Meitnerium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
The discovery itself was not disputed. The public debate is about the person behind the name. Lise Meitner helped explain fission, but the 1944 Nobel Prize for its discovery went to Otto Hahn alone5.
Meitnerium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →
Last updated 15 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
Element 109 had no rival claim. A team at Dubna ran the same reaction, and the 1993 working group counted its results as a confirmation of the Darmstadt work1. In 1997 IUPAC called the discoveries of elements 108 and 109 by Darmstadt uncontested2.
The names of elements 101 to 109 were disputed from 1994 to 1997 (see the superheavy elements page). The name meitnerium was not part of the dispute. In 1994 all 20 members of the IUPAC commission voted for it, and in 1997 IUPAC accepted it again32.
Workers and communities
Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with meitnerium, one atom at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from meitnerium.
Who gains and who loses
We found no source on income from meitnerium. GSI lists meitnerium among the six elements that it discovered and that IUPAC recognized4.
Public debate
The debate concerns Lise Meitner. In November 1945 the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences gave the 1944 Nobel Prize in Chemistry to Otto Hahn for the discovery of fission56. The historians Elisabeth Crawford, Ruth Lewin Sime and Mark Walker read the files of the Nobel committees. In 1997 they wrote that the award “was and still remains controversial”, because Strassmann and Meitner were not included5.
The same authors named four factors behind Meitner’s exclusion. Among them were the difficulty of judging work across two fields and a lack of expertise in theoretical physics. They also named the isolation of Sweden during the war5. The fourth factor was that the committees did not see how far German persecution of Jews had distorted the published record5. Britannica writes that some have argued that Meitner merited a share of the prize7.
The Nobel Prize nomination archive has 49 nominations of Meitner, in physics and in chemistry. In 1946 Niels Bohr was one of five scientists who nominated her for the physics prize8. In 1966 Meitner, Hahn and Strassmann shared the US Enrico Fermi Award7.
Sources
- 1
IUPAC/IUPAP Transfermium Working Group (R. C. Barber, N. N. Greenwood, A. Z. Hrynkiewicz, Y. P. Jeannin, M. Lefort, M. Sakai, I. Ulehla, A. H. Wapstra and D. H. Wilkinson); Pure and Applied Chemistry 65(8), 1757-1814, 1993. Discovery of the transfermium elements , Part III, Element Z = 109, pp. 1792-1793, and the summary of conclusions.
The working group's assessment of the Darmstadt papers of 1982 to 1988 and the Dubna paper of 1985 on element 109, and its verdict.
-
The results agree reasonably with those of the Darmstadt group
-
- 2
IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 69(12), 2471-2473, 1997. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1997) , Recommendations, p. 2472, and the table of names and symbols, p. 2473.
The acceptance of the name meitnerium and the statement that the Darmstadt discovery is uncontested.
-
The discoveries of elements 107 (jointly by the Darmstadt and Dubna laboratories), and of 108 and 109 (by the
-
Darmstadt laboratories) are also uncontested
-
The discoverers wished to call these nielsbohrium, hassium, and meitnerium, respectively, and the Commission accepted the last two.
-
- 3
IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 66(12), 2419-2421, 1994. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1994) , Recommendations and the table of names with the votes, pp. 2420-2421.
The 1994 vote of 20 to 0 for meitnerium and the reason for the name. Read from the quote cache, which holds the text of a browser copy.
-
109 Meitnerium Mt 20
-
- 4
GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung, 2026. History of GSI: milestones .
GSI discovered six elements, bohrium to copernicium, from 1981.
-
Discovery of six new chemical elements and their official recognization by IUPAC in the Periodic Table of the Elements
-
- 5
Elisabeth Crawford, Ruth Lewin Sime and Mark Walker; Physics Today 50(9), 26 (1997), 1997. A Nobel Tale of Postwar Injustice , Summary and first paragraphs; the full text is in a PDF on the publisher's site.
The decision of November 1945 to give the 1944 chemistry prize to Hahn alone, and the authors' reasons for the exclusion of Meitner, from the documents of the Nobel committees.
-
a narrow majority of the members of the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences decided to award the 1944 Nobel Prize in Chemistry to Otto Hahn for the discovery of nuclear fission
-
The award was and still remains controversial, primarily because Hahn’s Berlin colleagues, the chemist Fritz Strassmann and the physicist Lise Meitner, were not included.
-
the difficulty of evaluating an interdisciplinary discovery, a lack of expertise in theoretical physics, Sweden’s scientific and political isolation during the war
-
a general failure of the evaluation committees to appreciate the extent to which German persecution of Jews skewed the published scientific record
-
decided to award the 1944 Nobel Prize in Chemistry to Otto Hahn for the discovery of nuclear fission
-
- 6
Nobel Prize Outreach, 2026. The Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1944 .
The prize to Otto Hahn "for his discovery of the fission of heavy nuclei", received in 1945.
-
for his discovery of the fission of heavy nuclei
-
- 7
Encyclopaedia Britannica (Britannica Editors), revised 3 November 2025, 2025. Lise Meitner .
The life of Lise Meitner, her work with Hahn, her flight in 1938, the word fission, the Fermi Award, the Manhattan Project offer and the naming of meitnerium. Read with Firecrawl; the site refuses scripts.
-
though some have argued that Meitner merited a share of the award
-
shared the Enrico Fermi Award (1966) with the chemists Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann
-
- 8
Nobel Prize Outreach, 2026. Nomination Archive: Lise Meitner .
The 49 nominations of Lise Meitner for the physics and chemistry prizes, from 1924 to 1967, and her nominators.
-
Nominee in 49 nominations
-
Physics 1946 by Niels Bohr
-