Phosphorus: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
The largest dispute is over Western Sahara, where Morocco mines phosphate in a territory whose status is not settled. Nauru grew rich from phosphate and then lost most of its land to mining. Water pollution and white phosphorus weapons are also debated.
Last updated 5 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Western Sahara is the main conflict linked to phosphate. The UN has listed it as a non-self-governing territory since 1963. Morocco has controlled most of it since 1975 and considers it Moroccan1. The Polisario Front claims independence for the territory2. A UN mission, MINURSO, was set up in 19911.
Positions changed in the 2020s. In December 2020 the United States recognized Moroccan sovereignty over all of Western Sahara3. In October 2025 the UN Security Council called on the parties to negotiate on the basis of Morocco’s 2007 autonomy proposal4. The same resolution asks for a solution that provides for the self-determination of the people of Western Sahara4.
The Boucraâ mine is in Western Sahara. OCP and its subsidiary Phosboucraa say they run it under Moroccan law and in line with international law5. The Polisario Front and the Sahrawi government do not share this view5.
In May 2017 South Africa detained a ship with 55,000 tonnes of phosphate from the territory. The cargo was bound for New Zealand6. In 2018 the High Court of South Africa ruled that the Sahrawi Republic (SADR) owned the cargo6. OCP called the case in South Africa an act of political piracy under judicial cover5.
Nauru took Australia to the International Court of Justice in 1989. It asked for the restoration of land mined before independence7. The two states settled in 19937.
Workers and communities
In the 19th century, match workers got ‘phossy jaw’ from white phosphorus. The disease slowly destroyed the jaw bone8. In 1888 Annie Besant organized the London matchgirls’ strike against the use of phosphorus8. Red phosphorus was safer but cost more8.
Labor disputes have cut supply in North Africa and the Middle East. After the 2011 unrest in Tunisia, the Gafsa company said its output fell to 45% of the 2010 level2. In 2012 the Hague Centre for Strategic Studies reported strikes in Morocco and Jordan too2.
Near OCP’s chemical plants in Morocco, activists and residents say the operations pollute land, water and food. OCP presents its approach to sustainability as a strength9.
In Florida, the Piney Point fertilizer plant closed in 2001 and left stacks of waste behind10. In April 2021 a leak there put homes at risk of flooding, and officials evacuated about 300 homes11.
Who gains and who loses
Nauru had both the gains and the losses. Phosphate made it one of the world’s richest countries per person in the 1970s. It paid for a welfare state, royalties and a trust fund12. The same authors say revenues were mismanaged12. Mining has taken about 80% of the island, and that land is now unusable12.
Phosphate is a large export for a few countries. In 2020 it was 8.8% of Togo’s export value and 4.3% of Jordan’s1.
Who gains from Western Sahara’s phosphate is disputed. The EU applies the UN view. It says resource activities in such territories are legal if they benefit the people there or have their consent1. In October 2024 the EU Court of Justice ruled on two EU-Morocco trade agreements of 2019, on fisheries and farm products. It found that the people of Western Sahara had not consented to them, so they broke the principle of self-determination13. Some buyers have stopped. Nutrien, then about half of all purchases from the territory, said it aimed to end them14.
Public debate
One debate is whether phosphate rock will run short. Dana Cordell estimated in 2010 that production would peak before 203515. USGS says there are no imminent shortages16. The IFDC estimated that reserves can sustain output for roughly 300 years1.
Another debate is about pollution of water. Phosphate from fertilizers and detergents can make algae grow fast in rivers and lakes17. The EU limited phosphates in household detergents to reduce this risk and the cost of removing them at sewage plants18.
Military use of white phosphorus is also argued over. Human Rights Watch says it is not a chemical weapon, because it harms mainly by heat and flame19. The group says burns on only 10% of the body are often fatal19.
Sources
- 1
SCRREEN2 (EU Horizon 2020 project), 2023. SCRREEN2 factsheets updates based on the EU factsheets 2020: Phosphate rock and elemental phosphorus , Uses; Supply from secondary materials; Primary supply; Geological occurrence.
