedia contributors, 2026. Salt March .
Dates and length of Gandhi's Salt March of 1930.
-
The march spanned 387 kilometres (240 mi) , from Sabarmati Ashram to Dandi
-
- 2
Wikipedia contributors, 2026. Gabelle .
The French salt tax and its abolition.
-
ultimately abolished in 1945
-
- 3
Associated Press, via Voice of America, 2017. China Begins to Ease Its 2,000-Year-Old Monopoly on Salt .
China's 2017 reform of the state salt monopoly.
-
China has started an overhaul of its salt industry, easing a monopoly that has existed in some form for more than 2,000 years
-
The monopoly is still on, and it is improper
-
- 4
Ann M. Thayer, Chemical & Engineering News (vol. 86, issue 43), 2008. Having The Mettle For Sodium Markets .
World demand for sodium metal, the producers, prices and the 2007-2008 trade dispute between MSSA and DuPont.
-
the two Western firms are accusing each other of dumping sodium by selling it at cut-rate prices
-
alleging that French imports were being sold at less than fair market value relative to the cost of production
-
In August, at the company’s behest, the European Commission began two trade investigations of DuPont … DuPont is selling sodium in Europe at lower than market prices and is receiving unfair subsidies for electricity
-
- 5
Chemical & Engineering News (vol. 93, issue 48), 2015. Chemours Restructuring To End U.S. Production Of Sodium Metal .
Closure of the last US sodium metal plant at Niagara Falls.
-
After U.S. and European investigations, the tiff ended without any lasting government actions
-
An additional 200 jobs will go when Chemours shuts the Niagara Falls metals operation in December 2016
-
his firm will be able to meet demand from former Chemours customers
-
- 6
International Finance Corporation (World Bank Group), 2021. Harvesting Stability for India's Salt Farmers .
Work, income and debt of salt farmers in the Little Rann of Kutch, India.
-
These salt farmers earn an average of only 150 Indian rupees ($2.10) per ton of salt … the market price is 17,000 Indian rupees per ton ($239)
-
Exploitative intermediaries pocket most of their earnings. Moreover, the average family spends about 60 percent of its annual income on diesel
-
a low-cost credit channel that is now available to the entire community of 15,000 women salt farmers who are SEWA members
-
- 7
Mongabay, 2024. In Brazil, half a century of salt mining sinks a city, displacing thousands .
Ground subsidence above Braskem's salt mines in Maceió, displacement and compensation.
-
Since extraction started in 1976, the city has been pierced by 35 mine shafts
-
Following heavy rains in February 2018, large cracks appeared in floors and walls
-
more than 14,000 premises, including homes, companies, churches and schools, have been declared unfit for habitation in the five suburbs. More than 60,000 inhabitants were forced to leave their homes
-
Following the events in 2018, Braskem stopped extracting and presented a permanent closure plan that was accepted by the national mining authorities
-
In January 2020, Braskem reached a settlement with public prosecutors … The company had issued 19,129 compensation proposals, of which 18,256 were accepted
-
those affected complain that Braskem has offered them meager amounts, with no negotiation
-
it presented the compensation program as the most beneficial possible
-
- 8
U.S. Geological Survey (W.P. Bolen), 2025. Salt, in 2019 Minerals Yearbook (advance release) , Pp. 63.1-63.4: production, consumption, prices, transportation, world review.
Types of salt and how each is made, end uses, chlorine production ratio, transport costs, world review for 2019.
-
Brazil’s Geological Survey determined there was a link between salt mining operations and geological damage in the vicinity of the salt mining
-
it often collects in lakes and other inland freshwater bodies, potentially changing water chemistry and affecting ecosystems and communities that use this water
-
- 9
World Health Organization, 2025. Sodium reduction (fact sheet) .
Global sodium intake, the WHO recommendation and the policies WHO recommends.
-
The global mean intake of adults was 4278 mg/day sodium (equivalent to 11 g/day salt) in 2021 (1) . This is more than double the World Health Organization recommendation for adults of less than 2000 mg/day sodium
-
An estimated 1.7 million deaths each year were associated with consuming too much sodium in 2023
-
- 10
Population Health Research Institute (McMaster University and Hamilton Health Sciences), 2018. THE LANCET Publishes Sodium Results of PURE Study .
The PURE study authors' summary of their 2018 sodium results.
-
found there an associated risk of cardiovascular disease and strokes only where the average intake is greater than five grams of sodium a day
-
- 11
Science Media Centre, 2018. expert reaction to study looking at salt consumption and health risks .
Criticism of the PURE sodium study by other researchers.
-
is not fit to address any of the issues regarding salt consumption and cardiovascular outcomes
-
There are methods to estimate 24h salt excretion from morning or spot urine samples, such as those used in this study, but they are known to be unreliable
-