Livermorium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Berkeley withdrew its claim of 1999, and a Berkeley Lab committee found that the data were fabricated. In 2003 the first Dubna reports were not yet enough. In 2011 IUPAC and IUPAP credited the Dubna-Livermore work of 20043. The city of Livermore celebrates the element each year.

Livermorium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →

Last updated 15 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

In June 1999 a team at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory announced elements 116 and 1181. Its three decay chains of element 118 passed through element 1162. Other groups, and the Berkeley team itself, could not repeat the result. Berkeley withdrew the claim in July 20011. In 2002 a Berkeley Lab committee found clear and convincing evidence that the data had been fabricated1. The scientist denied the accusations1. The full case is on the superheavy elements page.

The Dubna claims needed more time. From 2000 the Dubna team reported one decay chain of element 116 from curium-248. The chain did not reach any known nucleus2. In 2003 the joint working party (JWP) of IUPAC and IUPAP called the work careful and of high quality. It judged that the work was not yet enough for a discovery2.

In 2011 the JWP credited the Dubna-Livermore work of 2004 on curium-245. Its chains passed through copernicium-283, a nucleus that many experiments had identified3. The JWP accepted the discovery on two chains. It noted that it had done the same for roentgenium, and that more measurements in 2006 confirmed the result3. The JWP added that the earlier reports may be confirmed in the future3.

Workers and communities

Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with livermorium, one atom at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from livermorium.

The element has a place in the life of Livermore, California. In 2013 the Livermore Chamber of Commerce honored the laboratory’s team of 11 researchers. The mayor said that 30 May is now Livermorium Day in the city4. In 2022 the city and the laboratory opened Livermorium Plaza at 116 South Livermore Avenue5. Its fountain has a floating granite sphere, five feet across, that represents the nucleus of a livermorium atom6. The city gives 18,000 pounds as the weight of the fountain and its base together7. The city celebrates Livermorium Day each year at the end of May6.

Who gains and who loses

We found no source on income from livermorium. The name honors Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory8. The partner element 114, flerovium, honors the Flerov Laboratory in Dubna8. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory writes that its scientists helped to discover six elements5.

Public debate

We found no public debate about livermorium itself. Los Alamos National Laboratory points out that Livermorium Day is on 30 May, but that livermorium was discovered in July9.

Sources

  1. 1

    Bertram M. Schwarzschild, Physics Today (American Institute of Physics), 2002. Lawrence Berkeley Lab Concludes that Evidence of Element 118 Was a Fabrication , September 2002; first section, Retraction, and Clear and convincing evidence.

    The Berkeley announcement of elements 116 and 118 in June 1999, the retraction of July 2001, the finding of fabrication, and the denial by the scientist.

    • In June 1999, the LBNL heavy-element search team announced the discovery of elements 116 and 118
    • after various experimental groups around the world, including the Berkeley team itself, were unable to reproduce the 1999 result
    • LBNL had, in fact, already retracted the element-118 discovery claim in July 2001
    • We find clear and convincing evidence that the data in 1999, upon which the reported discovery was based, were fabricated
    • emphatically denies the accusations
  2. 2

    P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, B. W. Petley and E. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 75(10), 1601-1611, 2003. On the claims for discovery of elements 110, 111, 112, 114, 116, and 118 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Sections 116;01 and 116;02.

    The first assessment of the Dubna claims for element 116, and the retracted Berkeley report.

    • leading to the observation of three chains terminating in 269Sg and passing through observedintermediate 289116
    • terminating in spontaneous fission of previously unknown
    • The decay energies and lifetimes of three events for 288114 are internally redundant, but no linkto recognized nuclei occurs.
    • The Dubna collaborations have performed careful, high-quality studieswhose acknowledgment as discoveries is unfortunately not yet warranted
  3. 3

    R. C. Barber, P. J. Karol, H. Nakahara, E. Vardaci and E. W. Vogt (IUPAC/IUPAP Joint Working Party); Pure and Applied Chemistry 83(7), 1485-1498, 2011. Discovery of the elements with atomic numbers greater than or equal to 113 (IUPAC Technical Report) , Sections 116;01 to 116;05, JWP assessment, and the summary of JWP conclusions.

    The working party's review of every Dubna report on element 116 and its credit to the Dubna-Livermore collaboration.

    • all noted with very good reproducibility to pass via the 283Cn nuclide, which serves as an established link
    • Although there are only two chains in this cited study, subsequent measurements in 2006 in the same laboratory
    • the precedent of basing discovery on two chains has already been established by the JWP in the case of Rg
    • reports may be confirmed in the future if the identity of relevant intermediate isotopes is unambiguously
    • should be credited with the discovery of the new element with
  4. 4

    Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, 2013. Livermorium team honored as dream-makers , 31 May 2013.

    The award of the Livermore Chamber of Commerce, the 11 researchers of the team, Livermorium Day on 30 May, and the date of 30 May 2012 for the name.

    • accepted the award on behalf of the 11 researchers who make up the team
    • noted that May 30 now be noted as Livermorium Day in Livermore
  5. 5

    Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, 2022. Livermorium Plaza makes its official debut , 20 June 2022.

    The dedication of Livermorium Plaza, its sphere, and the six elements that Livermore scientists helped to discover.

    • The plaza, located at 116 S. Livermore Ave., pays perpetual tribute to the Lab’s work on element 116, livermorium.
    • have been collaborators in the discovery of six elements on the periodic table
  6. 6

    Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, 2026. Livermorium Day: celebrating big ideas, team science and partnerships , 2 June 2026.

    The yearly Livermorium Day, the plaza and its granite sphere, and the laboratory's account of elements 114 and 116.

    • The focal point of the plaza is a five-foot, 18,000-lb floating granite sphere fountain representing the nucleus of a livermorium atom.
    • Each year, the city celebrates Livermorium Day at the end of May.
  7. 7

    City of Livermore, 2022. Livermorium Plaza , Page on the plaza, opened 15 June 2022.

    The opening of the plaza on 15 June 2022, and the weight of the fountain and its base. The site refuses scripts; the text was read in a browser.

    • The fountain and base, together, weigh 18,000 pounds
  8. 8

    Robert D. Loss and John Corish, IUPAC Inorganic Chemistry Division; Pure and Applied Chemistry 84(7), 1669-1672, 2012. Names and symbols of the elements with atomic numbers 114 and 116 (IUPAC Recommendations 2012) , Abstract, Introduction and Recommendation, pp. 1669-1670.

    The credit to the Dubna-Livermore collaborations, the dates of the JWP report and of adoption, and the reason for the name livermorium. The publisher refuses scripts; the text was read with Firecrawl.

    • honours the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
    • the discoverers proposed the name flerovium
  9. 9

    Los Alamos National Laboratory, 2026. Livermorium, in the Periodic Table of Elements , Sections History, Properties, Uses, Forms, Sources, Fun Facts.

    The absence in nature, the place in group 16, the predicted likeness to polonium, the lack of uses, the placeholder name, Livermorium Day and the plaza.

    • which is a little strange, because livermorium was discovered in July!