Roentgenium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
We found no rival claim for element 111 and no dispute about the name. The only dispute that we found is about roentgenium in nature. A later search did not confirm a 2007 report of roentgenium in natural gold5.
Roentgenium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →
Last updated 15 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
We found no rival claim for element 111. In 2003 the IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party reviewed claims for elements 111 to 118. Of the new claims, only the GSI claim for element 111 met the criteria for discovery1. The working party also confirmed again its 2001 decision on element 1102.
In 2001 the working party called the GSI results of high quality, but asked for more data. It found too little internal redundancy, that is, too few matching results within the data2. It gave the credit in 2003 without an independent confirmation from another laboratory. It wrote that the decision rested on the quality of the work and on known nuclei in the decay chains2. In 2004 a RIKEN team called its own results the first clear confirmation3.
In 2007 Amnon Marinov and colleagues reported evidence of roentgenium isotopes in natural gold4. In 2011 a team at the University of Vienna searched gold with a different method and saw no events5. The Vienna team wrote that such results need independent checks by other methods5.
Workers and communities
Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with roentgenium, one atom at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from roentgenium.
Who gains and who loses
We found no source on income from roentgenium. GSI lists roentgenium among the six elements that it discovered and that IUPAC recognized6.
Sources
- 1
J. Corish and G. M. Rosenblatt, IUPAC Inorganic Chemistry Division; Pure and Applied Chemistry 76(12), 2101-2103, 2004. Name and symbol of the element with atomic number 111 (IUPAC Recommendations 2004) .
The proposal of the name by the discoverers, the reasons for it, and its adoption on 1 November 2004. Read with Firecrawl; the publisher refuses scripts.
-
concluded that the criteria for discovery of an element had been fulfilled onlyin the case of element 111 and this by the collaboration of Hofmann et al.
-
- 2
P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, B. W. Petley and E. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 75(10), 1601-1611, 2003. On the claims for discovery of elements 110, 111, 112, 114, 116, and 118 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Element 111, items 111;01 to 111;03, the Comments and the Summary.
The assessment of 2001 and the decision of 2003 on element 111. Read with Firecrawl; the publisher refuses scripts.
-
revisited, by necessity, and reaffirmed the previously accepted
-
The results of the collaboration of Hofmann et al. are definitely of high qual-ity but there is insufficient internal redundancy to warrant certitude at this stage.
-
Elements 110 and 111 have been reviewed and assigned priority of discovery despite lack of inde-pendent confirmation of the isotopes observed.
-
previously characterized nuclideswere identified as part of the detection sequence(s)
-
- 3
K. Morita, K. Morimoto, D. Kaji and others, RIKEN; Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 73(7), 1738-1744 (record in the Houston Methodist research portal), 2004. Production and decay properties of 272111 and its daughter nuclei (abstract) , Abstract.
The 14 decay chains of roentgenium-272 at RIKEN and the authors' statement that this is the first clear confirmation of the GSI discovery. The publisher refuses scripts; the abstract was read in the Houston Methodist research portal, which holds the full record of the paper.
-
The present result is the first clear confirmation for the discovery of
-
- 4
A. Marinov, I. Rodushkin, A. Pape, Y. Kashiv, D. Kolb, R. Brandt, R. V. Gentry, H. W. Miller, L. Halicz and I. Segal (arXiv preprint, 20 February 2007; later in International Journal of Modern Physics E 18, 621, 2009), 2007. Existence of long-lived isotopes of a superheavy element in natural Au , Abstract and first page.
The claim of roentgenium isotopes with mass numbers 261 and 265 in natural gold, from mass spectrometry.
-
The measured masses fit the predictions made for the masses of 261 Rg and 265 Rg (Z=111)
-
- 5
F. Dellinger, W. Kutschera, O. Forstner, R. Golser, A. Priller, P. Steier, A. Wallner and G. Winkler, VERA Laboratory, University of Vienna; Physical Review C 83, 015801 (copy hosted by the University of Vienna), 2011. Upper limits for the existence of long-lived isotopes of roentgenium in natural gold , Abstract and section I.
The search for roentgenium in natural gold with accelerator mass spectrometry, the limits found, and the comparison with the Marinov claim.
-
abundance limits in gold of 3×10⁻¹⁶ were reached (no events observed)
-
these extraordinary results certainly need independent verification by other experimental techniques
-
This is in stark contrast to the findings of Marinov et al.
-
- 6
GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung, 2026. History of GSI: milestones .
GSI discovered six elements, bohrium to copernicium, from 1981.
-
Discovery of six new chemical elements and their official recognization by IUPAC in the Periodic Table of the Elements
-