World uses of phosphate rock, elemental phosphorus production, the EU recycling input rate, deposits, mining and processing.
-
have been listing Western Sahara as Non-Self-Governing Territories since 1963. Starting from 1975 on … has been controlling the largest part of the former Spanish colony which it considers … to be Moroccan territory
-
the UN Mission (MINURSO 1991)) was established in 1991
-
Togo (8.8 %), Jordan (4.3 %) and Morocco (2.8 %)
-
where resource exploitation activities are conducted in non-self governing territories for the benefit of the people of those territories, on their behalf or in consultation with their representatives, they are considered as legal
-
current reserves can sustain output for roughly 300 years
-
- 2
M. de Ridder and others, The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies, 2012. Risks and Opportunities in the Global Phosphate Rock Market , Chapter 4, political risks.
Unrest in Tunisia in 2011, labor disputes in Morocco and Jordan, and Western Sahara.
-
Western Sahara, a disputed territory where a separatist movement, the Polisario Front, claims independence from Morocco
-
Gafsa has issued tempered figures for the previous year, saying that 2011 production was only 45% of 2010 levels
-
Employment relations also remain difficult and a source of instability in Morocco and Jordan. The former has seen strikes
-
- 3
President of the United States (Federal Register vol. 85, p. 81329), 2020. Proclamation 10126: Recognizing the Sovereignty of the Kingdom of Morocco Over the Western Sahara .
US recognition of Moroccan sovereignty over Western Sahara, 4 December 2020.
-
as of today, the United States recognizes Moroccan sovereignty over the entire Western Sahara territory
-
- 4
United Nations Security Council, 2025. Security Council resolution 2797 (2025) on Western Sahara, S/RES/2797 (2025) , Paragraphs 2 and 3.
Negotiations on the basis of Morocco's autonomy proposal; MINURSO extended to 31 October 2026.
-
Calls upon the parties to engage in these discussions without preconditions, taking as basis Morocco’s Autonomy Proposal
-
a final and mutually acceptable political solution that provides for the self … determination of the people of Western Sahara
-
- 5
Dominic Dudley, Forbes, 2017. Activists Claims Victory As Morocco Pulls Out of Court Case Over Controversial Phosphate Exports .
The positions of OCP and of the Polisario Front on the Western Sahara cargoes.
-
OCP and Phosboucraa say they operate the Boucraa mine under Moroccan law and in full conformity and compliance with international law
-
That is not a view shared by the Polisario Front or the Saharawi government
-
OCP said it considered the situation in South Africa … to be an act of political piracy committed under judicial cover
-
- 6
RNZ, 2018. Court rules detained phosphate may be sold .
The NM Cherry Blossom cargo and the South African court ruling.
-
A shipment of phosphate that was bound for New Zealand … The 55,000 tonne shipment was detained in Port Elizabeth in May last year
-
The High Court of South Africa has now ruled that SADR is the owner of the whole cargo of phosphate
-
- 7
International Court of Justice, 2026. Certain Phosphate Lands in Nauru (Nauru v. Australia): overview of the case .
The 1989 application, the 1992 judgment on preliminary objections and the 1993 settlement.
-
On 19 May 1989 the Republic of Nauru filed in the Registry of the Court an Application instituting proceedings against the Commonwealth of Australia in respect of a dispute concerning the rehabilitation of certain phosphate lands mined under Australian administration before Nauruan independence
-
by a joint notification deposited on 9 September 1993, informed the Court that they had, in consequence of having reached a settlement, agreed to discontinue the proceedings
-
- 8
Susan Isaac, Royal College of Surgeons of England, 2018. 'Phossy jaw' and the matchgirls: a nineteenth-century industrial disease .
Phossy jaw, the 1888 matchgirls' strike and the bans on white phosphorus matches.
-
By 1858, detailed medical reports of a disease involving the slow progression of exposed jaw bone started to appear
-
Annie Besant organised the London matchgirls … strike in 1888, protesting against the use of phosphorus in the manufacturing process
-
The disease could be prevented by using the safer but more expensive red phosphorous
-
- 9
Follow the Money, 2025. Pollution, poverty, protests: On the toxic trail of Morocco's phosphate giant .
