Lawrencium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

The main dispute was about credit. Berkeley reported element 103 in 1961, Dubna disputed parts of the work, and in 1993 an international working group gave credit to both2.

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

In 1961 a team at Berkeley reported element 103 and gave its mass number as 2571. In 1965 a team at the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research in Dubna, in the Soviet Union, reported lawrencium-2562. Later work could not confirm the mass number of the 1961 report2. In 1968, according to its own account, Dubna told IUPAC that the names for elements 102 and 103 were adopted too early3.

IUPAC and IUPAP, the international unions of chemistry and physics, appointed the Transfermium Working Group to judge the claims3. In 1993 it gave credit to both laboratories. It found that no single paper was conclusive2.

Albert Ghiorso and Glenn Seaborg, of Berkeley, wrote in 1992 that the review was a waste of effort3. Yu. Ts. Oganessian and I. Zvara, of Dubna, wrote that, in their view, the group underestimated some Dubna papers on element 103. They also wrote that Dubna would respect the decision3. In 1993 the members of the working group examined the criticisms from Berkeley. They saw no reason to change their conclusions3.

Workers and communities

Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with lawrencium, one atom at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from lawrencium.

Who gains and who loses

We found no source on income from lawrencium. Berkeley kept its name for the element: IUPAC approved lawrencium, with the symbol Lr, in 19974.

Sources

  1. 1

    A. Ghiorso, T. Sikkeland, A. E. Larsh and R. M. Latimer; Physical Review Letters 6 (1961) 473; record by the U.S. Department of Energy OSTI, 1961. New element, lawrencium, atomic number 103 (OSTI record) .

    The targets, the beams and the half-life of the first report. Only the record and its abstract were read, not the paper.

    • it is thought that the mass number is 257
  2. 2

    M. Thoennessen, National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory, Michigan State University (preprint for Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables), 2012. Discovery of Isotopes of Elements with Z ≥ 100 , arXiv:1203.2105v1, section 5, Discovery of 252-260 Lr.

    The Berkeley report of 1961, the Dubna work of 1965 and 1971, the verdict of the Transfermium Working Group, the name and the discovery of each isotope.

    • Four years later, Donets et al. identified 256 Lr [81].
    • The mass assignment of the original observation could later not be confirmed [82].
    • none conclusive, and referring to several isotopes, it is impossible to say other than that full confidence was built up over a decade with credit attaching to work in both Berkeley and Dubna
    • Credit for the discovery was given to both groups in 1993 by the IUPACIUPAP Transfermium Working Group
  3. 3

    A. Ghiorso and G. T. Seaborg (Berkeley), Yu. Ts. Oganessian and I. Zvara (Dubna), the GSI group, and the Transfermium Working Group; Pure and Applied Chemistry 65 (1993) 1815-1824, 1993. Responses on the report 'Discovery of the transfermium elements' , Section I (Berkeley), section II (Dubna), section IV (TWG reply).

    Each laboratory's position on elements 102 and 103, and the working group's reply. The text in the quote cache is an excerpt of a Firecrawl copy saved for nobelium on the same day.

    • as early as in 1968, basing on its own data Dubna drew the IUPAC’s attention to the fact that the adoption of names for elements 102 and 103 was hasty
    • we were invited to serve by, and were appointed by, IUPAP and by IUPAC
    • It is clearly a futile waste of effort and time to reopen the cases of elements 102 and 103
    • It seems to us that the TWG conclusions underestimate the importance of some Dubna papers on the elements 103, 104 and 105. But we have agreed to cooperate with the TWG
    • we do not find it necessary in any way to change the conclusions of our report
  4. 4

    IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 69(12), 2471-2473, 1997. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1997) , Table of names and symbols.

    The approved name and symbol of element 103. The text in the quote cache is the full PDF, read in a browser on the same day.

    • elements 101, 102 and 103 should retain their commonly accepted names mendelevium, nobelium, and lawrencium … 103 lawrencium Lr