Selenium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Selenium from coal mines in British Columbia flows down the Elk River into Montana and Idaho. Teck Coal was fined C$60 million in 2021; Glencore now owns the mines. In 2024 Canada and the United States asked the International Joint Commission to study the problem.

Last updated 10 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

In 2021 Teck ran metallurgical coal mines in the Elk Valley of British Columbia1. Teck later sold the mines. Glencore now owns them, and its company Elk Valley Resources runs them2. Pollution from these coal mines flows down the rivers3. The Elk River runs into Lake Koocanusa, on the Kootenai River, which flows through Montana and Idaho4.

In May 2022 the International Joint Commission wrote to the Canadian prime minister and the US president. A treaty of 1909 set up the commission. The two countries look to it to prevent and resolve disputes about waters along the border4. It said that selenium contamination was causing more and more conflict4.

The letter gave the standard of Idaho and Montana for dissolved selenium: 0.8 micrograms per liter. Measurements had reached 9.46 micrograms per liter in the Elk River and 4.99 in Lake Koocanusa4.

The Montana standard for Lake Koocanusa was itself in dispute. The owners of the coal mines said that it was stricter than the federal guideline. The Montana Department of Environmental Quality said that it was necessary to protect aquatic life2. In April 2026 a Montana district judge upheld the standard2.

In March 2024 the two governments asked the commission for a two-year study and solutions3. The request followed ten years of advocacy by the Ktunaxa Nation. The Ktunaxa Nation includes First Nations in British Columbia and tribes in Montana and Idaho3.

The study took longer than planned. The study board gave an interim report in late 2025. In September 2026 it moved its final recommendations to 5 February 20275.

Glencore plans to extend the Fording River mine. Tribal governments want no new or larger open-pit coal mines in the watershed until the effects of existing pollution are understood and remedied. Elk Valley Resources says that the provincial and federal assessments of the project have been comprehensive. It also says that it is making significant progress on its water quality plan5.

Workers and communities

In March 2021 a British Columbia court fined Teck Coal C$60 million. Teck pleaded guilty to two charges about selenium and calcite from its Fording River and Greenhills mines in 2012. The Narwhal reported it as the largest penalty ever under the federal Fisheries Act1.

Downstream of the mines, the Upper Fording River held 9 to 90 parts per billion of selenium. Upstream it held less than 11. Officers found selenium in westslope cutthroat trout high enough to cause harm1.

  • The Ktunaxa Nation Council called the fine a step in acknowledging harm done to the land and water without Ktunaxa consent1.
  • Teck’s chief executive, Don Lindsay, apologized and took responsibility. He said Teck had invested about C$1 billion in a water quality plan1.
  • Wildsight is a conservation group in the Kootenay region. Its mining lead, Lars Sander-Green, compared the fine with Teck’s coal revenue of more than C$4.5 billion in 2012. He said the fine may not do much to discourage more pollution1.

Who gains and who loses

The selenium in these disputes does not come from selenium production. It comes from coal mines, coal ash and farm drainage, as at Belews Lake in North Carolina and Kesterson in California.

Some places gain from added selenium. In 1984 Finland decided to add selenium to fertilizers. The goal was enough selenium for people and farm animals6. Intake rose from 30 to 40 micrograms a day to more than 100 by the early 1990s7.

Sources

  1. 1

    Ainslie Cruickshank, The Narwhal, 2021. Teck fined $60 million for water pollution in B.C.'s Elk Valley .

    The Fisheries Act fine, selenium levels in the Fording River, statements by the Ktunaxa Nation Council, Teck and Wildsight.

    • the Elk Valley, where the company operates metallurgical coal mines
    • In the largest penalty ever issued for Fisheries Act offences, Teck Coal Limited was fined $60 million by the Provincial Court of British Columbia
    • pleaded guilty to two charges related to selenium and calcite pollution released from its Fording River and Greenhills mines over the course of 2012
    • ranged from 9 part per billion to 90 part per billion
    • Selenium concentrations upstream of the operations meanwhile, were less than 1 part per billion
    • detected selenium concentrations high enough to cause adverse effects
    • are steps in acknowledging the harm that has been and continues to be done to
    • We sincerely apologize and take responsibility for the impacts of these discharges
    • the company has invested about $1 billion to implement the Elk Valley Water Quality Plan
    • Lars Sander-Green, mining lead with the Kootenay-based conservation organization Wildsight
    • more than $4.5 billion in 2012 alone
    • the fine may not do much to discourage further pollution
  2. 2

    Tristan Scott, Flathead Beacon, 2026. Montana Judge Upholds Lake Koocanusa Water Quality Rule .