Phosphogypsum discharge into the Atlantic, and the views of residents and of OCP. Part of the article is behind a paywall; we used only the open part.
-
OCP hails its approach to sustainability, yet activists and locals say its operations are polluting land, water, and food sources
-
- 10
Tampa Bay Estuary Program, 2026. Piney Point Monitoring .
The 2021 release of wastewater from the Piney Point phosphogypsum stack.
-
the plant produced fertilizer for decades until it was abandoned in 2001, leaving in place phosphogypsum stacks holding millions of gallons of wastewater
-
- 11
Thompson Earth Systems Institute, Florida Museum of Natural History, 2022. A Timeline of the Piney Point Wastewater Disaster .
Dates of the Piney Point plant's history and the April 2021 evacuation.
-
April 2021: Responding to the risk of catastrophic flooding … 300 homes
-
- 12
M.J. Clifford, S.H. Ali and others (Ambio 48: 397-408), 2019. Mining, land restoration and sustainable development in isolated islands: An industrial ecology perspective on extractive transitions on Nauru .
Share of Nauru mined, the wealth of the 1970s and the later decline.
-
phosphates made Nauru one of the world’s richest countries per capita during the 1970s, allowing the establishment of a welfare state, substantial royalty payments amongst the population and foundation of a trust fund for future generations
-
Revenues were mismanaged
-
80% of Nauru has been mined for phosphate, leaving pinnacles of limestone that occur alongside phosphate rock, making this land unusable
-
- 13
Court of Justice of the European Union, 2024. Press release No 170/24: Judgments in Joined Cases C-778/21 P and C-798/21 P and C-779/21 P and C-799/21 P, Commission and Council v Front Polisario .
The 2019 EU-Morocco agreements on fisheries and farm products were concluded without the consent of the people of Western Sahara.
-
the 2019 EU-Morocco trade agreements regarding fisheries and agricultural products, to which the people of Western Sahara did not consent, were concluded in breach of the principles of self
-
- 14
Sustainalytics, 2018. Battle over Western Sahara is moving into court rooms .
Buyers of phosphate from Western Sahara and the Nutrien decision.
-
This new company, which accounts for about half of the global purchases of phosphate from WS, announced shortly after its creation that its goal is to end all imports from WS
-
- 15
D. Cordell, doctoral thesis, Linköping University, 2010. The Story of Phosphorus: Sustainability implications of global phosphorus scarcity for food security , Abstract; chapters 2 and 5.
The peak phosphorus estimate, the history of fertilizer and the 2008 price spike.
-
This thesis estimates peak phosphorus to occur before 2035
-
- 16
S.M. Jasinski, U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Phosphate Rock, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , World Mine Production and Reserves table; Events, Trends, and Issues; World Resources.
World mine production and reserves of phosphate rock for 2024 and 2025; US production, prices and trade.
-
There are no imminent shortages of phosphate rock
-
- 17
Royal Society of Chemistry, 2026. Phosphorus, in Periodic Table , Uses; Biological role; Natural abundance; History.
Discovery by Brandt, the name, biological role, uses and the main production route.
-
Over-use of phosphates from fertilisers and detergents can cause them to pollute rivers and lakes causing algae to grow rapidly
-
- 18
European Parliament and Council of the EU, 2012. Regulation (EU) No 259/2012 on phosphates in consumer laundry and dishwasher detergents (recitals) , Recital 1.
The stated reason for the limits on phosphates in detergents.
-
to reduce the contribution of phosphates from detergents to eutrophication risks and to reduce the cost of phosphates removal in waste water treatment plants
-
- 19
Human Rights Watch, 2023. Questions and Answers on Israel's Use of White Phosphorus in Gaza and Lebanon .
Military uses of white phosphorus, its legal status and the injuries it causes.
-
It is not considered a chemical weapon because it operates primarily by heat and flame rather than toxicity
-
White phosphorus burns on only 10 percent of a human body are often fatal
-