Rutherfordium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Dubna and Berkeley disputed the credit for element 104 and its name. In 1993 an international working group gave credit to both1, and in 1997 IUPAC chose the Berkeley name.
Rutherfordium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →
Last updated 14 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Each laboratory disputed the other’s work. In 1969 the Berkeley team could not find the 0.3-second activity that Dubna had reported. On that basis it claimed priority1. Dubna authors, in turn, compared Berkeley’s results with their own experiment on a lead target. They concluded that the Berkeley results could not be trusted1.
The Transfermium Working Group of IUPAC and IUPAP judged both claims. It rejected the Dubna criticism of the Berkeley work1. It also wrote that, by then, scientists generally accepted that the 0.3-second isotope reported by Dubna does not exist1. But it accepted the Dubna chemistry. In 1993 it found that the two laboratories did their work at about the same time, and that credit should be shared1.
Both laboratories answered in 1992. Albert Ghiorso and Glenn Seaborg, of Berkeley, rejected the shared credit2. They wrote that the Dubna chloride experiments were an “untenable alternate claim” after the 0.3-second activity proved wrong2. They asked for the Berkeley name2. Yu. Ts. Oganessian and I. Zvara, of Dubna, wrote that, in their view, the group underestimated some Dubna papers on element 104. They also wrote that Dubna would respect the decision2. In 1993 the members of the working group replied that the Berkeley criticisms did not change their conclusions2.
The name took four more years. In 1994 an IUPAC commission accepted neither kurchatovium nor rutherfordium. It recommended dubnium for element 1043. In 1997 the commission named element 105 dubnium, to honor the Dubna laboratory. It gave element 104 the Berkeley name, rutherfordium4. The commission wrote that Berkeley had already been recognized more than once4.
Workers and communities
Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with rutherfordium, one atom at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from rutherfordium.
Who gains and who loses
Sources
- 1
IUPAC/IUPAP Transfermium Working Group (R. C. Barber, N. N. Greenwood, A. Z. Hrynkiewicz, Y. P. Jeannin, M. Lefort, M. Sakai, I. Ulehla, A. H. Wapstra and D. H. Wilkinson); Pure and Applied Chemistry 65(8), 1757-1814, 1993. Discovery of the transfermium elements , Part III, Element Z = 104, pp. 1776-1783.
The working group's assessment of the Dubna and Berkeley papers on element 104, the proposed names, and its verdict that the credit is shared.
-
The Berkeley authors do not find the 0.3 s (or 0.1 s) SF activity reported in earlier Dubna work. The authors therefore claim priority
-
The Dubna authors therefore conclude that the results for the latter cannot be trusted either.
-
On the basis of present day knowledge, these criticisms must be rejected
-
now generally accepted fact that no 0.3 s SF isotope of
-
were essentially contemporaneous and each show that element 104 had been produced. Credit should be shared.
-
each show that element 104 had been produced. Credit should be shared.
-
- 2
A. Ghiorso and G. T. Seaborg (Berkeley), Yu. Ts. Oganessian and I. Zvara (Dubna), the GSI group, and the Transfermium Working Group; Pure and Applied Chemistry 65 (1993) 1815-1824, 1993. Responses on the report 'Discovery of the transfermium elements' , Section I (Berkeley), element Z = 104 and summary; Section II (Dubna); Section IV (TWG reply).
Berkeley's and Dubna's views of the working group's conclusions on element 104, and the working group's reply. The text in the quote cache is from Firecrawl copies of the full PDF.
-
we cannot–indeed, in all honesty, should not–accept the TWG CONCLUSION
-
erroneously accepted their untenable alternate claim (the chloride volatility experiments) to the discovery of element 104
-
Our suggested name for element 104, should be adopted.
-
It seems to us that the TWG conclusions underestimate the importance of some Dubna papers on the elements 103, 104 and 105. But we have agreed to cooperate with the TWG
-
After detailed examination of all the criticisms from Berkeley we do not find it necessary in any way to change the conclusions of our report.
-
- 3
M. Thoennessen, National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory, Michigan State University (preprint for Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables), 2012. Discovery of Isotopes of Elements with Z ≥ 100 , arXiv:1203.2105v1, section 6, Discovery of 253-267 Rf.
The dates of the Dubna and Berkeley papers, the names, the IUPAC decisions of 1994 and 1997, and the discovery of each isotope.
-
In 1994, the Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry of IUPAC did not accept either suggestion and recommended dubnium instead
-
the Dubna group suggested the name kurchatovium (Ku) while the Berkeley group suggested rutherfordium (Rf)
-
- 4
IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 69(12), 2471-2473, 1997. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1997) , pp. 2472-2473 and the table of names and symbols.
The approved name and symbol of element 104, and the reasons the commission gave for the names of elements 104 and 105. The text in the quote cache is the full PDF, read in a browser for another element.
-
The Commission recommended that element 105 should be named dubnium in its honour … Finally, the Commission accepted the name rutherfordium for element 104
-
The Berkeley laboratory has … already been similarly recognized on more than one occasion.
-
104 rutherfordium Rf
-