    The April 2026 ruling on the Montana selenium standard, the owners of the Elk Valley mines, and the stated reasons of each side. Fetched with Firecrawl because the site refused a script.

    • The coal mines were previously owned by Teck Resources Limited. Under Glencore’s ownership, the mines are operated by a spinoff company called Elk Valley Resources (EVR)
    • the Canadian coal miners have disputed the standard on the grounds that it … is more stringent than the comparable federal guideline for selenium
    • necessary to protect aquatic life from the toxic effects of selenium, and protect downstream water quality
    • On April 8, Lewis and Clark County District Judge Kathy Seeley granted a motion for summary judgment supporting DEQ’s claims as well as those of the conservation groups while denying cross motions from BER and EVR
  3. 3

    Stefan Labbé, Prince George Citizen, 2024. B.C. mining pollution referred to international commission .

    The 2024 reference to the International Joint Commission and the Ktunaxa Nation's part in it. Fetched with Firecrawl because the site refused a script.

    • Pollution flowing downriver from coal mines in British Columbia
    • Canada and the U.S. have asked the International Joint Commission to carry out a reference study and recommend solutions for mining pollution in the Elk and Kootenay rivers
    • Together, they will carry out a two-year independent study and recommend solutions to protect the waterways
    • The reference to the IJC comes after a decade of advocacy from the Ktunaxa Nation
    • a group that includes the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes, Kootenai Tribe of Idaho
  4. 4

    International Joint Commission, 2022. Letter to Prime Minister Trudeau and President Biden on selenium contamination .

    Selenium in the Elk River, Lake Koocanusa and the Kootenai River, and the Montana and Idaho standard.

    • The Elk River rises in Canada and flows into the United States at Lake Koocanusa, an impoundment of the Kootenai River which flows through the States of Montana and Idaho
    • The International Joint Commission (IJC) was created by the Boundary Waters Treaty of 1909
    • to prevent and resolve disputes regarding waters along the transboundary
    • that is causing increasing conflict between interested parties and rights holders on both sides of our shared border. This issue is selenium contamination of the Elk River, Lake Koocanusa, and the Kootenai River
    • The standard for dissolved selenium concentration established by the States of Idaho and Montana, and approved by the U.S. EPA, is 0.8 ug/L. Measurements of selenium have reached 9.46 ug/L in the Elk River, 4.99 ug/L in Lake Koocanusa
  5. 5

    Flathead Beacon, 2026. Elk-Kootenai Study Board Postpones Draft Report on Transboundary Coal Pollution .

    The interim report of 2025, the new date for the final recommendations, the Fording River extension and the stated positions of the tribal governments and Elk Valley Resources.

    • The board delivered an interim report to both governments in late 2025
    • pushing its recommendations to Feb. 5, 2027
    • Glencore’s proposed Fording River Extension
    • Tribal governments have long called for a moratorium on new or expanded open-pit coal mines in the transboundary watershed until the effects of existing pollution are understood and remedied
    • Elk Valley Resources says provincial and federal assessments of the project have been comprehensive and that it is making significant progress on its water quality plan
  6. 6

    Merja Eurola and Veli Hietaniemi (eds.), Agricultural Research Centre of Finland (MTT), 2000. Report of the Selenium Monitoring Programme 1997-1999 .

    Selenium in Finnish fertilizers since 1984 and the intake of Finns in 1999. In Finnish with an English summary.

    • In Finland, 1984, by resolution of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, the addition of selenium to multiple nutrient inorganic fertilizers was initiated
    • The goal of the procedure was the safeguarding of selenium acquisition for the general populace and for domestic animals
  7. 7

    U.S. Geological Survey (Lisa L. Stillings), 2017. Selenium, chapter Q of Critical Mineral Resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802-Q) .

    Discovery, history of uses, geology, by-product recovery, the US stockpile, environmental cases and health.

    • This practice has caused selenium dietary intake to increase from a base of 30 to 40 micrograms per day (µg/d) to greater than 100 µg/d by the early 1990s